Mafia TBT Mafia XIII: XCOM: Enemy Within (End Game - Town Wins!)

[oath2order]

I shared the whole thing about mafia
She didn't reply back to that.
We still chat on there though just not about maf.

- - - Post Merge - - -

omg i thought it was from only the host

No, it includes other ones. That's why Truffle and iLoveYou were modkilled in HP Mafia.

It's up to Fel now.

 

[Geoni]

For everyone's reference. I don't think screenshots are allowed.

But we're allowed to post logs? Logs and screenshots of skype serve the same purposes so I don't get why one would be banned and the other not banned.

Also, Capella probably cut it off to where she outed herself to Noodles. But then noodles puts in her will that she thinks there's something going on between her and Oath. And as much as I can believe that Oath would keep her alive to manipulate her, I could just as easily believe that he'd get rid of her as soon as he can due to the role's influence and the fact that she can indeed figure it out eventually. Hmm.

 

[Ashtot]

I shared the whole thing about mafia
She didn't reply back to that.
We still chat on there though just not about maf.

- - - Post Merge - - -

omg i thought it was from only the host

Well I mean it's kinda good because now we can figure out who's scum.

 

[Yui Z]

Aye - I mentioned a few names before but I really think that MewMew is acting completely out of character this game. She has not been very active and she's not been responding to the PM I sent her, but she HAS been online on TBT overall. Furthermore, I called ShinySandwich out repeatedly some pages back, and they responded to me quickly - But they gave me an incredibly poor defense, and then continued posting in other threads on TBT rather than actively participate in the conversation I was trying to start up with them. Both of these players could certainly be scum trying to slip by for a while.

As for the stronger players, they're always harder to read - Yui Z has not spoken much yet but she recently stepped in to replace Amaze, so we'll have to give her some time. And it would be nice to hear a little bit more from Minties, about whom they find suspicious, though the posts they've made so far has been solid. Both Tina and MissNoodle obviously trusted Oath and then ended up dead, but Tina told me that she was convinced Oath was innocent - Why would he kill her if she didn't suspect him at all, if he was scum?

I don't really consider myself a strong player. X_X

Honestly, the whole trash talk in the thread has completely thrown me and I'm only just starting to see what's been happening before I came in as a replacement. I don't think I ever want to see Kermit the flipping frog again either.

Here's a few quick thoughts:
First of all, I don't think Niamh's will should be overlooked or brushed aside because she makes some interesting points.

Moron seems very town-like to me at the moment. They're posting more than I've seen them post when they're scum, so I'm convinced that they're town from what I've seen so far.

C r y s t a l hasn't said anything too helpful yet so far. Mostly one-liners. They might be someone worth keeping an eye on to see if they're posting minimum.

Spoiler: Crystal's posts

So, I read everything. 1, I do not think SP has 14 roleclaims because if he does, why is everyone roleclaiming on day 1. Cory can be obnoxious at times but I think we should give him more of a chance. I'll be voting no lynch for the jailor.

We all have inthoughts on days, it's just hard to get them out.

Oh hai.

I came out to have a good time and I?m honestly feeling so kermited right now.

Mewmewmewm usually posts in a bit more depth than she is now (or, at least, that's what I've gathered from the mafia games I've played with her). Looking at their post filter, it looks like she started out serious and then went a bit more 'jokey'. She might just be a bored townie.

Superpenguin seems to be acting like he normally does. I think it makes sense with what he did to keep himself from being killed at night, I mean, scum wouldn't be dumb enough to waste a kill on someone who can't die at the time.

Blu Rose is posting like they usually do really. I think they're a good help to town, although one or two of their longer posts have stated the obvious a bit much. They don't seem scummy for the time being.

Aerious came off as a little suspicious, however I'd rather think right now that this was some kind of plan of hers or something. Superpenguin made a good theory about it which would've made sense, but I can't also help thinking that she was just backing off because she realized that her argument was invalid. On the fence about her at the moment.

Oath doesn't seem scummy to me, for now. Niamh probably have had a reason that she decided to contact him, but she obviously trusted him enough (considering she was trusting him with her blue role). Perhaps it was how he was posting or contributing.

Tom helped to lead the no lynch, which could be scum trying to slow town down. People bandwagoned pretty quick on it (in one hour!? Seriously???), which makes me believe that there will have been scum hiding among the voters. Not sure where he's disappeared to, but I'm on the fence at the moment. He does seem town-like looking at his posts.

Shiny, where have you been? Am I missing something here? I'm pretty sure you usually post more than this, and all I'm seeing looking at your post filter is one-liners. I was kind of leaning towards bored townie, however I'm still not sure.

