Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[Jeremy]

I mean elves!

 

[oath2order]

It had to have been Mafia, if it were not a Vigilante. At first I was convinced it was a Vigilante who shot me to try to get me out of the way for Town / confirm my role.

The thing is, I was inspected last night. Which didn't make sense to me & got me to ask in the first place whether I was hit by a Vigilante or not. Why would people have a Vigilante shoot at me & have a Detective inspect me on the same night.

> implying that the vigilante and detective are in contact with each other.

I mean, either way, you're town, we know this now.

By the way, gurl get on IRC we miss you. Justin said you're unbanned.

Can you explain why it wasn't a SK? I am confused about that.

By the way if two people were protected does that mean two doctors?

God damn it I keep forgetting about the SKs.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Can you explain why it wasn't a SK? I am confused about that.

By the way if two people were protected does that mean two doctors?

I know who the two vigilante's hit and the mafia clearly didn't hit their own member, therefore the SK hit Karla.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean elves!

Yes, that does mean there would be two elves, as far as we know. (Or a mafia doctor saving a town role?)

 

[Jeremy]

I doubt mafia would protect town. I don't see any benefits.

How do you know who the vig hit? Are you talking with them?

 

[iLoveYou]

Can you explain why it wasn't a SK? I am confused about that.

By the way if two people were protected does that mean two doctors?

I am a Veteran. =P Which means I have two Night lives. One was used up last night. <|3 Trundle also explained why the SK possibly did not target me.

By the way I would like to bring the following up against Blu Rose:

- Day One: Is very curious what my colour is. He does not ask for my role, rather wants to know whether I am blue or not. I confess I am blue.

- Night One: I get shot at by Mafia.

- Day Two: Immediately, Blu Rose runs to me to ask me if it'll make him look bad that I got shot at when I told him I was a blue role.

I told no one about this PM exchange. I was yelling in the thread that I was a Veteran, but I'm sure the Mafia didn't believe me for one second. All they knew is that I was Town & I was NOT willing to get lynched. This makes it obvious that I could be an important blue role in their eyes if Blu Rose had any part in this. But nope, I guess everyone knows now I am a simple Veteran since Trundle said he got protected. C:

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

I know who the two vigilante's hit and the mafia clearly didn't hit their own member, therefore the SK hit Karla.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Yes, that does mean there would be two elves, as far as we know. (Or a mafia doctor saving a town role?)

Wait theres 2 doctors? Who was the second person saved?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kayla posted my reasoning. Kayla was vet. So technically we only have one doctor we know and thats teh one that saved trundle

 

[EpicGamer12]

Wait theres 2 doctors? Who was the second person saved?

iLoveYou and I were both saved. (As mentioned 4+ times haha)

 

[iLoveYou]

Blu Rose is also in contact with Beary509 as it's made obvious in the thread. It is very likely that one of them is Mafia if information is being tossed between them.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Oh um yeah sorry Kayla is veteran, not two doctors, my bad

 

[Jeremy]

Makes sense I guess, but how do you know who was targeted by vigilantes, Trundle?

 

[iLoveYou]

Makes sense I guess, but how do you know who was targeted by vigilantes, Trundle?

We like to keep Town on a "Need-To-Know" basis. Why do you need to know? Or are you just curious?

 

[EpicGamer12]

Makes sense I guess, but how do you know who was targeted by vigilantes, Trundle?

I do but I'm reluctant to share for various reasons. In this case it's not safe to share it right now, although that may change later. As a townie I have my head/reason and my vote, so I have to be quite careful what I say to who. It's especially less safe to speak about such matters on the public thread, because it will add a whole new layer to the game if the mafia know this information.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

So who are possible lynch candidates?
ILoveYou pointed at Blue Rose
Quite a few of us are pointing at River
And it seems we've just dropped all suspicions on Beary

 

[Jeremy]

We like to keep Town on a "Need-To-Know" basis. Why do you need to know? Or are you just curious?

Trying to figure out who everyone is talking to, if anyone is lying, etc.

 

[Blu Rose]

By the way I would like to bring the following up against Blu Rose:

- Day One: Is very curious what my colour is. He does not ask for my role, rather wants to know whether I am blue or not. I confess I am blue.
I wasn't very curious. I was just, simply, curious, as I had cultivated suspicions against you being the Serial Killer, which came out of the blue.
No pun intended.

- Night One: I get shot at by Mafia.

- Day Two: Immediately, Blu Rose runs to me to ask me if it'll make him look bad that I got shot at when I told him I was a blue role.
Immediately is a bit of a stretch...
More like an hour.

I told no one about this PM exchange. I was yelling in the thread that I was a Veteran, but I'm sure the Mafia didn't believe me for one second. All they knew is that I was Town & I was NOT willing to get lynched. This makes it obvious that I could be an important blue role in their eyes if Blu Rose had any part in this. But nope, I guess everyone knows now I am a simple Veteran since Trundle said he got protected. C:

If you always claim Veteran, why should we trust your claim in this area?

Blu Rose is also in contact with Beary509 as it's made obvious in the thread. It is very likely that one of them is Mafia if information is being tossed between them.

Obviously.
But, how does this mean that it is likely that one of us is Mafia?

Oh, and sorry for lying to you, Trundle, about being "in cahoots" with beary.

 

[Superpenguin]

If you always claim Veteran, why should we trust your claim in this area?

How many times does Kayla need to say she was rolechecked last night?

 

[Ashtot]

If you always claim Veteran, why should we trust your claim in this area?



Obviously.
But, how does this mean that it is likely that one of us is Mafia?

Oh, and sorry for lying to you, Trundle, about being "in cahoots" with beary.

That was me you were talking to. You aren't making this any easier for yourself.

 

[EpicGamer12]

And it seems we've just dropped all suspicions on Beary

Not quite. Even though I haven't posted recently I'm still very suspicious of beary509 but I'm not ready to make a case at the moment. If I do, it will likely be Day 3.
Also, I am supporting the Blu Rose lynch today, so I'm going to put my vote in on the that. I, as well, have suspicions of Blu Rose, and from what I've seen, Blu Rose has been searching around for blue roles (blu rolses lel) all game. Not even their roles, just whether or not they're blue. Doesn't this scream mafia to you? What else would he need it for? He's not trying to bring up any other conversation in these cases, just whether or not they're blue.

 

[oath2order]

If you always claim Veteran, why should we trust your claim in this area?

The fact that she was rolechecked and also says she was targeted but survived the night kind of confirms it.

 

[Blu Rose]

Not quite. Even though I haven't posted recently I'm still very suspicious of beary509 but I'm not ready to make a case at the moment. If I do, it will likely be Day 3.
Also, I am supporting the Blu Rose lynch today, so I'm going to put my vote in on the that. I, as well, have suspicions of Blu Rose, and from what I've seen, Blu Rose has been searching around for blue roles (blu rolses lel) all game. Not even their roles, just whether or not they're blue. Doesn't this scream mafia to you? What else would he need it for? He's not trying to bring up any other conversation in these cases, just whether or not they're blue.

Not all game, but I did have suspicions of Kayla being the Serial Killer Day 1, as she was desparate not to get lynched, and this was a big behavioral change, as some people pointed out.
Yes, now that I think about it, it does scream Mafia to me.
Y'know, I guess I'm in full support for a lynch against me today, too. If you really think I'm Mafia, then maybe it will really help you all that I go off and die.
But, I can assure you, it most likely won't.