Mafia TBT Newbie Mini Mafia (Game Over)

[FireNinja1]

But, I don't think that's really worth a lynch vote. It's day 2 and one of our best players has died, it's a total dead end. And I don't think she was dodging evidence more like showing how there are other players who hasn't really contributed anything.

You do realize that showing how other players are suspicious without a defense from the person themselves is dodging evidence, right? This "defense" is a series of cases on other people, and she has failed to sufficiently address the issues involving her.

 

[Jennwa]

gnoixaim is suspicious enough for me though, and I think lynching is better than No Lynch for sure considering how Mafia outnumbers Town at the moment. What do you consider as proper evidence? I might try to look back at some other people's posts and analyze a bit more if needed. (Town people who should do the same)

- - - Post Merge - - -



I mean how the ratio is real close, not outnumber. Like 7:4.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ignore the gnoixaim part in the second post merge. Gah!

Remember the serial killer, that means 41.66% of the players alive are bad. We definitely need to lynch, but we need to really think it over. And blues need to use their powers very wisely.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was going to post a case on Beardo involving this same reason, but I'd rather address this first.

Your reasoning: "I'm not the only one avoiding contribution! Look at all of these people!" That's a desperate attempt to shift attention. That is not a defense, at all, whatsoever. That looks like dodging of evidence too, which is never good for Town. For the time being, you have my vote.

Also I agree with this. Throwing a bunch of names up with pretty much no real evidence to me seems like a bad attempt at trying to divert attention and make it seem like you are contributing. I wasn't really suspicious of gnoixaim until they made that post.

 

[Qwerty111]

don't tell me that you didn't notice I voted for myself... I didn't even say I had proof that puprl was scum I was only suspecting of him and enden up voting for myself since everyone was following " THe most skilled player Thoughts" Totally B#.

Voting for yourself doesn't exclude you from being suspicious sadly. That was one weak defence...

 

[Jennwa]

Voting for yourself doesn't exclude you from being suspicious sadly. That was one weak defence...

Sure he doesn't have the best defences and seems sketchy at times, but the thing is... he claimed Jay Leno. Unless someone else claims Jay Leno then it's pointless to suspect him or waste a lynch on him.

 

[gnoixaim]

I was going to post a case on Beardo involving this same reason, but I'd rather address this first.

Your reasoning: "I'm not the only one avoiding contribution! Look at all of these people!" That's a desperate attempt to shift attention. That is not a defense, at all, whatsoever. That looks like dodging of evidence too, which is never good for Town. For the time being, you have my vote.

I didn't mean for it to come off that way (I'm re-reading it now) I'm just stating that Farobi's reasons to want to lynch me make no sense, especially since other members haven't been contributing much either.

(this might sound repetitive)
Nikki and Beardo have not contributed town with any "new" information. They pop in, quote someone, and that's that. I understand that it seems like I'm doing the same thing, but the fact they're not very vocal makes them seem like they're hiding something. Both of them haven't contributed anything new for Day 2's lynch, even though they've been online and reading the thread. I know this doesn't seem like a strong defense, but I'm at least trying to help town by posting (which obviously comes back to make me look like an idiot) and making time for the game.

-------------

"This game uses a semi-open setup; that is, all possible roles are given, but the number of each role is unknown. Some roles may not even appear in the game. A player's role will be revealed when they die."

I also noticed this now - Kyuby claimed to be our Jay Leno and got roleblocked last night. Kyuby can easily be fooling all of us (since not all roles appear in the game). Okasan was the only loss for us, so whoever blocked Kyuby obviously could have prevented him from killing another member. (if he was mafia or SK)

It wasn't just about me, and lol I got roleblocked, that was useless on me

 

[Kildor]

I didn't mean for it to come off that way (I'm re-reading it now) I'm just stating that Farobi's reasons to want to lynch me make no sense, especially since other members haven't been contributing much either.

(this might sound repetitive)
Nikki and Beardo have not contributed town with any "new" information. They pop in, quote someone, and that's that. I understand that it seems like I'm doing the same thing, but the fact they're not very vocal makes them seem like they're hiding something. Both of them haven't contributed anything new for Day 2's lynch, even though they've been online and reading the thread. I know this doesn't seem like a strong defense, but I'm at least trying to help town by posting (which obviously comes back to make me look like an idiot) and making time for the game.

-------------

"This game uses a semi-open setup; that is, all possible roles are given, but the number of each role is unknown. Some roles may not even appear in the game. A player's role will be revealed when they die."

I also noticed this now - Kyuby claimed to be our Jay Leno and got roleblocked last night. Kyuby can easily be fooling all of us (since not all roles appear in the game). Okasan was the only loss for us, so whoever blocked Kyuby obviously could have prevented him from killing another member. (if he was mafia or SK)

I've been thinking about this for awhile, it is possible that certain roles do not appear. So that's why anyone can claim Jay Leno, and look innocent.

 

[Qwerty111]

Sure he doesn't have the best defences and seems sketchy at times, but the thing is... he claimed Jay Leno. Unless someone else claims Jay Leno then it's pointless to suspect him or waste a lynch on him.

True, True. I haven't seen anyone claim Jay Leno and Kyuby said him/herself that he/she would vig shot anyone who claimed it anyway.

 

[Jennwa]

True, True. I haven't seen anyone claim Jay Leno and Kyuby said him/herself that he/she would vig shot anyone who claimed it anyway.

