Mafia TBT Mini Mafia XV: Pokémon Colosseum [End Game]

lol but I was having a lot of fun pulling strings!

I wonder if I was choked by a makuhita or killed by Miror B.

wth you told me after dc mafia ended that you wished you were mafia again in this one :(

RIP Blu Rose/Alice/Crystal. There's two extra kills so I'm assuming its 2 - Mafia, 1 - Miror B, 1 - Makuhita? And yeah when I have time I'm going to look back at what Dad posted and compare it to what he pmed me about other players in dc mafia, maybe there will be similarities in how he talks about his scummates.
 
Well that was an interesting night.

For everyone asking who I wanted to make a case against, I dont have anything to offer since they were not in the skype convo with everyone else. I have some free time today so I am going to go back and look at posts to see if anything sticks out.
 
You are a Townie. You have your voice and your vote, and you have full access to the Pok?mon catching system. Each trainer will start with a random Pok?mon.
Your starting Pok?mon: Furret
My Role PM.
 
I think that Tom is probably mafia.

-----

Just like Madoka Magica mafia (and pretty much every other game where he is scum) Tom has barely been posting or contributing - almost to the point of being modkilled. The little that he actually does post is a mixture of obvious statements combined with jokes and non-helpful comments. He also keeps blaming work, which I understand, but only to a certain point. He hasn't been posting any reads on players. He's definitely more vocal than this when town.

RIP Justice and Yui-Z. Really sus of Cory, stupid typical town behavior or not.

The one lynch candidate he suggested was obviously town. I think he was working together with Dad to get a bandwagon going.

If its the chat I had been in, Justice, Alise, Cory, Yui, and Caraid were all there.

Strong possibility that Tom was smart enough to figure out from this chat that Yui & Justice were Rui, and that's why they ended up dead.

Personally I think I'll be voting for Truffle to recieve Slugma. They're my top town read, followed by Dad

Dad was his second top town read? It was pretty obvious that Dad was scum, and Tom is smarter than that.

Tom:

This is one of the two games where I can't get a read on you, the other being Madoka where you turned out to be Mafia anyways. Even though you have a new job and stuff, you still seem to be lagging behind and not reading up almost? I don't know, all I know is that I'm getting the same feelings now as I did in Madoka Magica, and thus you land on my suspect list.

Suspicion Level: Medium for inactivity

I'll admit that it's pretty weak evidence to use this. But Blu Rose ended up dying and she pointed out some of Tom's flaws. However, this is the perspective of a confirmed townie - so keep it in mind.
 
thts a really weak case imo

blu is a boy btw

tom should b out w some reads soon but im lazy until posts r filtered {r they? hnng}

he was like this in 1 mafia game but idk ill check if im not 2 lazy
 
I cant really get a read on Tom because even though we are super de duper close, he has started a job in the past week, and when hes working we don't talk, and hes exhausted when he gets home, so I am not sure if hes just a disinterested townie, or he really cannot help being inactive as the job and stuff. I am by no means defending him, I'm just stating that I cannot get a read on him.

Another thing, I think we should pay close attention to Blus list as it could lead to why mafia or 3rd party killed them, as they could have highlighted a mafia member.
 
Crystal - TRAINER (TOWNIE) - is dead.
??? (DECEASED?)

Did anyone else notice this? Crystal's Pokemon is unamed and may still be alive. Don't know how this is relevant but now I'm super confused on what happened last night since Pokemon should die with their trainers.

@Truffle: some parts of your case I agree with but some of it is contradicting (eg. You are the top townread followed by Dad, so following your logic you are also scum?).

Also if Dad was obvious as scum why didn't you push to lynch him day 1?
 
RIP Sharky for pasting his Role PM -.-

Even though Truffle's case isn't exactly the most strongest, I'm still keeping an eye on Tom. Whenever I think he's Town, he's actually Mafia and vice versa.

I'm also keeping an eye on Ryan, he completely slipped by in Transformers Mafia.
 
Is Ryan going to get modkilled? I thought posting the role pm is against mafia rules, but on the other hand, maybe hes not getting killed because that is not his true role..
 
RIP Sharky for pasting his Role PM -.-

Even though Truffle's case isn't exactly the most strongest, I'm still keeping an eye on Tom. Whenever I think he's Town, he's actually Mafia and vice versa.

I'm also keeping an eye on Ryan, he completely slipped by in Transformers Mafia.

