-
In celebration of The Bell Tree's 20th birthday this week, we're hosting several activities and presentations about the community over this weekend. See the Twenty Years on The Bell Tree announcement for more details and good luck in the high-stakes raffles!
Mafia TBT Mafia ~ The Binding of Isaac ~ Town Wins!
- Thread starter Sataric
- Start date
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
care to explain ?!?!?!?!?!
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
don't have much of any reason huh Crys?
mother of all llamas
llamas <3
mother of all llamas's Creature:
I'll claim tomorrow and post my thoughts
I'm not doing right now for reasons I will say tomorrow
I'm not doing right now for reasons I will say tomorrow
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
omg.... do you have anything to say this is like your 5th post the whole game and you've had nothing to say.
mother of all llamas
llamas <3
mother of all llamas's Creature:
Well okay, I whipped some quick reads up for you, I'll elaborate further tomorrow
I am the Cain, I turned my Lucky Foot into Chocolate Milk, and I'm not saying until tomorrow if I have used it or not yet, for the sake of me surviving or not.
Oath- Pretty confirmed town in my option, unless he has somewhat manipulated everyone into thinking he's town but I highly doubt that. I think he should lead for tomorrow in my opinion.
Panda- Very similar playstyle to all her other games as town, I feel like she is my strongest town read for now. Victim is a relatively easy claim, as such with Cory did, but I'm still inclined to trust her. Slightest chance Dolby bussed her but I'm not sure. "I actually feel like Panda is town, unlike quite a few of you, even though I haven't been seen her as scum. Most noob scum try to lay back and be non-confrontational, but panda isn't doing that. Not that certain aspects of her posts and nitpickyness aren't scummy to some people, but it's normal behavior for her)"- Dolby.
Doughssant/Heyden- I am leaning towards town due to what other people have said about his meta and such. A lot of his posts seem to be filler or spam, and to me it looks like he's exclaiming his opinions freely. I don't think he is scum but there's a slimmest chance he could be since the no save on night 2 seemed pretty off to me.
M3ow- Made a strong case on Jacob and Ness (who flipped mafia), which has makes me believe Jacob is scum. Meow is very pro-town, like in other games she has participated in. Could still be 3rd party but I don't really see it.
Jacob- Last game as scum it didn't seem to me he tried as hard as this game, but is definitely more defensive. Claimed to be hit by bomb. Claiming to be bomb hit would be a very risky action to choose to do, but out of everyone right now, I think he is our best lynch
Crys- Unsure, claimed Judas/Cop, I'd like to hear her reports as I can't seem to find them?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Alexi- Has a huge suspicions against me because of my inactivity and I can understand why, as in the last game Rune made it right to the end without saying anything. Not sure what to think of her either.
- - - Post Merge - - -
a few format errors ^^;;
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
@Oath i never defended Cory, i just personally wanted to lynch Jacob more, same as you wanted the Cory lynch more.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
Alright. So, here's my thoughts. I'm very likely to die tonight. Doughssant/Hayden being doctor is very iffy as to whether or not her protection on me will go through since Sloth is still in play.
Current Playlist and Claims
You'll notice two differently colored names on the list. Our last two scum are hiding in mother of all llamas and Panda1376.
Why mother of all llamas is Scum or Third-Party: By Oathy Oathington
Alright, so. First, we shall start with some gut reactions to her posts in isolation.
This was her reaction to the Night One deaths. Interesting that you address the two blue roles that died as "overpowered". A running theme with Cory was that he claimed that town had too many blue roles and was OP. Interesting.
She promised to be more active on the weekend, yet wasn't. Granted, it was Easter weekend so I can't be too judgmental on this.
This is a fair point that you address on Daniel's post above yours. The thing is on this, you are not a partner with m3ow, so I can't accuse you of defending a scum partner.
Also interesting that you admit you're still going to be inactive.
Why haven't you been modkilled, for that matter? I wonder if it's because you're the last Sin or Horror and Sataric doesn't want to end your party's chance of winning.
That's weird. There's no reason to not say whether or not you'll be using it or not. It's not like you're a target, unless if you do end up using it, and Sloth somehow ends up redirecting the mafia kill onto you, thus resulting in their kill being stopped.
The thing is, I don't believe this. You've been cagey this entire game. You didn't want to claim your role after everyone else, and you still don't want to tell us whether you've used your item. My guess is that you're mafia or third-party, got the teleporter, and stole the Chocolate Milk from Daniel in order to try and claim Cain. This is a very risky thing for her to do, so if Jacob could tell is if he still has his Chocolate Milk or not, that would be very helpful.
Why Panda1376 is Scum or Third-Party: By Oathy Oathington
Panda has been very very strange as of recently. But let's go back.
Why is it that scum this game seems to all have been looking at Sarasa, Rune, and Daniel as anti-town?
Fascinating that you think he was "sincere" with "genuine mistakes". at 2:19AM on March 28th, yet 12 hours later around 3:00PM March 28th, she suddenly switches over to "Jacob is scum" with lines such as the following:
She also had me read as very very town.
Until I started pushing for Cory, when she suddenly started doubting me as town.
You may not been explicitly been defending Cory but you were implicitly defending him.
A Reminder Going Forward
Night Three is giving us 6 town, 1 mafia, 1 third party (6/1/1). To reiterate,
If Mafia hits Third-party, then we go into Day 4 as 6/1. Very good position.
If Mafia hits Town, then we go into Day 4 as 5/1/1. Not as good as them hitting third-party, but it still does mean that we have a higher chance of lynching anti-town tomorrow.
If we have a successful protection, then this means that we go into Day 4 as 6/1/1.
A redirect or unsuccessful protection just results in one of the above.
