• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

But what is the point in lying to the confirmed town if you don't want to get lynched? You're best bet to stay alive would be to talk to them.

Which is why we are pressuring you right now, Blu Rose. There is no way we are 100% sure you are Mafia, which means some of us still think you are Town aligned in contact with a red player. Beary509 should also be put up as a lynch candidate ( sowwy Maddy. <3 ;~; ).

If Town has any other names to bring forward, please do. We will not ignore any other names and would rather have more than just Blu Rose or Beary509 up for lynching today.

Your PM exchanges with Beary509 explain too much of what happened on Night One through the Mafia's actions. I don't know how much of it is a coincidence.
 
Beary509:

1) Did you think Superpenguin was a Serial Killer? What did you do with that information?

2) What did you do with other information that was given to you (About me, Trundle & You)?

3) Are you in contact with anyone else besides Blu Rose?
 
But what is the point in lying to the confirmed town if you don't want to get lynched? You're best bet to stay alive would be to talk to them.

But there is no confirmed town.
I'm not saying I doubt her, but, in all seriousness, she could be lying. Unless, of course, the DT steps up, which is NOT a wise move.
Or, Mafia could have fakeclaimed to have checked her.
Just looking at things from all viewpoints here.

So those people you PM'ed Trundle and Kayla were actually in contact with you? Can you please say what you were discussing with each of them?

Don't bother ripping apart posts at this point. Your main goal right now is to avoid getting lynched and getting all that you know out to town if you can't avoid it.

If I remember right, you were one of them.

I PM'ed You (user), you (SP), Oath, Kayla, and Trundle about it. And, of course, beary.

Lastly...
Too late on the ripping apart posts. : )

Beary509:

1) Did you think Superpenguin was a Serial Killer? What did you do with that information?

2) What did you do with other information that was given to you (About me, Trundle & You)?

3) Are you in contact with anyone else besides Blu Rose?

She is at school now...
PST.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, in the first paragraph, I was talking about Kayla.

- - - Post Merge - - -

But what is the point in lying to the confirmed town if you don't want to get lynched? You're best bet to stay alive would be to talk to them.

Okay, might as well respond to this directly...

Trundle and You are not confirmed Town.
I am talking to you, Kayla, beary (not right now), and oath.
All you are doing is reprimanding me for being a horrible Townie, saying I need to find some way to improve.
 
Holy shizmuffins.

Karla? Wow...

slowpoke_pokemon.jpg
 
Prin

Was this really a defense for Prin?
Prin is a terrible lynch. A new player who vote switched once (in the early stages of voting) is not a reason for a lynch.
Or, defending a fellow Mafioso?

I am the unspoken person pointing a finger to Blu Rose. If scum are scared of standing out, wanting to go unnoticed, why am I doing this instead of just lurking? Aren't mafia supposed to stay away and try to avoid posting? Aren't I doing the exact opposite? If I was mafia, I would probably be the same. Being a new player may make me suspicious, because you aren't exactly 100% certain how I play. But I think you need a little more evidence before you start lynching me. You'll probably be lynching Town.
Prin was definitely not unspoken. Outspoken, maybe, but not unspoken.
Prin posted in here not half an hour ago.
Now, if s/he is doing anything, s/he is lurking. Avoiding suspicion. Being inactive, to put it simply. Not drawing attention to him/herself.

Now, the posts that I am about to bring up, at first sight, did not look like evidence to me.
But, if we look at them compared to each other...
I did change after what people posted of Dolby. I know I changed my mind twice, but still. What does that have to do about beary? I didn't bandwagon, I read posts and changed my mind.
Also, I cant drop a suspicion.
Prin stated that s/he changed his/her vote after what people posted about Dolby, who, may I note, the Godfather started. But, s/he also then turned around and said that s/he could not drop a suspicion.

Contradiction, right?

Also, I know Prin is a new player, but, so was Fanous in MM II. He slid by because everyone did not know his playstyle, and such.

I know Oath is not on my suspicions list, but...
Karla expressed his opinion on Dolby (RIP), who should SERIOUSLY CONSIDER STOPPING ROLECLAIMING IN HiS USERTITLE:
In fact, I'd rather lynch Dolby for being a toxic anti-town force with the bs he keeps pulling ever game.
If I remember right, did not Oath jump on this rather quickly?
6 scum roles, only 5 scum players. I also think that having 4 or all 5 power scum roles would be a little much, so we're probably looking at a Godfather, roleblocker, framer and two goons. Naturally be wary of there being a suicide bomber and avoid stacking obvious actions on a single player.
I'm betting that this is what we are actually not facing.
I'm thinking we are looking at a Roleblocker, Framer, Goon, and, lastly, a Mafioso Doctor, now that the Godfather is dead. But, I can not be sure, as I'm not Mafia.

And then you pull a vote for Blu Rose out of your ass? Where did this come from? Because Prin said he was aggressive and therefore suspicious? The very same reason I addressed in my "filler" post that you just slammed. You seem to be playing directly against me already this game, why is that?
The above kind of puts my situation with Kayla into a confirmed Town, as Karla did attack Kayla.
Note that I just noticed that.

For my pardoning words, I do not usually use PMs when playing Mafia. I only use them to share evidence with people I don't want to post publicly, but, this game, absolutely nothing has gone according to "plan."
Note that "plan" is used for lack of a better word.

Oh my God, finally...
 
One of the reasons I've been inactive on this thread is because of school, and I check back occasionally. I'll probably post my defense later.
^
Also, what does me posting in a different thread have to do with this?
 
Prin

Was this really a defense for Prin?
Or, maybe she was stating the truth. In that case, me switching my vote once was a terrible idea for a lynch.
Or, defending a fellow Mafioso?


