• Guest, can you feel the love in the air? Valentine's Week at The Bell Tree has begun with a new mini-event featuring four activities to enjoy -- new and returning collectibles are up for grabs! Dive in to the love here.

Mafia TBT Micromafia: The Resistance (Spies Won)

Yeah but if we keep voting no on everything, then we fail and get no information too
 
Oh thats what it is... Dolby/Vanessa/Punchy? absolutely not...

and honestly that ^^^ post by Punchy kinda confirms he isn't scum
Vanessa HAS to be scum
 
LOL WHAT

Two 180s in one post. SCUM!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Let me guess, you were "drunk" and will 180 on it once again tomorrow
 
How does that post confirm that he's not scum?

why would punchy say anything to talk me out of voting FOR that team... if he was scum and wanted to win, he wouldn't have said something to help me question that team

- - - Post Merge - - -

LOL WHAT

Two 180s in one post. SCUM!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Let me guess, you were "drunk" and will 180 on it once again tomorrow

There was no 180s in it... and don't just call me out on being drunk, I'll let you know if i am drinking while mafia-ing

I realized having both punchy/vanessa on the team, was dumb because I know its going to fail... so yeah of course I'm failing it. I was bent on it just not having me on it earlier, but hearing that team again reminds me that its stupid to put that team in.

You voting against Dolby's team clearly shows you aren't on scum team. If you were scum aligned at all, you would've voted yes so fast and clinched a point, but you didn't. That settles who is scum between Punchy and Vanessa which as I stated earlier... I know one of you is scum from the 3 person mission we were in that failed.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Furthering that Vanessa is S C U M...

sorry girl, but the ride is over

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I think this thought process really shows that I've been at least following this game in order to try to solve it... Vanessa just seems to be there and offering convenient opinions in order to clear herself.

I guess Vanessa/Punchy could also be a possibility, but punchy had all the power to make this mission fail for mafia, and he voted no lol. I know someone is scum in that 3 person mission I was in, its not me and I highly doubt its punchy so Vanessa has to be it
 
Vanessa and Dolby where Ness staged his leaving or Vanessa and Dedenne, the obvious choice?
 
And reminder two more failed proposals if Dedenne’s proposal fail will result in automatic win for the spies.

Btw Happy Bday Antonio!
 
Last edited:
Dedenne please submit You/Me/and Punchy

I understand that you think that me/Vanessa is a technical possibility and know that Antonio won’t submit something without him on it , but are you seriously considering voting yes on that atrocity

At college orientation rn, no computer
 
I understand that you think that me/Vanessa is a technical possibility and know that Antonio won’t submit something without him on it , but are you seriously considering voting yes on that atrocity

At college orientation rn, no computer

I absolutely would, if it passes WOO... if it doesn't then I know the team is Vanessa/Dedenne
 
I absolutely would, if it passes WOO... if it doesn't then I know the team is Vanessa/Dedenne

Ok, hold on. Vanessa’s in a better position than you with far more credibility. I still believ that you are scum, if it doesn’t pass, which Vanessa/Dedenne would like to happen, how does that not passing implicate Vanessa/Dedenne as a team

Besides, Punchy would not vote for that.
 
Ok, hold on. Vanessa’s in a better position than you with far more credibility. I still believ that you are scum, if it doesn’t pass, which Vanessa/Dedenne would like to happen, how does that not passing implicate Vanessa/Dedenne as a team

Besides, Punchy would not vote for that.

Sooooooo... you think I'm fudging that whole thought process a second ago? You think I'm faking all of this effort to actually solve this? Really? What part gives me less credit? Please tell me

There is so many people in this game that want to be involved, but don't want to actual offer up any idea in how to actually solve this. No one else is giving me any hope that they actually will win this game
 
No, you’re clearly desperate that me and Vanessa have the right team and you’ll lose once it passes, so you shifted to the two of us being scum to try to get a team to pass that has scum on it. Nothing that you’ve done recently gives you less credit than Vanessa honestly besides this desperate shift, you even stated that me/Vanessa was unlikely 10 posts ago, and that Vanessa/Dedenne was the “obvious choice”

I’m offering an idea on how to solve it and I’ve been offering since stage one, Toads/Anyude
 
No, you’re clearly desperate that me and Vanessa have the right team and you’ll lose once it passes, so you shifted to the two of us being scum to try to get a team to pass that has scum on it. Nothing that you’ve done recently gives you less credit than Vanessa honestly besides this desperate shift, you even stated that me/Vanessa was unlikely 10 posts ago, and that Vanessa/Dedenne was the “obvious choice”

I’m offering an idea on how to solve it and I’ve been offering since stage one, Toads/Anyude

I also standby that Town Dolby would have come around and began to see my side of this... but the fact that you continue to just put it down and undeniably stand up for Vanessa who has been lackluster which in a roundabout way... you just admitted to

Dang Dolby are you scum? did you and Ness really fake that at the start?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dedenne, please send You/Me/Punchy

Punchy would you vote this?
 
