tbt needs to create an established system

Status
Not open for further replies.
I noticed that lately mods just close threads without any explanation. I don't expect them to fully explain why they close things, but some times the threads they close don't seem like they're bad at all? I understand the obvious spam threads, but I've seen some threads get shut down for no reason. Of course, no explanation generates many questions which aren't always answered.

As for the whole "this is an AC forum!!" argument, yeah, you are right, the purpose of this site is Animal Crossing. But it's more than that; it's about the way things are handled apart from the ~AC~ theme.

Explanations would be nice. What would also be nice is if they'd just leave some sort of message, even a one-word explanation so we could see who it was locking the threads. Then we could see if there's a certain moderator who is just a little too trigger-happy with closing threads. ;)
 
when i got my ban recently i tried to contact mods bc it was actually really unfair and i dont think i ever got a reply :/
 
Exactly that too! From what I know you can ask for TBT in Re-Tail if you're also accepting IGB. But I'm also seeing that thread in the TBT Marketplace auctioning off villagers and I'm like shouldn't that be in the Villager Trading Plaza? Should I report it? Who knows I don't anymore

Justin told me I (used to) send in too many "post quality" reports. He said most of the things I reported weren't against the rules. Since I don't really understand that very well, I've stopped all together. I thought I was helping, but I was wrong. So...I don't know what's what. LOL

- - - Post Merge - - -

Is that after creation or after the last post?

I really like the latter.

5 or 6 months after the last post, it gets locked because it's not active anymore.
 
There's a lot of rules the community has formed that are communicated through mind waves like trading forum Bells for in-game Bells being on the TBT forum. :p

I love it when threads go a bit crazy like this.

TBT for IGB exchange has always been a thing; buying/selling with TBT in Re-Tail and buying/selling with IGB in TBT Marketplace used to apparently not be allowed (yet it was??)

I know this won't happen, but the general guides/FAQs just need a massive update, and maybe a link to them automatically PM'd to every new user. That way the rules are clear and concise and we don't have to even discuss this.
 
I noticed that lately mods just close threads without any explanation. I don't expect them to fully explain why they close things, but some times the threads they close don't seem like they're bad at all? I understand the obvious spam threads, but I've seen some threads get shut down for no reason. Of course, no explanation generates many questions which aren't always answered.

As for the whole "this is an AC forum!!" argument, yeah, you are right, the purpose of this site is Animal Crossing. But it's more than that; it's about the way things are handled apart from the ~AC~ theme.

exactly my point. maybe the members would be happier if they were to be informed about whats happening, rather than the 'im a moderator assume this lock was just' approach. this applies for warnings, infractions, bans and locks. dont just state what rule it broke, explain how it broke that rule in depth, so we arent left wondering what we did wrong, or what was wrong with the thread that got banned

and there should be sanctions set in stone, instead of leaving things up to
moderator discretion in the moment
because thats the definition of a crooked system
 
Last edited:
Justin told me I (used to) send in too many "post quality" reports. He said most of the things I reported weren't against the rules. Since I don't really understand that very well, I've stopped all together. I thought I was helping, but I was wrong. So...I don't know what's what. LOL

Meh. Unless it's definite spam, people don't care much about post quality. :p
 
Justin told me I (used to) send in too many "post quality" reports. He said most of the things I reported weren't against the rules. Since I don't really understand that very well, I've stopped all together. I thought I was helping, but I was wrong. So...I don't know what's what. LOL

Yeah I just report things that are obviously on the wrong board or just 100% someone being nasty 'cause otherwise I have no idea either LOL.
I just know that reaction images aren't allowed by themselves, even though some people get away with it :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Yeah I just report things that are obviously on the wrong board or just 100% someone being nasty 'cause otherwise I have no idea either LOL.
I just know that reaction images aren't allowed by themselves, even though some people get away with it :rolleyes:

I thought posting one or two words in a forum where you earn TBT for your posts was a post quality issue. Apparently, that's only true if it's something like, "Me too" or "I agree" or "This." Still, I'm careful to type out a full sentence in case they want to slap me with an infraction.
 
I've contaced mods about warning / bans / etc and I've never received a reply...
Did you report the warnings or did you PM a mod? I think the former works better but if you didn't get a reply at all that's kinda crap :/

I thought posting one or two words in a forum where you earn TBT for your posts was a post quality issue. Apparently, that's only true if it's something like, "Me too" or "I agree" or "This." Still, I'm careful to type out a full sentence in case they want to slap me with an infraction.

