Mafia TBT Mafia XIII: XCOM: Enemy Within (End Game - Town Wins!)

[toastia]

Uhhh I'm pretty sure mafia have more than 1 KP....

I realized what I said after I posted it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well, a Mafia team normally discuss whom they're going to kill together with each other so he would send his minions to kill the other targets he thought would catch on to him, I reckon.

I wouldn't doubt the scum team would follow him.
I'm more sus of Capella right now, though.

 

[Superpenguin]

He killed us both on Night 1 in the Mean Girls Mafia and then sent me a PM taking credit for the kill. He told me straight out that he thought we where the most likely to eventually catch him otherwise, especially if we'd be talking to each other. Dolby has proven that he can normally tell if Oath is scum or blue a few times before, such as in Tom's PoI game when Oath was the detective and got killed Night 1.

1.) Why make it obvious and do the same two kills as a previous game.
2.) "Oh, the same people didn't die so that clears so-so" is never an excuse to clear someone especially in a completely new game with a totally different set-up, roles, and even players.

 

[CookingOkasan]

Also is Blu Rose going to be replaced today?

 

[8floor]

it also would not surprise me if dolby and oath were scum together
dolby has given those posts of looking like they are contributing while really saying nothing

and to whoever brought up Mewmew, i find that sus, as well. i feel like that comment got entirely too overlooked

 

[Sataric]

1.) Why make it obvious and do the same two kills as a previous game.
2.) "Oh, the same people didn't die so that clears so-so" is never an excuse to clear someone especially in a completely new game with a totally different set-up, roles, and even players.

No, that is very true. But as I said earlier:

Both Tina and MissNoodle obviously trusted Oath and then ended up dead, but Tina told me that she was convinced Oath was innocent - Why would he kill her if she didn't suspect him at all, if he was scum?

That is my primary reason for not thinking Oath is nearly as scummy now as I perhaps might've done previously. I could be wrong though. That's certainly happened before. >_<

 

[Superpenguin]

it also would not surprise me if dolby and oath were scum together
dolby has given those posts of looking like they are contributing while really saying nothing

Yup, there is also the possiblity that oath didn't kill you guys because you are on a team OR oath is in EXALT and thus can't kill anyone anyway.

 

[8floor]

That is my primary reason for not thinking Oath is nearly as scummy now as I perhaps might've done previously. I could be wrong though. That's certainly happened before. >_<

and i do not think that is an entirely sound reason.
it is better to kill people that do not suspect you, especially on night 1, so that they do not leave incriminating information in their will. it is always better to go after people that do not suspect you, compared to people that do (with exception).

 

[oath2order]

It looks like Capella is on much later in the day (11PM EST).

 

[Superpenguin]

That is my primary reason for not thinking Oath is nearly as scummy now as I perhaps might've done previously. I could be wrong though. That's certainly happened before. >_<

Oath's circle was obviously getting very big. If he was scum, he knew he would get caught by the people who trusted him. He has to reduce the numbers in his circle early so they don't squeal about him. Also, Noodle was a valuable blue, so I mean whether she trusted oath or not, she would die the moment she roleclaimed to a mafia member.

 

[oath2order]

Oath's circle was obviously getting very big. If he was scum, he knew he would get caught by the people who trusted him. He has to reduce the numbers in his circle early so they don't squeal about him. Also, Noodle was a valuable blue, so I mean whether she trusted oath or not, she would die the moment she roleclaimed to a mafia member.

My circle? I've only PMed with about four people this game.

I find it odd that Noodle was killed though. Seems to me like a random kill. If I was scum, I'd keep her alive for manipulation purposes. It's obvious she didn't know what to do with the role.

This could change, depending on what Capella's PMs look like.

 

[BlueLeaf]

RIP: Tina, MissNoodle, and Cory.

As for the Aerious thing, I find it hard to believe that she accused Oath just because. I believe she had an intention of doing so, I just don't really think she would use really flawed evidence. Ashtot's reasoning also makes sense.

As for Oath, Capella, and possible third person: I believe at least one of them is scum as of now, I don't think MissNoodle posed any threat (2 posts, I think) to people who weren't communicating with her in private. I'm not too sure of MissNoodle being a random kill, however.

I'd like to hear more from Crystal, you have been active on other parts of the forum but not too much on here.

 

[Superpenguin]

My circle? I've only PMed with about four people this game.

Exactly, you can't kill four people at once later down the road. So you have to reduce those numbers earlier on in the game cause as soon as one player in your circle is suspicious of you, they all are.

 

[Capella]

RIP everyone

Noodle and I talk on skype, not pm's on here.

Spoiler: The conversation

 

[BlueLeaf]

I'd like to hear more from Crystal, you have been active on other parts of the forum but not too much on here.

There are also others, Crystal came into my head first. Another name is LittleBeary, I'd like to see you post more of substance.

 

[Ashtot]

RIP everyone

Noodle and I talk on skype, not pm's on here.

Spoiler: The conversation

View attachment 55001

You didn't share the whole conversation.

 

[radical6]

I don't see why "Oath doesn't like killing blues" clears him.

Noodle's role was one which mafia would want completely out of the way. In HP mafia, Karen was a tracker/watcher and I didn't want her alive even though she trusted me and shared a ton of information with me. We decided to just kill her cause the tracker/watchers were too big of a nuissance to the mafia.

I'm not saying it clears him, but I'm saying Capella is the more suspicious one out of the two. I don't think he would've killed Noodle in a game with wills. If there weren't any wills then he could've killed her without drawing suspicion to himself. But I doubt anyone knew Noodle's role besides those 2. So if he killed her and there were no wills it would've been fine - no one knew she was a blue before her death and no one knew she told Oath. But I would think he would expect a will from Noodle if he did kill her. idk. I just feel like Capella would be the one to kill Noodle over Oath. I don't believe he's mafia, but there's still a possibility he's exalt.

And yeah I agree with Oath, she would've been really easy to manipulate. If I was scum I would've kept her alive to use her anyway.

RIP everyone

Noodle and I talk on skype, not pm's on here.

Spoiler: The conversation

View attachment 55001

Uh, I'm not sure if you're allowed to post literal screenshots of your conversation. Idk, it's different for every mafia game.

im not making much sense i should probably go take a nap

 

[Superpenguin]

ATTENTION: I got a vig to shoot Aerious at night tonight. If you are not that vig, then don't both shooting her. Thanks.

 

[BlueLeaf]

ANYONE CAUGHT SHARING SCREENSHOTS FROM OBSERVER, PM, SCUM CHAT, ANYTHING WILL BE BANNED!

For everyone's reference. I don't think screenshots are allowed.

 

[Ashtot]

Uh, I'm not sure if you're allowed to post literal screenshots of your conversation. Idk, it's different for every mafia game.

im not making much sense i should probably go take a nap

This too...

 

[Capella]

You didn't share the whole conversation.

I shared the whole thing about mafia
She didn't reply back to that.
We still chat on there though just not about maf.

- - - Post Merge - - -

omg i thought it was from only the host