Mafia TBT Mini Mafia XIV: My Little Mafia: Deception is Magic [Endgame - Ponyville wins!]

[Sumemr]

Ugh .. well at least that answers our questions @ alise. zz
Alright, I have been thinking about who to vote for after I posted last night, and I'm leaning towards Ryan88. Although there is the risk if KarlaKGB is scum and we don't lynch him today, what about the opposite? What if he's not? At the moment there is no clear person to lynch (to me), but I'm leaning towards Ryan88 just because he doesn't contribute and it is frustrating to have him alive, but not helping, if he really is a townie. He comes off as kind of scummy, but then he acts like this in most games so no one is really too sure. Either way, he comes off as a distraction to me, and it'd be better than a no lynch, imo, especially if he turns out to be scum. About Cariad though, that no lynch vote came off a little scummy to me. Especially because she only voted no lynch so that she wouldn't get modkilled. Really? After all our discussion..? I'm not sure who to vote on atm. Since the deadline got extended by an hour, I'll check back around 3 since I have to go take a test for an hour now. I will have time to make a vote, but I just will be voting later since I'm still uncertain.

Oh & @Feloreena, I did mention the possibility of Minties maybe getting notified as soon as she said the cursed word, if she was cursed. But I also am uncertain to accept the fact that there's another person who can kill during the day in this set up. It's scary for me to think about bleh. & I never said I thought Sataric was the only third party, but possibly the only day killer. Although, this is all just speculation on my part, as I don't know the amount of players in each townie/3rd party/mafia roles.

 

[Cory]

well he should be bloody well viewing.

do u... do u want some kfc to calm you down?

 

[Lauren]

Stop ****ing spamming **** cory.

 

[Ashtot]

Ashtot, I have some questions for you. You know, you've been very eager to defend people (Cory, Karla; can pull up quotes), but I feel you haven't really put any effort into listing your own suspicions. You only made a small list of possible lynch candidates at the beginning of day 1, but you admitted yourself that there wasn't a lot to go off yet and your reasoning was thus mostly based on their playstyles from previous games. You also didn't have a problem with lynching an inactive just because you wanted to prevent a no lynch.

Lynching an inactive is ALWAYS better than a no lynch. No lynches are stupid and completely useless, unless the game is set up in a way where a no lynch would be beneficial, in most cases, it isn't. No lynches are ideal for scum because you've pretty much wasted a whole day, and it doesn't give any information. You're right that I haven't been posting many of my own suspicions. I don't like to make loads of generic lists of everyone that consists of whether or not I may think they're Town or scum. The people I'm finding the most suspicious right now are the inactive players, we've been talking about this for a while now. Another thing: You should always use evidence from previous games to help figure out people in present games.

Some other things I noticed:



This was a reply to Minties post, who named some people she wouldn't mind lynching. You "suppose" you agree with her because you "trust her judgment". That's a little too easy, don't you think? It seemed like you were okay with just lynching whoever (aside from the people you defended; scum mates maybe?).

Minties is a very strong player, and because I don't know the styles of other players in the game, why wouldn't I agree with her? I don't see it as "too easy", and the fact that I agreed with Minties doesn't mean that I was okay with lynching them.

Again, you're just agreeing here without really explaining your suspicion. That just seems.. a bit too easy to me. Anyone can just agree with someone's else's reasoning without explaining why and place their vote on them.

These players have been under suspicion and there is nothing for me to say that wouldn't be regurgitating what others have said already. I'm not going to clog up the thread with identical suspicions. If you had been reading my posts, I have been giving reasoning towards my suspicions, and vote choices, I don't need to write a wall of text to explain that Ryan88 is useless and should be lynched in favor of a no lynch.

Again, why?

Why not? Why are you in favor of a no lynch?

Responses in bold.

 

[Campy]

Minties is a very strong player, and because I don't know the styles of other players in the game, why wouldn't I agree with her?