Same like I'm always going "is this post saying enough oh no" before posting anything
 
mods should really ask us before they lock threads. if were unhappy, well tell them. if theres a flame war, ban those users from the thread, but dont ruin it for everyone else
 
Last edited:
Hi guys.

First, I want to say that there are some very valid points being brought up by some of you, and I do think that there are some topics being touched upon here that warrant further discussion within the staff. I understand that it can be frustrating when it seems as though things are being handled in a way that's inconsistent, and I will say that we do try to make larger decisions in a way that's consistent and sensible, but there are times when it's difficult to get a full consensus from everyone and whomever is online at the time just acts on something, especially when it seems like a small and/or routine thing that shouldn't warrant a discussion. I do see how this might seem confusing when you're on the outside looking in and something is done that doesn't seem to make sense, but none of us are perfect and we all try to do the best we can.

I don't like the fact that you have to be best friends with the mods to be exempt from harsh punishments.
It honestly makes no sense...

I'm sorry you feel this way and while I don't believe any of the staff intentionally practices favoritism, it's particularly sucky for me to read since I honestly didn't have any friends here on TBT prior to joining the staff (yay reclusion!) Although I have made a couple of friends since, I can say that I would have absolutely no qualms with doling out punishment to any of them exactly as I would to anyone else who broke the rules.

As far as everything else goes, all I can say is that it's only natural that we as moderators are going to occasionally make decisions that other people don't agree with, just as there are disputes between members over not seeing eye to eye. I don't see anything wrong with discussing these things so long as the discussion remains respectful and constructive and isn't an attempt to single out one specific person and make them feel bad. I also want to say that my inbox is always open if someone desires clarification on anything I've done, or even to drop a suggestion on how to improve the way we do things so long as it's a valid concern and not just "u mods suk" or something of the like. ;)
 
mods should really ask us before they lock threads. if were unhappy, well tell them. if theres a flame war, ban those users from the thread, but dont ruin it for everyone else

As nice as that would be I feel like it would be too much for the mods since they are obviously understaffed. If they decode to keep their numbers then a simple explanation before closing would be nice.
 
mods should really ask us before they lock threads. if were unhappy, well tell them. if theres a flame war, ban those users from the thread, but dont ruin it for everyone else

I have only seen one mod actually delete posts in order to make a flopped thread good again. Sure the thread was locked while posts were deleted 'cause the inside was a massive **** fest but it was up and running back to normal right after.
 
Did you report the warnings or did you PM a mod? I think the former works better but if you didn't get a reply at all that's kinda crap :/



Same like I'm always going "is this post saying enough oh no" before posting anything

I reported the PMs and I emailed them after I got banned
 
Hi guys.

First, I want to say that there are some very valid points being brought up by some of you, and I do think that there are some topics being touched upon here that warrant further discussion within the staff. I understand that it can be frustrating when it seems as though things are being handled in a way that's inconsistent, and I will say that we do try to make larger decisions in a way that's consistent and sensible, but there are times when it's difficult to get a full consensus from everyone and whomever is online at the time just acts on something, especially when it seems like a small and/or routine thing that shouldn't warrant a discussion. I do see how this might seem confusing when you're on the outside looking in and something is done that doesn't seem to make sense, but none of us are perfect and we all try to do the best we can.



I'm sorry you feel this way and while I don't believe any of the staff intentionally practices favoritism, it's particularly sucky for me to read since I honestly didn't have any friends here on TBT prior to joining the staff (yay reclusion!) Although I have made a couple of friends since, I can say that I would have absolutely no qualms with doling out punishment to any of them exactly as I would to anyone else who broke the rules.

As far as everything else goes, all I can say is that it's only natural that we as moderators are going to occasionally make decisions that other people don't agree with, just as there are disputes between members over not seeing eye to eye. I don't see anything wrong with discussing these things so long as the discussion remains respectful and constructive and isn't an attempt to single out one specific person and make them feel bad. I also want to say that my inbox is always open if someone desires clarification on anything I've done, or even to drop a suggestion on how to improve the way we do things so long as it's a valid concern and not just "u mods suk" or something of the like. ;)

u mods suk :(

(I'm jk thank you for actually answering and allowing us to reply back to you, bless you)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top