The fact that you’re seriously considering that Ness ragequit in a scum v scum tells me all I, Punchy, and Vanessa, need to know honestly
 
The fact that you’re seriously considering that Ness ragequit in a scum v scum tells me all I, Punchy, and Vanessa, need to know honestly

no one else in this game seems to be offering me any hope that they could figure this out when I wasn't throwing out more farfetched ideas. I'm not saying that Ness wouldn't rage quit, but I'm doubting the validity of it being a full "rage quit", maybe theres more behind it.

Were getting to the nitty gritty now, so what the **** else do you expect me to do. So again, stop being so ****ing smug and condescending...

Toad - I'm town, and I've been screaming it from the heavens since day 1, but everyone who is town seems to be just casually disregarding it... yeah I've been all over the place seemingly flip-flopping... but shouldn't that tell you I'm not trying to suck up or keep any one person in the game, not afraid to challenge anyone in this game. Whereas of course scum would undeniably try to back up their scummate.
Punchy - Could've literally just voted to get a free point with Dolby's proposal
Vanessa - I know one of Vanessa/Punchy is scum, and I don't think Punchy could've lied in that scenario described above... by default, that means Vanessa is scum. Tbh, I see it because Vanessa has been lackluster this entire game

So then whose Vanessa's partner?

Dedenne - has been not focused at all, very easy prey and honestly it is easy to pin them for scum, but that last post of theres about the checking their PM... I did the same thing yesterday I think, so it just seems very genuine town at this point. Hence why I'm entertaining the idea of a Dedenne/Punchy/Toad town team. I think overall Dedenne would be more focused if on a scum team.

Dolby on the other hand has undeniably supported Ness and Vanessa this entire game. Is Ness and Dolby capable of something like this, absolutely. I have been a supporter of town dolby for a little bit now, because I agreed that a Ness/Dolby team seemed not a possibility. However, with the recent development of Vanessa def being a scum, the most teamiest team connections has been Dolby for Ness/Vanessa and he has coasted on it this entire game for a safe reason and I'm not afraid to challenge that right now. These two always supported each other's teams and have even teamed up to gang up on me, who is seemingly the biggest threat to them winning. Dedenne and Punchy if you are town, we need to come together. Dolby in all other games too always is flexible, and able to reason with even the most poor of players' reasonings, and for him to completely shut me down at all times shows he is doing it to keep up a unified front on me. He has been stauchly set on his reads from the start which have not gotten us really anything major, so I see no reason why Punchy and Dedenne should continue to believe him. Please think about all this, we are close to the end of this game and we need to close it up, not flitter on anything anymore. I'm still open to different possibilities, but Vanessa is most definitely scum... and Dolby makes the most sense for her partner right now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And Punchy and Dedenne, do you honestly think I would fudge all of this? Like really, you all need to go back and read my meta for town and scum, because I tend to be like dolby, and be consistent on reads and play much more focused.

- - - Post Merge - - -

When i'm scum... and I tend to be all over the place as town, I think we can all agree on that. Vanessa and Dolby should BOTH know that, but they casually and conveniently leave out any say about my play style this game except that its "clearly scum" in which I get misnomered as scum a lot of the time when I'm actually town... the fact that both of them have so much as commented anything like that and seem to be even avoiding talking about it shows me they are calculating little scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think we would also very much agree that dolby likes to take control when he is town, especially in the late game. However he hasn't taken charge on anything really... he just sits on his pedestal and tears down anyone for an idea that doesn't match his own scum-plot
 
So

1. Toads is suggesting that me and Ness coordinated for him to ragequit to give us an advantage which is actually illegal (using your modkill) or replacement to give advantage to your factionan.
2. I have not ?undeniably supported Ness? the whole game, I ****ing tore him down at the start
3. Toads blows over why I don?t take that him/me/Punchy because I would as scum (though it didn?t have the support regardless). Why? Because that?s my golden opportunity to frame Toads AGAIN.
4. Teams, teams. You?re saying that like it?s plural. We?ve supported one TEAM, singular the whole game, and that?s you/Dedenne and we have no obligation to reevaluate because I think that it?s still right
5. Importantly, why won?t Vanedsa, as scum, compromise with Punchy and put forward herself/Punchy/Antonio, which would have had the support of all three, and then fail it, framing a Toads/Antonio team and paving the way for me/Punchy/her round five?
6. I?m shutting you down because all your teams are bull crap
7. You?re shifting your team because I refuse to be on a team with you. Again, golden opportunity to frame, but I don?t take it. Pure OMGUS
8. Why have you been treating this like it?s the last phase?. Because it isn?t unless Vanessa/Punchy/me gets through. You?ve been treating it like if any team passes without you on it, we lose the game, but that isn?t the case.
9. I?ve ****ing taken charge, I?m forcing Punchy to vote yes on me/him/Vanessa on the fifth round bc if that fails town loses
10. You?ve consistently cited my meta, but never brought to the thread because you know it supports my position. So if you?re actually town, do it
 