Because she didn't know the playstyles of most of the people she listed, either? Asides from Cariad and Kuma, she just named (relative) newbies.

And I'm not in favor of a no lynch, I just would have liked to see a bit more reasoning behind your votes than "I agree with". I can understand having the same opinion as other people and not wanting to repeat what has already been said, but at the same time it's also an easy way for scum to get their votes in without having to really explain themselves.

Anyway, I'll stop bothering you for now.

 

[Ashtot]

Because she didn't know the playstyles of most of the people she listed, either? Asides from Cariad and Kuma, she just named (relative) newbies.

And I'm not in favor of a no lynch, I just would have liked to see a bit more reasoning behind your votes than "I agree with". I can understand having the same opinion as other people and not wanting to repeat what has already been said, but at the same time it's also an easy way for scum to get their votes in without having to really explain themselves.

Anyway, I'll stop bothering you for now.

It's not a bother.

 

[Feloreena]

I will change my vote to Ryan for now as it seems like he will be the only one we can get majority on at the moment. He is so useless and should be banned from playing in main/mini games and stick to nub until he can learn how to play (if it's even possible). I don't really understand why he insists on signing for every game and proceeds to do nothing. How is that even fun? People just get mad at him for it. -_-

Not impressed with Cariad's no lynch vote at all. She better explain it because it is not helping town in any way. After all that has been said about placeholder votes and all that has been discussed it is just lazy.

 

[Axeler137]

WWWWWWWORROROROROOGGONNNG SO SO SO SO SO WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG

u know what is risky? leaving players like him alive until late game. when ur at lylo with two players who u cant get any reads on. what do u do then?

lylo? sorry still nub here.

Also Axeler, your plain disregard to my activity screams lazy scum bag, just saying.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I cant play in these conditions PPPP

- - - Post Merge - - -

plz respond axeler, i crave your attention.

Sorry, had to pick up my sister from school.
What is it you need?

- - - Post Merge - - -

So at this point, is Ryan the one to be lynched? Are there any other theories or possible suspicions lurking around or is lynching Ryan the only way to go?

 

[Feloreena]

So at this point, is Ryan the one to be lynched? Are there any other theories or possible suspicions lurking around or is lynching Ryan the only way to go?

He's probably the only person that we can reach majority on at this rate. Inactivity is killing this game...

 

[Lauren]

lylo? sorry still nub here.



Sorry, had to pick up my sister from school.
What is it you need?

- - - Post Merge - - -

So at this point, is Ryan the one to be lynched? Are there any other theories or possible suspicions lurking around or is lynching Ryan the only way to go?

HOLY ****! I made a bloody few posts on ryan? I don't give a damn if you're a nub you should read. I'm actually going to pull my hair out, you have literally disregarded all my posts haven't you? Dear Christ.

 

[KarlaKGB]

lylo? sorry still nub here.

lynch or lose - a state in the game where u must lynch scum or u lose the game

 

[Campy]

I'm about to head to bed so I have to place my vote now. My gut feeling says Ryan is innocent, but a no lynch wouldn't be helpful and I just really hope I'm wrong here. And he's definitely guilty of being a doofus, at least.

 

[Cory]

2 more to majority! (this is why i like plurality better)

 

[Axeler137]

HOLY ****! I made a bloody few posts on ryan? I don't give a damn if you're a nub you should read. I'm actually going to pull my hair out, you have literally disregarded all my posts haven't you? Dear Christ.

Alright. I just went through all your posts and here's all that you have said in this thread about ryan:

Spoiler: spacial reasons

Now, Ryan88's claim doesnt sit right with me? Why the **** would he claim again? He usually asks, lol. Could this be a scum cover? he knows we know he claims every bloody game, could he use this to try and sway us and shun him like every other game?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just an idea, he usually role claims but asks before hand. He doesn't usually pop it out of no where for no reason.

