I'm with Jer on this. If he wasn't confirmed last night then there would be a case against him led by the detectives/associates of the detectives. Jer has to be who he says he is or he wouldn't have put himself in a position to be inspected. Jer claimed a blue roll to me and to the rest of his group and I'm sure that after the detectives did their inspections on him he returned a blue roll to them as well. Since there isn't a case against Jer and he didn't return back as Bushi, he can't be scum or hiding behind the Godfather roll. Jer right now is the single most trusted person in the game so I don't know why SP wouldn't want to claim to him, especially if his roll could help the town.
Mafia TBT Mafia X: The Honnō-ji Incident [Game Over/Town Win]
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
I'm with Jer on this. If he wasn't confirmed last night then there would be a case against him led by the detectives/associates of the detectives. Jer has to be who he says he is or he wouldn't have put himself in a position to be inspected. Jer claimed a blue roll to me and to the rest of his group and I'm sure that after the detectives did their inspections on him he returned a blue roll to them as well. Since there isn't a case against Jer and he didn't return back as Bushi, he can't be scum or hiding behind the Godfather roll. Jer right now is the single most trusted person in the game so I don't know why SP wouldn't want to claim to him, especially if his roll could help the town.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
The problem is, Godfather can choose what they return as so there's still the small chance Jer is the godfather.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Quick thing though, Lunatic's a girl
Other than that, yeah, I'd like some clearing up on this discrepancy.
Oh yeah, I was thinking about Supernatural where I had to choose one of two choices of Town (non blue) only =/
You idiot that's our last cat...
Let me put everything I know about SP on the table then. He claimed Bushi (Vanilla Town) to Lunatic, as well as a few other people. And I'm now realizing there must be more than one because my little birds informed me that he created a separate IRC channel called BushiIRC or something. He is inviting people who claim Bushi to him. So by claiming to be leader of the Bushis he's role claiming Bushi to all of these people. I've noticed a lot of people are claiming Bushi in this game, which makes sense, but why would someone go to such lengths unless they are trying to pull information from them? Also, I know all of the blue roles besides veteran and he's none of them. Why would he even refuse to claim to me if he is vanilla townie? That's bizarre. So SP, if you are the vet, kindly PM me and I won't ask someone to shoot you or push for this lynch. Otherwise, please explain what the heck you are trying to do.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
cat???? wwhaaa
Still though, wouldn't it have made sense for Trundle NOT to give Jer the names to the detectives so that when they inspected him he could tell who the detectives were and then PM them? It would be pretty stupid for Trundle (who most likely had the detectives roll claim to him but not sure, they might not have) or the detectives to say "Hey I'm/they're detective and will be inspecting you tonight". They would have had to keep the rolls a secret to confirm Jer, in which they must have done because there isn't a case against him and Godfather can't see rolls against him.
Firstly, I just want to note that if the general pulse of the town is that we strongly suspect both Alise and SuperPenguin to be evil roles, then eliminating SP first would make a lot of sense since it has been mentioned that he is more likely that he's the cultist, and since he is the stronger player out of the two. Using the Ronin to eliminate both is a decent enough proposal but the power that the Ronin possess is incredibly powerful and can only be used once, so the longer we can safely delay putting it to use, the better.
Personally, I must speak up against Farobi though - I felt that his post a few pages back was a very weak defense. Essentially he seemed upset that so many of us had called him out and asked him to participate in the game, even though it must've taken him nearly 50 pages or something before he finally contributed with something remotely useful. I get strong scummy vibes from him and think he's more than just a bored Townie - I think he's active in scum chat since he's clearly active on other parts of TBT, and just trying to slip by for as long as possible. He would've been my first pick for today's lynch, but if the rest of you disagree then I am perfectly okay with eliminating either SP or Alise as well.
Oh, and Jeremy, do you already know my role? PM me if you don't, and we'll have a chat! Cheers.
Personally, I must speak up against Farobi though - I felt that his post a few pages back was a very weak defense. Essentially he seemed upset that so many of us had called him out and asked him to participate in the game, even though it must've taken him nearly 50 pages or something before he finally contributed with something remotely useful. I get strong scummy vibes from him and think he's more than just a bored Townie - I think he's active in scum chat since he's clearly active on other parts of TBT, and just trying to slip by for as long as possible. He would've been my first pick for today's lynch, but if the rest of you disagree then I am perfectly okay with eliminating either SP or Alise as well.
Oh, and Jeremy, do you already know my role? PM me if you don't, and we'll have a chat! Cheers.
No, look back a bit. She voiced suspicions on me going off of how my reads were safe and mostly unoriginal.
- - - Post Merge - - -
edit: he* LOLWHOOPS.
He's created his own IRC channel before with people, I think in Weaboo mafia or something, he had a team tots channel.
I disagree with most of the candidates up for lynch today. Everyone is looking at evidence without any context. If we take a look at past behaviour of each person up for consideration you'll find that it's highly likely none of them are scum, and they're just playing the only way they know how. They don't have the kind of experience that some of us do, that goes for Karen too. If Karen had been playing as long as some of us, she would have understood what Karla was saying. What I find most people don't do is put the situations people are in and analyze their posts through the right context. Someone who isn't as experienced in the game will almost always sound scummy compared to others. This is something very crucial that people don't take into enough consideration.
The only people I would even consider lynching right now would be Farobi, MissNoodle, PurplPanda, or Superpenguin, as they've proven so far that they either don't do anything, or have no intention of helping town.
The only people I would even consider lynching right now would be Farobi, MissNoodle, PurplPanda, or Superpenguin, as they've proven so far that they either don't do anything, or have no intention of helping town.
So he's role claiming and allying to tons of people other than the confirmed mayor.
