Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can you explain why yesterday you said I was town and now I'm suspicious? What changed?
Your vote on someone who wasn't up for Lynch, the way you assume you are always the target when people are talking in the general sense, and your inactivity early game.
 
So there's 8 players left, 3 are mafia, likely no third party, so that leaves 5 town.

We knew from Oath's death that the maf wincon is to equal or outnumber the town.

If we end up lynching a town today, that leaves 4 town and then with their 2KP, they will bring it down to 2 town, therefore winning.

Please correct me if I'm in anyway wrong, because I could be, but this kinda sounds like-

oh Shawo posted all of this just before me lol gg. Anyway yeah I was gonna say isn't this basically lylo territory now?
Post automatically merged:

Your vote on someone who wasn't up for Lynch, the way you assume you are always the target when people are talking in the general sense, and your inactivity early game.
1. Inactivity in early game I don't feel counts. It was literally my first ever mafia game, you gotta allow for the fact that I was more lurking than contributing because I didn't know how to contribute at that point.
2. I talk in a general sense because I'm not confident in doing it any other way. I'm not confident in turning around and pointing out "this person said this therefore mafia" because I know 0 metas and have never done this before.
3. Which vote? I've only voted for Geoni who ended up lynched so far, and you can't say I voted a person who was 'never up for lynch' because you will notice that each time I've voted, my vote had been placed with the biggest voted at that time
 
Antonio, given the circumstances that we're in MYLO, we should probably agree on a lynch together? Or even just you?
I'm fairly content with my reads, knowing that Shae is third party basically locks my townreads in place, due to how the game is progressing.

This list of:
Harbour, glow, Trundle, tae + antonio
Means you're treating a 4 mafia pool as "Punchy/shawo/locket/dino", Given that I'm effectively clear, what you're saying is that "Since mafia has no reason to buss there, the mafia pool has to be Punchy/Locket/Dino"

However, Town actually has the same amount of ML's regardless of how many mafia got lynched yesterday, obviously they were unable to assume that Shae was getting modkilled.

So I would argue that there's no reason for mafia to not have bussed.

The long point I have coming is...

Tae is mafia.
Tae + Locket + 1 more.

I'm getting Tae lynched today, I'm sure locket will get turbolynched under glow/others after today, but better to do this now than never.
 
There's 9 people.

If we don't lynch mafia
6t - 3m
5 -3
3 - 3

then
2-3
or
3-2
2-2?

if we do Lynch
6-3
6-2
5-2

then
5-1
4-1

or

4-2
3-2
 
do NOT LYNCH ME

i am town but i have no way to make that obvious all i can say is DO NOT LYNCH ME
 
I counted 8 players instead of 9, but a mislynch today still ends with 3 town after the kills so same result of mad win
 
I'm kinda surprised that Shae flipped third party given the circumstances, and the fact that the third party is survivor means that most likely mafia had an additional night kill.

The issue with the Shea modkill is we're at 9 + 3 mafia, given the assumption that 3 mafia gets 2 kp.

Which means we're in MYLO.

if we lynch wrong we go to 6 + 3 mafia, and the game ends.

So we have to lynch mafia today. Effectively.
Like I mentioned, oath had a strongarm ability and was likely 1 kill on TOP of mafia KP, which explains that third kill N2 or N3 (I don't remember).
 
Please don't ask for my opinion on things, thanks.

Scum is obviously try to keep me alive for a reason because I'm an obvious liability for town.
 
Well. okay then.
Post automatically merged:

Lynching mafia today is the single most important thing town can do right now. Since it's mylo today, but if we lynch right we get an ML.

I'm likely going to ISO and just vote my strongest read, and if I'm wrong we lose, I guess.

Also, Evan. Your vote will probably be the single thing that stops a potential mafia blitz, so that's pretty nice.
 
Also, Tae isn't scum. Why would they vote for oath.

I would assume there would have been alot of hesitation between mafia on voting oath off due to how valuable his role is.
 
You don't think any of the three mafia at all bussed?

I'll check Oath's role again but it was three pretty subpar one-shot abilities I believe.
Post automatically merged:

Jack of all Trades: You are a Mafia Jack of all Trades. During the night phase, you have the choice of selecting between three 1-Shot abilities. These include: 1-Shot Roleblock, 1-Shot Doctor Protect, and 1-Shot Strongarm Kill. Each of these abilities may only be used once, and you may only select one ability per night.

So there's a roleblock, which was important but could have been used already, a doc and a strongarm.

So besides the roleblock, there's basically two completely useless abilities. (I'm still not sure why there's a doc).
I mean presumably Oath was useless at this point, with a bandwagon already starting, I'm sure AT least one mafia bussed.
 
Oath had roleblock, doctor protect and strongarm kill, 1 each.

I think the chances of bussing is high. Considering I'm currently up on the table for not voting Oath, basically, then it seems going for a fellow team member would be a way to avoid suspicion
 
Y'all being stupid, fr.

Oath has 3 abilities:
1. He can kill an extra person.
2. He can block a role.
3. He can protect a fellow member of his team.

He can do one of those abilities during the night. There is also another 1-2 3RD Party outhere.

Those abilities are valuable to scum, anything is valuable to scum compare to Mafia. Why would they risk voting off a valuable member, it's stupid...
 
Y'all being stupid, fr.

Oath has 3 abilities:
1. He can kill an extra person.
2. He can block a role.
3. He can protect a fellow member of his team.

He can do one of those abilities during the night. There is also another 1-2 3RD Party outhere.

Those abilities are valuable to scum, anything is valuable to scum compare to Mafia. Why would they risk voting off a valuable member, it's stupid...
in order to not come off as scum i bet one of them bussed oath
 
lynching me is a bad choice unless town wants to lose
Hey, at least you can take solace from the fact that if you really truly are town, then they all lose 'cause they doubted you. That's what I'm doing, anyway.

Anywho remember when I said I was tired and not staying long?
Back to bed I go
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top