Prin was definitely not unspoken. Outspoken, maybe, but not unspoken.
Prin posted in here not half an hour ago.
Now, if s/he is doing anything, s/he is lurking. Avoiding suspicion. Being inactive, to put it simply. Not drawing attention to him/herself.
I stay in school from 7AM to 4PM. And my car broke down, so there is another hour. Again, what does me posting in another thread have to do with this? Must I post every single time I check this thread?
Now, the posts that I am about to bring up, at first sight, did not look like evidence to me.
But, if we look at them compared to each other...


Prin stated that s/he changed his/her vote after what people posted about Dolby, who, may I note, the Godfather started. But, s/he also then turned around and said that s/he could not drop a suspicion.


It was pointless. It wasn'g going to happen anyway.
Contradiction, right?

Also, I know Prin is a new player, but, so was Fanous in MM II. He slid by because everyone did not know his playstyle, and such.

I know Oath is not on my suspicions list, but...
Karla expressed his opinion on Dolby (RIP), who should SERIOUSLY CONSIDER STOPPING ROLECLAIMING IN HiS USERTITLE:

If I remember right, did not Oath jump on this rather quickly?
I'm betting that this is what we are actually not facing.
I'm thinking we are looking at a Roleblocker, Framer, Goon, and, lastly, a Mafioso Doctor, now that the Godfather is dead. But, I can not be sure, as I'm not Mafia.


The above kind of puts my situation with Kayla into a confirmed Town, as Karla did attack Kayla.
Note that I just noticed that.

For my pardoning words, I do not usually use PMs when playing Mafia. I only use them to share evidence with people I don't want to post publicly, but, this game, absolutely nothing has gone according to "plan."
Note that "plan" is used for lack of a better word.

Oh my God, finally...


I think you are just eager to point fingers at somebody to draw attention from yourself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Great strategy, bro. I think I put enough information to go against your suspicion.
As of right now, I think I will ##VOTE: Blu Rose. Not because he pointed fingers at me, but I agree with most of the things already posted. Posting them again will be pointless.
 
One of the reasons I've been inactive on this thread is because of school, and I check back occasionally. I'll probably post my defense later.
^
Also, what does me posting in a different thread have to do with this?

Its mainly just the fact that you are active on the forums but on mafia rich would raise some mild red flags seeing as how a lot is going down and you're just nowhere to be found, especially when you were a bit outspoken earlier in the game. But if you're not mafia you shouldn't have much to worry about.

Whats really getting to me is everyones excuse with school for reason of inactivity. I have school too and I was just about the only one to mention it being a problem before the game started. Now fast forward to middle of the game when everyone is getting accused and the defense is posting "sorry I had school". It could really be your genuine excuse and I'm not saying it isn't but just address it before the game starts so that everyone knows why you're being inactive.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*but not on mafia which*

i need to proofread my posts more.
 
Its mainly just the fact that you are active on the forums but on mafia rich would raise some mild red flags seeing as how a lot is going down and you're just nowhere to be found, especially when you were a bit outspoken earlier in the game. But if you're not mafia you shouldn't have much to worry about.

Whats really getting to me is everyones excuse with school for reason of inactivity. I have school too and I was just about the only one to mention it being a problem before the game started. Now fast forward to middle of the game when everyone is getting accused and the defense is posting "sorry I had school". It could really be your genuine excuse and I'm not saying it isn't but just address it before the game starts so that everyone knows why you're being inactive.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*but not on mafia which*

i need to proofread my posts more.

I wasn't in school when the game started, I was on break. If it wasn't for school, I probably would have posted more, no doubt. I know school is a common excuse, but it's still somewhat of a problem. I had to read through one whole page of posting after I got home >.< that's just how much I missed.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^ also I've only made two post on the forums outside of mafia today.
 
-_-
You know, I'm providing factual evidence to back up my claims.

Well, I guess dying Town will be fun.
Good luck, Town!

It's not factual evidence and if you keep saying "WELL I GUESS I'M DYING TOWN! OH WELL!" you probably will. I'm sure at this point people will start to consider lynching you just for being annoying.
 
I think you are just eager to point fingers at somebody to draw attention from yourself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Great strategy, bro. I think I put enough information to go against your suspicion.
As of right now, I think I will ##VOTE: Blu Rose. Not because he pointed fingers at me, but I agree with most of the things already posted. Posting them again will be pointless.

That's not pointing fingers. That's making an accusation and backing it up with evidence. And did have you on his suspicion list before his name was brought to the table for lynch candidate. Plus, he wasn't even going to post much, people encouraged him to make an effort. Here and here.
 
I know I was on his suspicion list, and he did have evidence. Not evidence that could put up that big of a case against me though.


You know you people are really working my brain... I'm younger than 95% of you. Eh, at least I'm having fun doing it. That's what I signed up for this for... one thing that would have helped me if I used better terms than the people do in my class >.<

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, Blu, why don't you put up a defense instead of just going with it? Aren't you going to at least put up a fight than just give in?
 
I think you are just eager to point fingers at somebody to draw attention from yourself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Great strategy, bro. I think I put enough information to go against your suspicion.
As of right now, I think I will ##VOTE: Blu Rose. Not because he pointed fingers at me, but I agree with most of the things already posted. Posting them again will be pointless.
Exactly what I thought :/ Right when I saw a red name in Blu's post, I knew he was getting desperate.
 
It's not factual evidence and if you keep saying "WELL I GUESS I'M DYING TOWN! OH WELL!" you probably will. I'm sure at this point people will start to consider lynching you just for being annoying.

Okay, what about it is not factual?
Please, point this out, oh wise one.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Did I not say I would rip apart people's posts?
 
Back
Top