What do you mean?I asked the host if I could post it?In the rules it says you may post a part of your host pm if you get permission from the host first.:3
 
What do you mean?I asked the host if I could post it?In the rules it says you may post a part of your host pm if you get permission from the host first.:3
Sorry about that, I'm used to people not asking the host for permission, I think you're the first person ever to actually ask, lol.
 
Sorry for not being on yesterday.I went to my cousins 4th birthday party.Then when I got home I went to sleep.I'm going to maeke a sus list soon!^-^

I have reasons for being inactive.:3 I'm a Trainer/Townie
Reasons being the party of reasons being because you're Trainer/Townie?

RIP Alice, Blu, Crystal
Looks like Dad was scum after all, no one will miss you

Since Dad likes to use fake convos with his scum partners (Mafia Disconnected), I'm starting to worry if his argument against Cariad was either single-sided or staged. Possibly Alise's argument too.

I'll make a few more points of interest later.
Has anyone actually gone back through the thread yet and looked? Or are we just going to sit here and parrot each other until somebody does it or mafia kills us?

gg no re (get bent Dad-chan!~)

I think that Tom is probably mafia.

-----

Just like Madoka Magica mafia (and pretty much every other game where he is scum) Tom has barely been posting or contributing - almost to the point of being modkilled. The little that he actually does post is a mixture of obvious statements combined with jokes and non-helpful comments. He also keeps blaming work, which I understand, but only to a certain point. He hasn't been posting any reads on players. He's definitely more vocal than this when town.

The one lynch candidate he suggested was obviously town. I think he was working together with Dad to get a bandwagon going.

Strong possibility that Tom was smart enough to figure out from this chat that Yui & Justice were Rui, and that's why they ended up dead.

Dad was his second top town read? It was pretty obvious that Dad was scum, and Tom is smarter than that.

I'll admit that it's pretty weak evidence to use this. But Blu Rose ended up dying and she pointed out some of Tom's flaws. However, this is the perspective of a confirmed townie - so keep it in mind.
Perhaps a recent trend in Mafia games where I've been mafia, but I really put in the most work lying and convincing others to the top of the town list in past mafia games as mafia. Really my contributions this game are lacking because the last few days I've been working and the day off I had (Friday) I didn't even want to look at the thread. I mean just skimming through it again, nothing stands out as obviously scum behavior.

Lynch candidate being Cory? Sorry that my views and Dad's happened to align, I'm just getting tired of people joined mafia games and then ****posting. If you want to ****post go talk about dating villagers or post on 4chan. Plus Cory revealed information (that though accessible to probably a 1/3 of the playerlist) that would have obviously led to a Blue death (or Red/Yellow if his luck was better). Day One I'm going to push players who do dumb****, Cory is no exception.

The chat I've been out of for a week at least (according to Skype), so determining Justice and Yui were both blue is incredibly unlikely. You can ask Caraid or Alise to confirm, maybe one of the many other TBT Members that are currently not in game to vouch. Left it because they were spamming some stupid copy-pasta crap and I didn't feel like getting bombed with that crap constantly in a day. So no, I didn't determine Justice and Yui's alignments from there. I determined Yui was probably blue from the logs and Justice assured me that they were a trainer when they went fishing for info from me. So I found out Justice was blue the same way everyone else did, from their death post.

Dad was my my second top town read for a few reasons:
  • He was active
  • He seemed to be acting in town's interests
  • He was prodding others

Like others said, if you felt he was being very obvious why not bring it up then? Or did you consult someone who had other means?

How can we be sure this just isn't a frame job? You got a PM, Dad got a PM, Blue Leaf got a PM and I got a PM. So five people knew that a case was coming and with night not yet over, Dad probably had enough time to alert his teammates to this. Heck for all we know, the only scum in the list of people who got that PM from Blu Rose is Dad.

thts a really weak case imo

blu is a boy btw

tom should b out w some reads soon but im lazy until posts r filtered {r they? hnng}

he was like this in 1 mafia game but idk ill check if im not 2 lazy
I'll make a seperate post in a bit with some reads. There's no filters so it will take longer and maybe if I'm lucky one will become a case.

Did anyone else notice this? Crystal's Pokemon is unamed and may still be alive. Don't know how this is relevant but now I'm super confused on what happened last night since Pokemon should die with their trainers.

