Mafia TBT Nub Mafia V: Daycare Mafia - Endgame - Town wins!

[Chrystina]

guys please re-consider no lynch. i am regretting bringing it up lol.
it really would not hurt town to vote someone. it will help mafia. now i'm just seeing it as anyone who wants NL is scum trying to throw off town & get that extra kill in.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oops. I always forget the profile thing. I see now! Thanks for clearing that up.

On that note, I guess I really don't know who to vote for now. If something doesn't come up, I'll go with no lynch. The more of us the better, amrite?

- - - Post Merge - - -

On the role thing, I guess if we all say our roles, we might figure it out. Though I doubt it, since Vanilla Townie seems repeated a lot, (In row 1, but also filled up with in row 3) so a mafia could claim that and we'd be none the wiser. Role calling is a late game thing though, so it might be best to leave that out. I just wanted to mention it, I guess. Not to mention it makes mafia go haywire killing all the town with roles.

LOL what?! "if we all say our roles".... im sorry but did you think that through before suggesting it?
everyone would claim town.

 

[tae]

guys please re-consider no lynch. i am regretting bringing it up lol.
it really would not hurt town to vote someone. it will help mafia. now i'm just seeing it as anyone who wants NL is scum trying to throw off town & get that extra kill in.

i'm down for a half blind lynch.
who you got in mind though?

i don't think i've seen much evidence towards who would be a good idea to lynch other than lynn.
only because i find their opening post to be a little off setting with how direct it was? but then again, maybe they're just excited?

 

[N e s s]

Current Vote Count
​

Lynn105-1: Alexi

Currently Not Voting: Inkling, Helloxcutiee, Runeraider, Taesaek, Mother of all Llamas, Qwerty111, Lynn105, toadsworthy​

---

You currently have 6 hours and 30 minutes left to vote. Currently, Lynn105 is set to be lynched.

 

[BungoTheElf]

Oops. I always forget the profile thing. I see now! Thanks for clearing that up.

On that note, I guess I really don't know who to vote for now. If something doesn't come up, I'll go with no lynch. The more of us the better, amrite?

- - - Post Merge - - -

On the role thing, I guess if we all say our roles, we might figure it out. Though I doubt it, since Vanilla Townie seems repeated a lot, (In row 1, but also filled up with in row 3) so a mafia could claim that and we'd be none the wiser. Role calling is a late game thing though, so it might be best to leave that out. I just wanted to mention it, I guess. Not to mention it makes mafia go haywire killing all the town with roles.

but what if the
[17:21] <+Dolby> And, magical townie happyland?
[17:21] <+SarasaKat> This is prob my last game guys
[17:21] <+lynn105> hey friends
[17:21] <+SarasaKat> I'm townie
[17:21] <+Dolby> Because I'm townie
[17:21] <+lynn105> I'm townie

so even if they're got the matric 5 or 6 or whatever in the op, there still might not be all those roles played?
ooohhhh this will be interesting. and goldie isn't bad but im more of a daisy kinda guy. ;')

and yes, not all the roles in the matrix will be in the game
::(((( I can't disagree daisy is cute too

Currently, Lynn105 is set to be lynched.

DED

and yeah besides me (lol) who else would we lynch tho I mean I don't suspect anyone either or have any evidence against anyone :I

honestly I don't know what to say bc it's just going to bring that "i am town" controversy again lol like I'm the only one who knows I am town besides scum gdi (if you need this explained I will slap you)

 

[tae]

but what if the
[17:21] <+Dolby> And, magical townie happyland?
[17:21] <+SarasaKat> This is prob my last game guys
[17:21] <+lynn105> hey friends
[17:21] <+SarasaKat> I'm townie
[17:21] <+Dolby> Because I'm townie
[17:21] <+lynn105> I'm townie


DED

and yeah besides me (lol) who else would we lynch tho I mean I don't suspect anyone either or have any evidence against anyone :I

honestly I don't know what to say bc it's just going to bring that "i am town" controversy again lol like I'm the only one who knows I am town besides scum gdi (if you need this explained I will slap you)

rip lynn. :'(

i don't know it's too early to tell anything at all. man this probably goes haywire in later days/ nights. my goodness.

