Mafia TBT Mafia XIII: XCOM: Enemy Within (End Game - Town Wins!)

[Minties]

This is true.

Can I ask why you're suspicious of me? I'd rather you just grow a pair and out me in the thread with reasoning so I can respond to you instead of being shady in PMs.

Aye - I mentioned a few names before but I really think that MewMew is acting completely out of character this game. She has not been very active and she's not been responding to the PM I sent her, but she HAS been online on TBT overall. Furthermore, I called ShinySandwich out repeatedly some pages back, and they responded to me quickly - But they gave me an incredibly poor defense, and then continued posting in other threads on TBT rather than actively participate in the conversation I was trying to start up with them. Both of these players could certainly be scum trying to slip by for a while.

As for the stronger players, they're always harder to read - Yui Z has not spoken much yet but she recently stepped in to replace Amaze, so we'll have to give her some time. And it would be nice to hear a little bit more from Minties, about whom they find suspicious, though the posts they've made so far has been solid. Both Tina and MissNoodle obviously trusted Oath and then ended up dead, but Tina told me that she was convinced Oath was innocent - Why would he kill her if she didn't suspect him at all, if he was scum?

Hi, I am usually more vocal in mafia games because I didnt have a job. I now work full time and get home when you all are asleep. It's 5:30am and I'm about to leave for work, I'll be home in about 9 hours to properly respond on a computer.

 

[f11]

There are also others, Crystal came into my head first. Another name is LittleBeary, I'd like to see you post more of substance.

Hi.
On Aerious- They said the same exact thing about being culted in MGM. She complained to me in irc once. In the beginning of most games she has played with pms, she roleclaims early on. If she was in 3rd party or mafia she'd have a group of people to tell her role to.

Mewx3: In the begginning of games she is a bit more energetic and tries to make plans. I don't know if she's busy or not but I'd like to hear her thoughts.

Oath- When Oath is scum he is usually quieter and tries to build a lot of trust. He was perfectly open to share his pm with Noodle. Him not killing blues doesn't necessarily make him not scum.

Capella- The second person to talk to Noodle. More of a newbie player, I'd expect them to kill a blue if they roleclaimed to them. They popped in to post a chat screenshot but it looked like it wasn't the whole thing. If no other lynch canidates come up, I'd be willing to vote for them.

 

[CookingOkasan]

What do you mean not safe? You aren't safe anymore because you won't defend yourself.

^^^

also Ashton could you quote Mew on that?

 

[Ashtot]

Can I ask why you're suspicious of me? I'd rather you just grow a pair and out me in the thread with reasoning so I can respond to you instead of being shady in PMs.



Hi, I am usually more vocal in mafia games because I didnt have a job. I now work full time and get home when you all are asleep. It's 5:30am and I'm about to leave for work, I'll be home in about 9 hours to properly respond on a computer.

Mainly because you just reiterated everything Tina posted, but I mean I understand that you're busy, so it would make a little bit of sense that you would post less and do less.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^^^

also Ashton could you quote Mew on that?

One second.

 

[8floor]

I just wanted to point out that Mewmewmewm soft-claimed a blue role early on in the game, and most of you seemed to have somehow missed it. I'm not trying to point this out to scum or anything, but I think it's something we need to consider. I PM'd her about 2 hours ago and haven't gotten a response. People are finding her scummy so I figured I'd point this out.

could be blue, could be red, or could be distraction.
we will just have to wait and see what she says for herself.

 

[Superpenguin]

could be blue, could be red, or could be distraction.
we will just have to wait and see what she says for herself.

>stating obvious information
>leaves out third-party
>just why?

 

[Ashtot]

could be blue, could be red, or could be distraction.
we will just have to wait and see what she says for herself.

WAhh what.
Where.
How.
Who.
When.
Why.
Okay, i just got my role and i swear i'm already confused XD i'll go back to re read everything. Aparently Fleorena is dead so RIP.
I GOTTA CATCH UPPPPPP

This.

 

[8floor]

>stating obvious information
>leaves out third-party
>just why?

did not think there was a complex enough role in exalt, based on what mewmew said before.

 

[ShinySandwich]

I already did, i don't post that much, i don't want to accuse people without being 100% sure they are mafia

 

[8floor]

also, i am headed out for a while, see you guys later (;

 

[Geoni]

I already did, i don't post that much, i don't want to accuse people without being 100% sure they are mafia

No, you really haven't defended yourself.

 

[Yui Z]

I already did, i don't post that much, i don't want to accuse people without being 100% sure they are mafia

Yeah, but pretty much all of your posts are one-liners. That means you aren't really being much of a help to town, so of course people will get suspicious of you. This isn't the best way to 'play it safe' since, if you're town, you'll get mixed up with any hiding scum.

 

[ShinySandwich]

No, you really haven't defended yourself.

Defend from what?

 

[BlueLeaf]

Defend from what?

...from all of the suspicions mentioned, I think.

 

[CookingOkasan]

I already did, i don't post that much, i don't want to accuse people without being 100% sure they are mafia

You don't have to accuse people to contribute

 

[ShinySandwich]

You don't have to accuse people to contribute

Ok, I will be here reading all your posts and i will try to contribute, i'm sorry, but this is my playstyle, and if you guys want me to change it, i will

 

[Sid2125]

Defend from what?

people are thinking you are suspicious. you are trying to defend yourself from getting lynched

 

[Yui Z]

Yeah, but pretty much all of your posts are one-liners. That means you aren't really being much of a help to town, so of course people will get suspicious of you. This isn't the best way to 'play it safe' since, if you're town, you'll get mixed up with any hiding scum.

Just to add to this...

It's also rare that you're actually 100% sure that someone's mafia too. So you'll be quiet for a long time before that happens, and even then, you'll probably be bandwagoning on that since someone else will say that so-and-so is definitely mafia.
You didn't do an amazing job at defending yourself either.

 

[Sataric]

By the way - This is not related to current discussions but I want to say it anyways - I think Central should go ahead and send in another XCOM Rookie to make up for the failure of last night. The odds of it happening twice in a row is just very small, and now EXALT is even stronger than they were in the beginning. We need to try and do something about that.

 

[Geoni]

Defend from what?

I posted something about it a few pages ago but I'll repeat myself in question form. How come you were not able to yourself from Sataric's post against your one liner defense at 6:00 AM (my clock), but able to find the time to make a bunch of posts in Brewster's Cafe at 7:00 AM (my clock)?

Here's Sataric's 6:00 AM post that you didn't respond to:

Why not you? You've added nothing to this game so far. The fact that others may also have contributed poorly is irrelevant - You're useless to town right now and a complete liability to the game. Your only redeeming quality is IF you are a Blue role and you are using your action cleverly at night - But you could also be scum floating under the radar, and we would never get a read on you. And if you are a green role, you add zero value.

You are not the only one doing this, but you are ONE of the players that do, and your name just came to mind first - And your excuse is incredibly poor. I am disappoint.