1. If Ness wasn't too keen on playing and wanted to just quit, I could very well see you two being like "let's stage a fight for the lols" or just overall not taking this game seriously or thinking of it as a time to try something crazy.
2. You "tore him down" but directly after this you have remained on the side of "he is town" on the basis of "scum ness wouldn't rage quit" and left it at that for most this game. Lazy, but a good plan to coast without being questioned
3. you should re-explain this, because I don't get it
4. You haven't even thought about another team, you are just so sure in this one team, you don't even try to think what would happen if I'm wrong about this? Which is something to definitely worry about because we have two phases left.
5. Dolby logic goes in circles, is convoluted, and can never have too much good logic behind it. This is what you do, you take past events and say what should have happened, give some reason for it and then tout that thats the only way it could've happened when you have absolutely no evidence or clue to back up anything you ever say.
6. You have been an egotistical, smug, stubborn, ******* this whole game... not the compromising dolby I'm used to, complete style change AND I CAN BOLD MY POSTS TOO TO LOOK MORE IMPORTANT
7. From a game standpoint, scum dolby would have to scum read me this whole time in order to keep me as a target to direct attention away from yourself and on to me. People would look at the veteran players and thing one has to be scum, and you wanted to make sure that was always me. Strategically place yourself on the opposite side of me from the start, which you have done since my post #1
8. Because with the stupid ass teams I keep seeing get proposed, were gonna be sitting in the last phase with no clue of what to do and no information from the previous ones still proposing stupid ass teams. If Dedenne does that team I suggest and her, me and punchy pass it, I'm confident I have all the information I need to solve this.
9. You on the other hand typically play so openly and include everyone in on the plan to solve things, I think back to BOTW and many other games where you did this. But you are holding back this game Dolby, you are more reactive than proactive and thats a hallmark sign of Dolby.
10. RHOM - Town Dolby
Dolby said:
Why don't you think she's mafia specifically? Don't really feel that we have enough data to go one way or the other towards her specific role
Yet you were hard scum reading me from my post #1
Dolby said:
I’d rather lower maf KP first guys, getting arso doesn’t really help us until maf KP is one. Best play for even a highly sussed arso is to just keep dousing
Planning Dolby has given us no such direct links to his plans like this... these types of posts are completely different from how Dolby has played this entire game.

BOTW Mafia - 3rd Party Dolby, scummy... a little different but you were still actively trying to kill people. Its similar.
Dolby said:
Ok, seriously, you're really reaching here. I can understand being sus of me for my claim, but arguing on my character meta (which really, from your description, does seem to match up), shows that you have little substance
Dolby tends to focus on tearing down others' thoughts rather than building a cohesive plan when he isn't town like in BOTW.
Dolby said:
Then how does it harm you guys? Admittedly, you aren't using your full time in day. You said earlier that you felt like there was something else to it, what would it be besides a Loss of time and a thorn out of your side
Dolby said:
Ok look, if you believe I'm mafia

1. I'm literally offering myself for investigation, no GF would choose to return as third if given the choice, and I doubt that Toads would give framer the option to frame somebody as third party
2. If you think I'm sk or other hostile, please post what you think the setup is, but there's little I could argue against you guys thinking that

- - - Post Merge - - -

Moreover Heyden, if I was mafia, don't you think that I'd be happier to keep that in my scumchat?
And for those thinking he wouldn't do something that bold, he literally made up a different 3rd party claim to try and clear himself.

Dolby said:
To prove a point that I'm a capable bluesniper and if the kills were bluesniper, Ness would be dead
He also tends to be more egotistical when not town too

Egyptian Gods Kingmaker - Town Dolby

THESE ARE THE POSTS YOU GET FROM A TOWN DOLBY

Dolby said:
Guys, we have one dead maf who consistantly sussed Bianca through the entire game, one who wanted her D1 lynched passively, and one who was passionate and vocal that she wanted a Bianca D1 lynch. In fact, waffles also was passionate and vocal that she didn't want an f11 lynch as well. There's no way multiple maf would bus their teammate to the extent to go after them for D1 lynch


Dolby said:
Tbh, Jacob’s been pretty townie the whole game, and honestly shouldn’t be saying this but I don’t think KM is Bianca, but if it isn’t f11, I’m lost. It CANT be Mog, meaning Jacob or Bianca, both of whom were bleeding town, I want to go back and look at all scum mentions of Bianca

Dolby said:
Low key think maf tried to kill Sensai because they know who Doc is, and failed when counting on Tae lol

Sensai what you got?

- - - Post Merge - - -

KM should make Sensai, Heyden, or Tina king at this point

LIKE COME ON, the difference in Scum and Town Dolby is like night and day to me.

Dolby said:
Also, don't think that waffles would only sus two of her teammates, even that weakly, so I'm honestly really conflicted, a large part of me wants to believe f11 framed herself

Here he openly decides to believe that someone was framed over being mafia... kind of an out there idea, yet he goes along with it casually.


THERE IS YOUR META I'M GOING TO SLEEP
you are gonna rip it to shreds and I don't give a **** because you will not see my posts or efforts as town ever because you are strategically always placing yourself against me for this game

Dedenne, please submit you me and punchy
Punchy, please vote yes to it... or at least talk to me a little before voting no
 
Back
Top