 

[Chrystina]

i'm down for a half blind lynch.
who you got in mind though?

i don't think i've seen much evidence towards who would be a good idea to lynch other than lynn.
only because i find their opening post to be a little off setting with how direct it was? but then again, maybe they're just excited?

yeah pretty much just lynn. unless something else happens, but 6 hours to go so time is ticking.
i def get how their opening post could be taken two ways, but i see sort of a scum bandwagon with qwerty also defending lynn so early in the game. because why would town question a suspicion on someone else who isn't even confirmed town?

Hey everyone what's up I'll try my best to help town

poor jubs

i think this is suspicious bc she's trying so hard to show her support for town.

perfect post to get scum reading started.

Sup. I would of posted sooner but the game started at like 3AM my time so I wasn't awake XD



What part of it is suspicious? It looks pretty average for a first post on a mafia game :I (then again what do I know)

no real reason to question that suspicion imo, unless defending fellow scum partner.


i did quickly quote toadsworthy on this as well, since he mentioned it earlier. but now i'm definitely seeing it. both of them want a no lynch (although lynn has been more open to lynch), even after logical explanation of why NL is not a good idea for town.


im sorry this is sort of rushed, have to go out real quick. wish i could give more info/elaborate more. but i will be back shortly.

 

[BungoTheElf]

yeah pretty much just lynn. unless something else happens, but 6 hours to go so time is ticking.
i def get how their opening post could be taken two ways, but i see sort of a scum bandwagon with qwerty also defending lynn so early in the game. because why would town question a suspicion on someone else who isn't even confirmed town?



perfect post to get scum reading started.

no real reason to question that suspicion imo, unless defending fellow scum partner.


i did quickly quote toadsworthy on this as well, since he mentioned it earlier. but now i'm definitely seeing it. both of them want a no lynch (although lynn has been more open to lynch), even after logical explanation of why NL is not a good idea for town.


im sorry this is sort of rushed, have to go out real quick. wish i could give more info/elaborate more. but i will be back shortly.

Idk maybe they have the same thought process as me as to how it really didn't seem suspicious at all? I mean qwerty didn't even defend me...they just...agreed lmao
and ofc... no one is confirmed town but it was a greeting wtf why would it be suspicious
I've already explained this all I'm gonna go nuts
(about the greeting- not to do with qwerty,which we can talk about with you if you want but I'm so done with this **** about saying how wanting to try my best is suspicious CHRIST )

and for NL it did seem like a good idea? like I said earlier I didn't really understand it fully (probably bc I was reading it over and over at 12 am) toadsworthy's reasoning to nl did seem to make a lot more sense than runeraider's at the time, I explained it earlier this morning on how I felt about it and I really didn't get it if you didn't read it lol

I really tried to make sense of your post there but I could really not keep up with your logic lol
I could bring up a buuuuunch of kind of contradicting and assuming things(towards myself in regards to this lynch/no lynch (note to self and you if you read: I'm considered suspicious, that nl=I live,good points but I don't really buy all of it scum might be smart,mentors new methods) key points that would be pathetic to bring up anyways since whenever I try to make a good content filled post everyone ignores it anyways) but It's easier to just say I kinda of do see your point in having a lynch now that I think about it but I'm really inbetween with everuthing I mean I even tried drawing out diagrams for the cycles but there's too many possiblities to branch out of what happens I mean someone could hit scum over night too many factors out too many assuming we don't get any scum at all means that scum is probs leading or just bandwagoning think people
I mean if I have to say overall I just thank thant the best thing to do with the low chance of hitting mafia today is to have 7:2 than 6:2 starting off into night where we know it will be 5:2 at the start of day 2 (refer to part where scum may be smart- info may not help, may even be misleading)
I think too deep and I've been writting this post for over an hour good ****ing night yes im bitter thansk for asking

I mean even if I did go for lynch who else would we go for? me lol
and that would just be a waste and lower our numbers

sorry for qwerty getting dragged into this man but I mean at the same time I can't exactly trust you either lol
(if you need an explanation for this too then it's because putting them towards my side in the beginning would seem better than inkling's side of being quick to point fingers) I don't think qwerty was defending me but I guess it can be seen that way so I can see why you guys are suspicious

and sorry if i seem to be rude it's because being under pressure is not a strong point for me and I'm trying not to get worked up too hard

 

[toadsworthy]

ummm I'm still not understanding why no lynch gives mafia control? if we mislynch guys its gonna lower our numbers, bottom line! I will re-read over the thing Rune Raider wrote, but still like.... wtf, I don't see how keeping the numbers we have gives power to the mafia (however I do see them getting more influence by us killing someone and us being wrong)

if I re-read it and understand I will post saying ok lets go... but this is literally my first real game of mafia, so I just don't know whats happening

 

[mother of all llamas]

I won't meet the end of the deadline as I will be out so I'll place my vote on Qwerty. Something just isn't right about them...