@Truffle: some parts of your case I agree with but some of it is contradicting (eg. You are the top townread followed by Dad, so following your logic you are also scum?).

Also if Dad was obvious as scum why didn't you push to lynch him day 1?
Bringing this back up again because thinking on it now is really strange. Perhaps a legendary Pokemon is in play? There's hidden Pokemon and so far Pokemon seen have either been late game or early game. Hidden Pokemon could be legendaries and Pokemon that had to be transferred from Ruby/Sapphire (Metagross).

RIP Sharky for pasting his Role PM -.-

Even though Truffle's case isn't exactly the most strongest, I'm still keeping an eye on Tom. Whenever I think he's Town, he's actually Mafia and vice versa.

I'm also keeping an eye on Ryan, he completely slipped by in Transformers Mafia.
As you should! Everyone keep an eye on me. Oath2order always likes to point out towards the end game I get sloppy as mafia because the goal is in sight and my silver tongue starts to slip. :)

Sorry about that, I'm used to people not asking the host for permission, I think you're the first person ever to actually ask, lol.
Probably! That or the first that got permission and was actually allowed to share. :/ Usually you're not supposed to share it as it puts blues and of course scum at a disadvantage, though now they also can hide behind "well that PM looks just like mine!" excuse. :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

Theory: What if we're dealing with two Wes? There was two Rui so it doesn't seem that farfetch'd.
 
Reasons being the party of reasons being because you're Trainer/Townie?

Has anyone actually gone back through the thread yet and looked? Or are we just going to sit here and parrot each other until somebody does it or mafia kills us?

gg no re (get bent Dad-chan!~)

Perhaps a recent trend in Mafia games where I've been mafia, but I really put in the most work lying and convincing others to the top of the town list in past mafia games as mafia. Really my contributions this game are lacking because the last few days I've been working and the day off I had (Friday) I didn't even want to look at the thread. I mean just skimming through it again, nothing stands out as obviously scum behavior.

Lynch candidate being Cory? Sorry that my views and Dad's happened to align, I'm just getting tired of people joined mafia games and then ****posting. If you want to ****post go talk about dating villagers or post on 4chan. Plus Cory revealed information (that though accessible to probably a 1/3 of the playerlist) that would have obviously led to a Blue death (or Red/Yellow if his luck was better). Day One I'm going to push players who do dumb****, Cory is no exception.

The chat I've been out of for a week at least (according to Skype), so determining Justice and Yui were both blue is incredibly unlikely. You can ask Caraid or Alise to confirm, maybe one of the many other TBT Members that are currently not in game to vouch. Left it because they were spamming some stupid copy-pasta crap and I didn't feel like getting bombed with that crap constantly in a day. So no, I didn't determine Justice and Yui's alignments from there. I determined Yui was probably blue from the logs and Justice assured me that they were a trainer when they went fishing for info from me. So I found out Justice was blue the same way everyone else did, from their death post.

Dad was my my second top town read for a few reasons:
  • He was active
  • He seemed to be acting in town's interests
  • He was prodding others

Like others said, if you felt he was being very obvious why not bring it up then? Or did you consult someone who had other means?

How can we be sure this just isn't a frame job? You got a PM, Dad got a PM, Blue Leaf got a PM and I got a PM. So five people knew that a case was coming and with night not yet over, Dad probably had enough time to alert his teammates to this. Heck for all we know, the only scum in the list of people who got that PM from Blu Rose is Dad.

I'll make a seperate post in a bit with some reads. There's no filters so it will take longer and maybe if I'm lucky one will become a case.

Bringing this back up again because thinking on it now is really strange. Perhaps a legendary Pokemon is in play? There's hidden Pokemon and so far Pokemon seen have either been late game or early game. Hidden Pokemon could be legendaries and Pokemon that had to be transferred from Ruby/Sapphire (Metagross).

As you should! Everyone keep an eye on me. Oath2order always likes to point out towards the end game I get sloppy as mafia because the goal is in sight and my silver tongue starts to slip. :)

Probably! That or the first that got permission and was actually allowed to share. :/ Usually you're not supposed to share it as it puts blues and of course scum at a disadvantage, though now they also can hide behind "well that PM looks just like mine!" excuse. :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

Theory: What if we're dealing with two Wes? There was two Rui so it doesn't seem that farfetch'd.

No,read the text aboe that line.
 
Back
Top