Spoiler: Shiny's posts

Janitor plan? What? I'm lost

Yes, i do

There are people who haven't even posted, Why me?

Thanks!

Ashtot seems townie-ish, but I haven't really got many thoughts on him so far.

This post is a bit rushed, and I'm fully aware that I've not included some people. I haven't got anything on the people who I've missed out, and I don't have time to go through the thread again at the minute.

 

[CookingOkasan]

that was a pointless screenshot anyway.

why would noodle include you in her will if neither of you even came out and role claimed or said anything at all of note...

 

[Superpenguin]

No, it includes other ones. That's why Truffle and iLoveYou were modkilled in HP Mafia.

It's up to Fel now.

iLoveYou was modkilled for playing against her win condition. Only Truffle was modkilled for posting a screenshot. Don't spread false information.

 

[Capella]

oh my god ;-;
i'm so sorry
so is it a ban from all games?

 

[Yui Z]

By Niamh I mean MissNoodle. Sorry, it's a habit.

 

[oath2order]

iLoveYou was modkilled for playing against her win condition. Only Truffle was modkilled for posting a screenshot. Don't spread false information.

Piss off.

 

[BlueLeaf]

But we're allowed to post logs? Logs and screenshots of skype serve the same purposes so I don't get why one would be banned and the other not banned.

Also, Capella probably cut it off to where she outed herself to Noodles. But then noodles puts in her will that she thinks there's something going on between her and Oath. And as much as I can believe that Oath would keep her alive to manipulate her, I could just as easily believe that he'd get rid of her as soon as he can due to the role's influence and the fact that she can indeed figure it out eventually. Hmm.

Logs can be faked, though, as it's text that you can type out yourself. Screenshots are hard to fake, you need to have the exact usnername, etc.

 

[Superpenguin]

Oath doesn't seem scummy to me, for now. Niamh probably have had a reason that she decided to contact him, but she obviously trusted him enough (considering she was trusting him with her blue role). Perhaps it was how he was posting or contributing.

Look at the PM exchange between the two of them. She roleclaimed at Night just because she didn't know what to do with her role. Her asking oath for his role before telling him hers shows that she didn't really trust him. She just went to players she knew would talk to her for help.

 

[radical6]

Ehh, posting screenshots is different than pasting skype logs. Mostly because you can just easily edit skype logs.

oh my god ;-;
i'm so sorry
so is it a ban from all games?

Nah, I'd doubt Fel will ban you forever lol.

 

[ShinySandwich]

Okay, Noodle's will is interesting. Though I think Oath is smart enough to not kill a blue right after they tell them their role.. That and whoever left the death message tried to make it look really obvious.

I was thinking the same, but what if oath wants us to think that, but idk really, i always overthink this stuff lol

 

[Superpenguin]

Can we just skip over the whole Cap posting a screenshot thing. Feloreena will come and handle it. Until then, let's move on with discussion.

 

[Feloreena]

I feel that Capella made a mistake and meant no harm by sharing the screenshot, and didn't understand the rules properly. I will let you off with a warning this time, but please, no screenshots whatsoever in the thread from now on. If you want to share chat logs, please copy and paste them instead.

 

[CookingOkasan]

I was thinking the same, but what if oath wants us to think that, but idk really, i always overthink this stuff lol

Shiny pls. you've been called out by a handful of people, you should be focused on defending yourself.

 

[Ashtot]

I was thinking the same, but what if oath wants us to think that, but idk really, i always overthink this stuff lol

How about you defend yourself because you've been called out a hundred times already. What you just said is completely irrelevant.

I just wanted to point out that Mewmewmewm soft-claimed a blue role early on in the game, and most of you seemed to have somehow missed it. I'm not trying to point this out to scum or anything, but I think it's something we need to consider. I PM'd her about 2 hours ago and haven't gotten a response. People are finding her scummy so I figured I'd point this out.

 

[ShinySandwich]

Shiny, where have you been? Am I missing something here? I'm pretty sure you usually post more than this, and all I'm seeing looking at your post filter is one-liners. I was kind of leaning towards bored townie, however I'm still not sure.

This was my playstyle in the last mafia game, where i had a pretty good role, i just don't think it's safe for me

 

[Geoni]

I was thinking the same, but what if oath wants us to think that, but idk really, i always overthink this stuff lol

Not going to defend Sataric and I's suspicions of you and our reasons why?

 

[Ashtot]

This was my playstyle in the last mafia game, where i had a pretty good role, i just don't think it's safe for me

What do you mean not safe? You aren't safe anymore because you won't defend yourself.