 

[tae]

but what is alexi is mafia then because they're so adamant on the lynch of lynn?
maybe their persistent push towards a day 1 lynch can also be called into question?


bottom line is, which is the best strategical play, lynch day 1, possibly kill a townie. down one number. night starts, down another townie. then what?

maybe we should go for the nl?
there isn't much to base a lynch off of. so **** it, i could possibly see the perks for nl on day 1.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I won't meet the end of the deadline as I will be out so I'll place my vote on Qwerty. Something just isn't right about them...

because they were quick to defend? whats your reasoning behind it though?

 

[Qwerty111]

Oh my gosh. We have literally no leads to anything. Nothing. Ziltch. And you seriously just want to randomly select a person, and hope for the best? The percentages are against us. I don't care if blah, blah, no lynching will only save us a night. I'm not gonna bandwagon on anybody else just so I don't stick out or whatever.To be completely honest, changing my opinion now would probably make me look worse, right? So, I'm not going to. If nothing comes up in a hour or so, I'll just vote no lynch. It doesn't really help that I'm absolutely rubbish at analyzing text either, then I could be sort of helpful. Oh well. Sorry in advance if this ruins things, everyone.

 

[tae]

Oh my gosh. We have literally no leads to anything. Nothing. Ziltch. And you seriously just want to randomly select a person, and hope for the best? The percentages are against us. I don't care if blah, blah, no lynching will only save us a night. I'm not gonna bandwagon on anybody else just so I don't stick out or whatever.To be completely honest, changing my opinion now would probably make me look worse, right? So, I'm not going to. If nothing comes up in a hour or so, I'll just vote no lynch. It doesn't really help that I'm absolutely rubbish at analyzing text either, then I could be sort of helpful. Oh well. Sorry in advance if this ruins things, everyone.

rip qwerty or lynn 2k16. :'(

 

[toadsworthy]

Were gonna be looking at the same odds of getting mafia in a lynch at some point in this game whether its day one or day two or whatever.... however we get more time to weigh our options and decide on whose mafia by not lynching, we are gonna lower our odds of overall success though by expediting the lynching of our own freaking people, so if we aren't sure then we should just bow out....

but seeing as how homie above placed a vote and aint coming back, NL isn't even an option anymore so we should probably look at the posts we do have....

 

[tae]

Were gonna be looking at the same odds of getting mafia in a lynch at some point in this game whether its day one or day two or whatever.... however we get more time to weigh our options and decide on whose mafia by not lynching, we are gonna lower our odds of overall success though by expediting the lynching of our own freaking people, so if we aren't sure then we should just bow out....

but seeing as how homie above placed a vote and aint coming back, NL isn't even an option anymore so we should probably look at the posts we do have....

does it count if they don't use the "format"

also, does a nl require majority rules or does it have to be a legit set number of folks? i should probably go read a ton more again and analyze better than just skimming over it a few times to pick out key points. a a a a a hhh.

if we can get people to reconsider, i'm alright with trying for a nl.

 

[toadsworthy]

you have to think if the flow of this conversation was going towards lynching someone who wasn't mafia, don't you think the mafia would WANT us to then go ahead and lynch someone? and thus expedite the killing off of our own people? so I'm quickly becoming suspicious of Alexi and Runeraider.... if they think they are in the clear they would of course want us to go ahead and lynch somebody, because its not anyone of their mafia goons.... they are trying to create chaos so that they can keep their own heads clean

 

[Chrystina]

