I'm making this case on my phone, expect typos.
Reasons why Jacob is a terrorist:
A letter by Daniel A. Scummington
Not sure why you said this, we don't have Role names. This is even before Ness added the joke deaths, so this just really makes no sense. I just see it as a bad fake claim.
this is my first time actually reading this game, sry kat
im just waiting for night LOL
He completely disregarded Sarasa's suspicions on him.
Eh, I've got a few suspicions rather than rling or nling that I'd like to bring up:
- Jacob seems to be quiet and stay away from us goofing off. And correct me if I'm wrong, but he seems like the kind who'd love to jump in on that kind of thing. Perhaps he's afraid to talk in the thread?
- Heyden's question raises some red flags for me. Possible that they're asking if they should shoot or not, but also struck me as a terrorist asking if they should base their shooting off of who others are going to shoot.
- Dolby is Kolech scum and his scum game is damn good so perma keeping him here
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh, and to answer Heyden's question, depends on if we're actually going to try to win this game or make this game a meme. If we're actually trying, I think we shouldn't shoot.
no sorry, I'm still reading it all
you can vote me if u want idc
- - - Post Merge - - -
def shooting tonight thats the only reason i signed up
Um ok so I read back and still no leads. I'd be fine with a Heyden, Inkling or Alexi lynch tho.
Usually when heyden is town he like tries to claim maf and he hasnt done that thus far so i call bull
First of all, in a game where majority takes very few votes, why don't you care about being voted for? Just seems like you're laughing off any suspicions on you.
Then, I don't understand where you got this read in Hayden. You didn't voice you're reasoning for the other lynch options, but you claim Heyden claims Mafia which I have never seen before. You're reasoning is really flawed. And you vote for him when HE DOES CLAIM TERRORIST ANYWAYS. Very hypocritical.
nah but we each have a 22% scum hit rate (except scum who has 11%) so if each town member (as of right now) shoots a different person there is like a 65% chance we are hitting scum one tonight. like 20% chance we hit both
If we lynch a town member, we actually have a higher percentage rate assuming we all dont shoot eachother in a circle.
If we lynch maf then we have about 45% chance of killing the other one tonight if 5 town members shoot different people
of course we could always let one of the town not shoot which lowers our scum hit rate but heightens our town survival rate if you want
but the mafia has like a 85% hit rate of town no matter what so i guess its ur call if we all shoot tonight. its a yolo kinda thing. im actually fairly excited
This statements really makes 0 sense. It seems like you don't care about who is lynched or who is shot, as it appears you are statistically justifying that you'll hit scum anyways. When though we're at the point were its MYLO now. If we all shot, it's very likely scum would have won or drawed.
1. i didnt change my mind i want to shoot tonight. but if salsakat tells me not to then i guess i wont. shes way more experienced than i am
2. idk they could be helpful in decided if everyone should shoot tonight or not
- - - Post Merge - - -
and personally yes i think we should all shoot, except one of us
Again this is the flawed "We should all shoot" logic. And then he says he won't shoot if explicitly SarasaKat tells him not to. Even though I said not too, she did, and mostly everyone agreed to. Why just Sarasa, was Minties or Dolby not experienced like her? Even if you are town, it's very likely you did in fact shoot, so you completely went back on what you said here.
no but the terrorists arent working together so I dont think it matters as much
Now that I think about it, everyone shooting could be more in favor for the terrorists so:
If we lynch a town member, I think 3 of us should shoot.
If we lynch a mafia member, I think 1 of us should shoot.
Again with this really weird we should all shoot philosophy, it's like you didn't even consider the possibility that the vigs will most likely shoot town. This I don't care attitude toward the game is very anti town.
And finally, the silence and lurking after it all. Fits right in with Scum Jacob meta.
