Mafia TBT Mafia XIV - Majora's Mask Redux - End Game

[Byngo]

Literally how did none of them have a mask, though? Did people seriously steal their masks? Jerks.

I can't see how 3 would've has their masks stolen and killed. But then again this is mafia.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Sataric (scum chat): Harry, if you read this in the future, I am terribly sorry for stabbing you in the back like this. I know you trusted me. I know I deceived you. I know our bromance is a thing of endless beauty, and that my actions have now damaged the bond between us. But it had to be this way. I hope you understand some day!

lol

 

[oath2order]

Sataric (scum chat): Harry, if you read this in the future, I am terribly sorry for stabbing you in the back like this. I know you trusted me. I know I deceived you. I know our bromance is a thing of endless beauty, and that my actions have now damaged the bond between us. But it had to be this way. I hope you understand some day!

lol

Shoo

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Man I didn't get to do sheet.

 

[Geoni]

Town just potentially lost the Postman's Hat. Unless a fellow townie stole it. :/

 

[Byngo]

Town just potentially lost the Postman's Hat. Unless a fellow townie stole it. :/

Wouldn't it say if one of them had the Postman's Hat? Or a I missing something?

 

[Pathetic]

Sataric (scum chat): Harry, if you read this in the future, I am terribly sorry for stabbing you in the back like this. I know you trusted me. I know I deceived you. I know our bromance is a thing of endless beauty, and that my actions have now damaged the bond between us. But it had to be this way. I hope you understand some day!

lol

EXCUSE ME? WHAT IS THIS 'BROMANCE'.

Town just potentially lost the Postman's Hat. Unless a fellow townie stole it. :/

Wait wat? Did one of them have the Postman's Hat? sry id ont remember where that was said

 

[BlueLeaf]

Shoo

oops wrong thread sorry

 

[Geoni]

I had the postman's hat and it was stolen from me. If mafia has it they can just give each other a bunch of brand new masks.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I knew a townie did this might feel much better about it having been stolen. :c

 

[Superpenguin]

Tsundere knows someone with the PostMan's Mask. If it was not Dad, I suggest they at least talk to Dad about it.

 

[Byngo]

I had the postman's hat and it was stolen from me. If mafia has it they can just give each other a bunch of brand new masks.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I knew a townie did this might feel much better about it having been stolen. :c

Oh. I was confused because you never even mentioned that it was stolen from you. o:

 

[Pathetic]

I had the postman's hat and it was stolen from me. If mafia has it they can just give each other a bunch of brand new masks.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I knew a townie did this might feel much better about it having been stolen. :c

O. Rip Postman's Hat.

{tbh lynch capella 2k14}

 

[Mewmewmewm]

Wow. RIP tom, sataric, and Ashtot.
But I'm pretty surprised none of them had masks 0_O not sure if thats a good thing or a bad thing.

 

[Geoni]

Tsundere knows someone with the PostMan's Mask. If it was not Dad, I suggest they at least talk to Dad about it.

I told them about it before it got stolen. Them being tsundere, not the other potential postman.

 

[MrPicklez]

Anyone else find it odd that Tom died Night 1 in a game him and Tsundere actually weren't fighting in? Also I'd like to bring up a case on Tsundere while we're at it...

So to sum up what happened ashtots being a namecallin dingus, Berrypop thinks no lynch, and Tsundere either made a townie mistake or doesnt have a townie pm in the first place.
Tsundere doesnt usually make mistakes like that, and they seemed to just play it off like it was no big deal.[/b] Or maybe i'm just the only noob who read the entire role pm, i don't know.

i skimmed my role pm so sorry. it wasnt in bold so i skimmed over it oops.
anyway, for once i agree no lynch is better. whoever has the inspection masks can tell us their results and we'll have something to work with on the next day. and someone will probably steal their mask so its not like we're losing the cop forever. ~_~

This right here seems unlike Tsundere, whom I consider to be a pretty good player. Too much of a noob mistake.

Personally, on the Tsundere thing, I can't seem to get a read.
When she was scum in my mafia, she was more voiced out and outspoken during the beginning of the game, then quickly changed her playstyle to make her seem more town. Maybe she's learned from that mistake and is fixing her scum playstyle? That would be kind of a stretch, IMO. So I'm sorta indifferent on this topic.

If I remember correctly, Superpenguin and Tsundere both claimed the same mask.

This one right here still bothers me. It brings up flashbacks of Jer's mini where there were multiple roles that were reused.

Tsundere claims openly to have a useless mask without any real reason or tactical advantage (provided that she spoke the truth), which seems like a massive blunder in my eyes since those masks are exactly what you would want Mafia to steal since it would not give them any additional powers.