Idk maybe they have the same thought process as me as to how it really didn't seem suspicious at all? I mean qwerty didn't even defend me...they just...agreed lmao
and ofc... no one is confirmed town but it was a greeting wtf why would it be suspicious
I've already explained this all I'm gonna go nuts
(about the greeting- not to do with qwerty,which we can talk about with you if you want but I'm so done with this **** about saying how wanting to try my best is suspicious CHRIST )

and for NL it did seem like a good idea? like I said earlier I didn't really understand it fully (probably bc I was reading it over and over at 12 am) toadsworthy's reasoning to nl did seem to make a lot more sense than runeraider's at the time, I explained it earlier this morning on how I felt about it and I really didn't get it if you didn't read it lol

I mean even if I did go for lynch who else would we go for? me lol
and that would just be a waste and lower our numbers

sorry for qwerty getting dragged into this man but I mean at the same time I can't exactly trust you either lol
(if you need an explanation for this too then it's because putting them towards my side in the beginning would seem better than inkling's side of being quick to point fingers) I don't think qwerty was defending me but I guess it can be seen that way so I can see why you guys are suspicious

and sorry if i seem to be rude it's because being under pressure is not a strong point for me and I'm trying not to get worked up too hard

no I did point out you weren't completely for the idea of NL.
I'm sorry if it really is just a greeting and nothing more. but it's literally all I got right now. and nobody else seems to have any suspicions of anyone else. if anyone does please do share.

ummm I'm still not understanding why no lynch gives mafia control? if we mislynch guys its gonna lower our numbers, bottom line! I will re-read over the thing Rune Raider wrote, but still like.... wtf, I don't see how keeping the numbers we have gives power to the mafia (however I do see them getting more influence by us killing someone and us being wrong)

if I re-read it and understand I will post saying ok lets go... but this is literally my first real game of mafia, so I just don't know whats happening

okay try and put all numbers aside. just read his TL;DR. "TL;DR: No lynching means we need to get 2 out of 3 lynches, while lynching means we only need to get 2 out of 4 lynches correct, meaning town should lynch on day 1."
Basically, if we no lynch we are wasting an entire day, we are throwing out the probability of lynching scum. Okay yes, the chances are low but it's better to risk those chances. I really can't explain it better, it makes sense in my head but when I try to explain I just feel like I'm repeating the same thing over and over.

 

[mother of all llamas]

^Agreeing with Alexi, it's best we take a shot in the dark rather than wasting a whole day. If we no lynch today, what are we basing off for tomorrow? Anyway, my lynch on Qwerty isn't firm so I might change in the next 10 minutes depending

 

[Chrystina]

you have to think if the flow of this conversation was going towards lynching someone who wasn't mafia, don't you think the mafia would WANT us to then go ahead and lynch someone? and thus expedite the killing off of our own people? so I'm quickly becoming suspicious of Alexi and Runeraider.... if they think they are in the clear they would of course want us to go ahead and lynch somebody, because its not anyone of their mafia goons.... they are trying to create chaos so that they can keep their own heads clean

wait what?
if anything scum would be trying to convince town to NL.

I cant even believe the discussion is still on about NL or no.

 

[Qwerty111]

"TL;DR: No lynching means we need to get 2 out of 3 lynches, while lynching means we only need to get 2 out of 4 lynches correct, meaning town should lynch on day 1."
Basically, if we no lynch we are wasting an entire day, we are throwing out the probability of lynching scum. Okay yes, the chances are low but it's better to risk those chances.

^Agreeing with Alexi, it's best we take a shot in the dark rather than wasting a whole day. If we no lynch today, what are we basing off for tomorrow?

Dang. Now that you all put it like that, I don't really know what to pick. Do we go and nl, to keep our numbers up? Or do we take a shot in the dark and just pray it works? It may not be logical in my eyes, but it's certainly a valid argument. a lot of day 2 stuff is like "okay, who didn't vote for them?".

(and gosh there's a lot of people looking/lurking here XD)

 

[toadsworthy]

yeah if we never lynch someone were obvi gonna lose, but I'm saying NL because I genuinely think its the right thing to do.... yes theres a "Chance" were gonna kill mafia but its such a small chance and if we kill one of our own now (which is the most likely outcome based on how our conversations have been going) and then the mafia kills one of us we have worse odds tomorrow than if we didn't lynch THATS A FACT, but were all thinking of killing Lynn, which I don't believe is mafia actually.... but someone is all for killing Lynn right now... someone wants to try to make us kill someone already.... I am open to hearing opposition to this without getting upset, or moody in this, but like just try to understand it from the other side from a second as I am clearly trying to understand logic of killing a random