Well there is a chance that there is no Jay Leno (like the people above are talking about). I don't know what to believe :|

 

[Qwerty111]

Well there is a chance that there is no Jay Leno (like the people above are talking about). I don't know what to believe :|[/QUOTE ]
There is no Jay Leno so nobody suspects a thing. Clever.Doesn't Jay Leno appear to be the:[COLOR="#FF0000]"The Agent of The Dome?"[/COLOR]though?

 

[Jennwa]

^ Yes, so it's probably the safest role for a mafia member to claim. But they'd have to get lucky and hope no one else had that role.

---

If every role was included then that means there'd only be two Helix Worshippers. And they are both dead. I think there's usually a larger volume of greens. If another Helix Worshipper dies we'll know for sure that some roles have been omitted.

Also, I'm thinking there's a good chance that the serial killer doesn't exist, but we should assume they do. Sooo yeah, I guess we can't be 100% sure that Kyuby is Jay Leno.

 

[Beardo]

The way you word this quote has caught my attention a bit. Agreeing with people's opinions doesn't necessarily raise red flags, but it doesn't make you look Town either - and that's more or less how I feel about your posting style. FireNinja1 addressed a really good point as well. It seems to me that you're trying to bring in any sort of evidence to make your candidates seem more scummy then they actually are.

Thank you! I honestly don't see how agreeing makes me suspicious

- - - Post Merge - - -

(this might sound repetitive)
Nikki and Beardo have not contributed town with any "new" information. They pop in, quote someone, and that's that. I understand that it seems like I'm doing the same thing, but the fact they're not very vocal makes them seem like they're hiding something. Both of them haven't contributed anything new for Day 2's lynch, even though they've been online and reading the thread. I know this doesn't seem like a strong defense, but I'm at least trying to help town by posting (which obviously comes back to make me look like an idiot) and making time for the game.

I haven't been on the thread almost at all today, but (for now and future reference) I'm on my ipad, and leave this tab open on safari. I'm not sure about Nikki though...

Now excuse me while I got and contribute instead of just quoting other people. Now I'm going to be late to my friends, but I guess being a few minutes late is better than being lynched.

 

[gnoixaim]

Thank you! I honestly don't see how agreeing makes me suspicious

But me agreeing to anyone is apparently suspicious?

 

[Beardo]

But me agreeing to anyone is apparently suspicious?

I don't think I ever said that...

 

[gnoixaim]

I don't think I ever said that...

It's more of a response to the others

 

[Beardo]

The way you word this quote has caught my attention a bit. Agreeing with people's opinions doesn't necessarily raise red flags, but it doesn't make you look Town either - and that's more or less how I feel about your posting style. FireNinja1 addressed a really good point as well. It seems to me that you're trying to bring in any sort of evidence to make your candidates seem more scummy then they actually are.

My main suspects are Kuyby, Nikki, and gnoixaim currently. Before you pounce on me for having no evidence, I want to ask if it would be OK if I gathered it now, organized it, then post it when I have time? I need to go to a friends place soon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's more of a response to the others

Oh, I'm sorry ^^

 

[hanzy]

Yes, please go into it. It might help even just a little bit.

Okasan had great opinions, and he had good observation skills, so yes it is a possibility.

Ultimately, I had almost no read on Purpl, and it felt safer at the time to vote him than someone I was beginning to think was town. If I had voted no lynch, kyuby would still have died, so I voted Purpl. I felt like he'd be more dangerous if he was mafia than kyuby.

 

[f11]

From re-reading the op it does seem weird that Kyuby roleclaimed a role that shows up as mafia. There's a chance no one spoke up because no one playing has that role.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I would just vig shot anyone who clamis to be Jay Leno, and also I don't think I will survive past this night as mafia will be all over me if I naded any of their members on my acusations.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I named* any

You, would just vig shoot? I don't know if I read this right. But in another quote you say you have no abilities....

- - - Post Merge - - -

It wasn't just about me, and lol I got roleblocked, that was useless on me

Ah, I found it. And here they are saying that they have no abilities.

 

[NikkiNikki]

Sorry guys, I was busy today.

ANYWAY I did some calculations and it seems there is one Helix worshiper left. And I believe all roles are claimed.

Right Now I am checking the posts from waay back to see if I catch something odd, I'll write my conclusions later when I find some strong evidences because the people on my suspicious list are Hanzy, Kuyby, Gnoixaim, and Qweery11

@gnoixaim you say I haven't been contributing and been quoting/agreeing with other, but you seem to have skipped some of my evidence posts. it seem like you are just pointing the finger at others without some solid evidence.

 

[NikkiNikki]

@Purpl: remember that there's a Jay Leno in the game who's townies side but will come out as "Agent of the dome".

^^ This worries me a bit even tho kyuby is "Jay Leno" he may come out as agent of dome?

Qweery: I seen him/her contributing a bit more on day 2 but not so much on day 1

don't tell me that you didn't notice I voted for myself... I didn't even say I had proof that puprl was scum I was only suspecting of him and enden up voting for myself since everyone was following " THe most skilled player Thoughts" Totally B#.

So what if everyone was following the most skilled player some of us are newbies at this and seen their way of getting evidence and posting is a good thing to take notes on.

I am suspicious of Hanzy because of that last moment vote change. yes you have explained yourself, but you were so into lynching Kyuby, I just find it odd.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aww man it didnt merge:/

 

[Qwerty111]

Who's Qweery XD It's Qwerty. If in doubt, first six letters of The keyboard.

To the above^

I wasn't active in day 1 because I had school on those days so that ate up 7 hours of The time that I could be posting.
And yes, I am active in Day 2 because I don't have school so thats +7hrs that I can post.