TL;DR
Lynch Mother of All Llamas and Panda1376. Panda1376 is likely to be the mafia member and should probably take priority.
Current Playlist and Claims
- doughssant - Doctor / Magdalane - Protected Ayaya N1, no action N2
- Panda1376 - Townie / Victim
- Alexi - Townie / Victim
- Oath2order - Vigilante / Samson - Shot Runeraider N1, Daggered Dolby D2, Shot Lucanosa N2, Item stolen by Cory on N2, removed from game upon Cory's lynch.
- mother of all llamas - Item Cloner / Cain
- m3ow_ - Townie / Victim
- Jacob - Veteran / Guppy the Cat - Apparently received Bomb which exploded on him N2.
- Crys - Self-Aware Miller+Granny / Judas - Used Book of Belial N2.
You'll notice two differently colored names on the list. Our last two scum are hiding in mother of all llamas and Panda1376.
Why mother of all llamas is Scum or Third-Party: By Oathy Oathington
Alright, so. First, we shall start with some gut reactions to her posts in isolation.
This was her reaction to the Night One deaths. Interesting that you address the two blue roles that died as "overpowered". A running theme with Cory was that he claimed that town had too many blue roles and was OP. Interesting.
She promised to be more active on the weekend, yet wasn't. Granted, it was Easter weekend so I can't be too judgmental on this.
This is a fair point that you address on Daniel's post above yours. The thing is on this, you are not a partner with m3ow, so I can't accuse you of defending a scum partner.
Also interesting that you admit you're still going to be inactive.
Why haven't you been modkilled, for that matter? I wonder if it's because you're the last Sin or Horror and Sataric doesn't want to end your party's chance of winning.
That's weird. There's no reason to not say whether or not you'll be using it or not. It's not like you're a target, unless if you do end up using it, and Sloth somehow ends up redirecting the mafia kill onto you, thus resulting in their kill being stopped.
The thing is, I don't believe this. You've been cagey this entire game. You didn't want to claim your role after everyone else, and you still don't want to tell us whether you've used your item. My guess is that you're mafia or third-party, got the teleporter, and stole the Chocolate Milk from Daniel in order to try and claim Cain. This is a very risky thing for her to do, so if Jacob could tell is if he still has his Chocolate Milk or not, that would be very helpful.
Why Panda1376 is Scum or Third-Party: By Oathy Oathington
Panda has been very very strange as of recently. But let's go back.
Why is it that scum this game seems to all have been looking at Sarasa, Rune, and Daniel as anti-town?
Fascinating that you think he was "sincere" with "genuine mistakes". at 2:19AM on March 28th, yet 12 hours later around 3:00PM March 28th, she suddenly switches over to "Jacob is scum" with lines such as the following:
She also had me read as very very town.
Until I started pushing for Cory, when she suddenly started doubting me as town.
You may not been explicitly been defending Cory but you were implicitly defending him.
A Reminder Going Forward
Night Three is giving us 6 town, 1 mafia, 1 third party (6/1/1). To reiterate,
If Mafia hits Third-party, then we go into Day 4 as 6/1. Very good position.
If Mafia hits Town, then we go into Day 4 as 5/1/1. Not as good as them hitting third-party, but it still does mean that we have a higher chance of lynching anti-town tomorrow.
If we have a successful protection, then this means that we go into Day 4 as 6/1/1.
A redirect or unsuccessful protection just results in one of the above.
TL;DR
Lynch Mother of All Llamas and Panda1376. Panda1376 is likely to be the mafia member and should probably take priority.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
My suggestion is Panda because llamas might be modkilled if she don't vote. Also Panda is probably the more likely mafia member. Eliminates night kills
oath2order
#Porygon2024
I'm fully expecting to die tomorrow by either mafia killing me or Sloth redirecting the mafia kill onto me out of pure luck. So.
Jacob and Crys: I really have no clue what exactly happened on the night Minties died, but I somehow trust both of your claims. There was likely some ****ery that probably involved the Sloth. I trust both your claims given how suspicious Panda and mother look. Don't worry about each other or fall for distractions trying to figure out what happened.
Doughssant: I'm trusting you'll protect yourself tonight just to be on the safe side. Don't answer this, Sloth might get involved.
Townies: please vote Panda first then mother of all llamas the next day.
Panda: well played.
Jacob and Crys: I really have no clue what exactly happened on the night Minties died, but I somehow trust both of your claims. There was likely some ****ery that probably involved the Sloth. I trust both your claims given how suspicious Panda and mother look. Don't worry about each other or fall for distractions trying to figure out what happened.
Doughssant: I'm trusting you'll protect yourself tonight just to be on the safe side. Don't answer this, Sloth might get involved.
Townies: please vote Panda first then mother of all llamas the next day.
Panda: well played.
Jacob
Senior Member
@Oath the chocolate milk-
I did not use it for myself, I'm practically townie now without my night life.
I gave it to someone else, but I don't want to say who (claimed town member). It would be a shame if they got killed when because I told scum who has it.
They can claim that they have it tomorrow, and if I survive, I'll tell you if they dont
- - - Post Merge - - -
also, couldn't there still be a scum member among the "claimed" townies?? That's an easy role to claim.
Let's not let M3ow_ and Alexi under our radar just yet
I did not use it for myself, I'm practically townie now without my night life.
I gave it to someone else, but I don't want to say who (claimed town member). It would be a shame if they got killed when because I told scum who has it.
They can claim that they have it tomorrow, and if I survive, I'll tell you if they dont
- - - Post Merge - - -
also, couldn't there still be a scum member among the "claimed" townies?? That's an easy role to claim.
Let's not let M3ow_ and Alexi under our radar just yet