This is true, he could be playing the dumb ass card as a cover.

His "scum" pals could have told him to do this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

in doing so he has drawn attention to himself?

being night one, it will be a random kill.

- - - Post Merge - - -



be srs. Ryan is dumb but you never know. Why are you reluctant to take in the possibility of this? What do you have to add? take? thoughts on night? Ideas on people so far?

You're quick to shoot opinions down, if you do so, state your own.

He could have fake claim, say he does, he must have a stronger player as a scum mate, "claim your fake claim ryan, you usually claim, no one will think anything of it"

As cap said, he didnt even check in nor did he **** post a little. He just.. claimed? no warning as he does.

i mean yeah, i wasnt present for the whole sataric voicing opinion, i read through but still, i didnt read into it, i was like blahblah same day one crap, i wont lie. He might of pissed someone off so we should look into who he's called out.

The ryan thing, he will probably try to vote Karla again LOL. Seriously, Ryan wont have anything to say, if he does, his scum mates will be directing him. If has anything to say, it'll be a change of character.

Can we all take a gander at this, now this was a post Sataric made about Ryan. Now, Ryan is known for his stupid moved, is he stupid enough to kill someone who made such an issue about him? (its ryan). Now, I could be looking way into things right now, as i usually do but maybe he claimed, told by his scum mates, obv then sataric made this post and inorder to counteract this they killed sataric to make it look like a frame?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sataric made such a big post on why we shouldnt lynch him thus bringing light onto him, i just dont like the situation

Well I've got a whole theory behind you already. How about you explain it? Or maybe actually do some reading and find it. Stop being so god damn lazy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

How about you stay active in the game for once in your life and actually contribute. I'm sick to death of your lazy play style. You do nothing so why do you keep joining the games? Read over, address any questions or conserns about you and then contribute.

Also I'll be placing my vote on Ryan for reasons I have stated throughout the day period.

Basically, in short, you believe that Ryan only roleclaimed so early and so quick because his scummates told him to, correct? Because if that is your theory, I have to at least agree with you that this is very probable.
Please let me know if I am misinterpreting your posts.

 

[Cory]

yes now vote please

 

[Axeler137]

lynch or lose - a state in the game where u must lynch scum or u lose the game

Alright thanks. Makes sense now.

 

[f11]

Hmm I small part if me thinks Ryan is innocent but a piece of me thinks he came up with the scheme with if scum members if he is. But anything is better then no lynch. Also it doesn't make us seem confuse about his role late game.

 

[Axeler137]

Though there is a chance that Ryan or Karla could be scum, I still don't think that there is enough proof that Ryan is scum. I just can't, for whatever reason, bring myself to that conclusion. I will stick to what I said before and if it bites me in the butt then oh well. (Plus, my vote doesn't even matter. Looks like Ryan is going to get lynched anyway.)

 

[toastia]

Alright, I'm in here, just in time. I've voted for ryan88 so that the day may end. I'm very sorry I wasn't here to contribute and actively post, but I had to get an algebra calculator for class and then I had to type a paper. Anyways, I'm here now, and I'm going to share my thoughts on certain scummy players once the day post goes up.

 

[Lauren]

Alright. I just went through all your posts and here's all that you have said in this thread about ryan:

Basically, in short, you believe that Ryan only roleclaimed so early and so quick because his scummates told him to, correct? Because if that is your theory, I have to at least agree with you that this is very probable.
Please let me know if I am misinterpreting your posts.

I dislike how you named the spoiler "special reasons" patronising.

But yes it is. Ryan usually only roleclaims when he feels like he has to to stay alive or when he's at least checked in. Never as his first post. I feel his scum mates are using this as a plan, make Ryan do his dumb ass role claiming and people will think it's normal Ryan.

Now Ryan is a distraction in himself, he does nothing and expects to win by not contributing, I feel even if he isn't scum or 3rd party, still a lynch worth while. Better than no lynch.