As for Ryan88 - I will be honest and admit that I think he's one of the weakest Mafia players on TBT simply because people constantly give him little pointers and advice, ask him to defend himself properly, and give him the benefit of the doubt a lot, and yet he never follows suit. But this is a PMs-Allowed game which means that someone could take him under their wing and attempt to mentor him. If Ryan himself would be interested in something like that, and shows a willingness to learn, then maybe it's best to No Lynch today - But otherwise maybe we should just remove him from play. We might lose a powerful mask in the process, but we would have a chance to get scum right away if we're lucky, and even if he is town at least his mask could not be stolen and used by scum either.

This makes me think what if she has a very powerful mask. She says she has a useless mask but she could only say that so nobody tries to steal it. It's just a thought and a good possibility.

And now both Sataric and Tom are dead.

Idk. This is all I could really get from reading EVERY page again. Ugh.

 

[Minties]

Okay, here's people I have barely seen posting: Alice, Tina, MissNiamh, Prin, Sid2125, MewMewMewm, Capella, Minties, MrKisstofur, and probably 1 or 2 other names I'm forgetting. I know there's time zones that have limited some of them, and others I have kind grown to expect to be quiet *cough*MissNiamh*cough* but if y'all could post more that would be great.

Tbh before Tsun mentioned Prin, I kind of forgot Prin was even playing. lol

Hi, this game started on a Thursday for me and I work full time Mon - Fri. I have finished work for the week now, so I can post more on the weekends. The huge issue is the ****ty times Oath picked for day to end. I get off of work at 2pm my time and day ends at 3pm my time.... I will try to post more from my tiny phone at work. Just explaining why I've been quieter than other times.

Now onto business. One person that I notice Sataric was suspicious of was Prin. A few of her posts:

Expect a post frome me in a few minutes. I got out of school early today.

A post never followed this.

Can someone sort out the Ashtot/SP thing? I'm literally so confused.

While it confused me slightly as well due to the misinformation going out, I was still expecting a post containing suspicions from Prin.

I can't really think of anything else to say :| guess I'll wait until tomorrow to see what the night brings.

She can't think of anything else to say? Has she even said anything at all? I may sound slightly hypocritical, but I made good on my promise to post suspicions on people. I feel like Prin is just posting enough for us to barely remember her playing and staying highly out of the spotlight. Iirc, she usually tries a lot more as town and isn't afraid to post suspicions on people. My gut doesn't trust her.

 

[radical6]

HAHAHA TOM DIED! ALSO WHO THE *** STOLE CAP'S MASK BEFORE ME. *** YOU. ok anyway me and tom don't always fight in PM games. i talked to him on skype so i got a town read from him - same as I did in XCOM. i didnt steal dad's hat. i dont want it anyway but i still only have the useless don gero mask. gdi. also me and sataric were talking in PMs (he wanted me to steal caps mask) so i feel like he somewhat trusted me? also im guessing a clockmaker killed one of the three, or a vig. also srry im not perfect

 

[Cariad]

just mentioning again, I'm not here tomorrow. I'll get on on Sunday and I'm on a bit today, but tomorrow is impossible. Sorry.

I think that Tina could be mafia. Her usual play style has lots of big posts, and she's in most discussions, but this time she's not talking so much here. I also haven't seen many big posts. to me, it seems like she's avoiding the thread.

 

[Chris]

Tina has been oddly quiet, though I don't really know her playstyle that well. She's the same as Tom tbh. Hard to read. I do suspect her a bit, but I'm hoping she will post more.

Day 1: starts at 3pm my time. I was drinking with my folks from 6pm onwards and went to bed at 1am. I didn't wake up until 11am, and day ended at 6am my time.

Night 1: as I've previously stated, I didn't want to influence mafia/clockmaker(s) actions or behaviour by giving my observations early on.

Tina is somebody I get bad feelings about this game. Now this could all just be because she's drinking a lot lately and has rl stuff going on, but she's unusually quiet in this game. I also thought that her being really opposed to a no lynch wasn't pro town enough because people who push for lynches in a game where stealing masks from more useless players are being anti-town. Loot before you shoot y'knowwhatI'msayin?

See above for activity.

I've been saying for eight months straight on here that I disagree with no lynching, this is not an opinion exclusive to this game. Lynches provide evidence: deciding to no lynch too early on means everyone bandwagons on that idea resulting in less discussion rather than searching for names to push forward. Also, not knowing the alignment of the main target by the Day 1 also makes it harder to analyse behaviours. I see no lynches as a last resort option.

I think that Tina could be mafia. Her usual play style has lots of big posts, and she's in most discussions, but this time she's not talking so much here. I also haven't seen many big posts. to me, it seems like she's avoiding the thread.

I toned down my play style several games ago. Someone complained my posts were 'just fluff'.

 

[Chris]

*by the end of Day 1