Mafia TBT Scummy Award Mafia Game - End Game #justicewasright

[Minties]

i dont know you either
but i know youre scum so rip you m8
everyone jump on my sweg bw and we will ride into the sunset while eating pickles idk
sounds gr8 to me

sorry this feels like d1 and i only sh!tpost on d1 so

Oh look it's like Trojan and Starrywolf had a child and named it Runeraider. Fantastic.

I'm going to bed, **** this.

 

[Sataric]

The person who I'm red-reading the most right now is Sataric

Spoiler: Sataric Iso

General beginning of the game thoughts


Only the last two lines of this are significant. I can understand the sentiment that Blu could have been mafia because of how they're acting, but that isn't really lynchworthy. You seem very certain that Ness is town at this point however.

1. You've only played one prior game with Ness, so why would you still be so confident that Ness is town at this point or incapable of what you say?
2. Other people. So far you have only mentioned Blu Rose in your suspicions, and with not much reasoning to that


Not much here. Claims to be uncertain on who to lynch, then decides that lynching the ****poster that people are bandwagoning on with little reasoning is the best option


Anyone else notice that Sataric hasn't actually contributed anything at this point? And isn't this hypocritical since you were considering jumping on the Trojan lynch wagon. And a hypothetical as well


Nothing contributive here at all, your first paragraph isn't to the present circumstances and the second paragraph is just theories about the set-up. Anyone else realize that Sataric hasn't made any good contributions with justified suspicions yet?


Trundle is confirmed to be a doublevoter, which a quick google search tells me that it is a town-specific role.

I would expect Sataric to play better than this if he is town, especially considering how he played last game.

You do make a couple of valid points, mister Dolby - And I will address them in a moment. However, before I do that I just want to say that it's CLASSIC Dolby scum tactics to make a strong case focusing on a single person like this when you're Mafia. It's enough to get people to say that you've done a 'great contribution' somehow and keeps you away from being bunched with the silent players, and allows you to slide on by for a bit longer. Looking back on your previous games from way-back-when, you used to do this every single time you were scum. This time you chose me even though there's a whole bunch of other players with similar amount of "valid contributions" as myself.

I will not waste too much time defending myself, but I will address the points you made. Ness seemed to be town, and he was. Blu Rose seemed to be scum, and she was not. Even in hindsight some of her posts and comments make no sense to me as me town, but what can you do.. ("Kill anyone, I don't care..") And just because I have only played one or a few games with someone else, that does not mean I haven't looked through some of the previous games people have been in.

Theories about the set-up is important at times, as it helps us all get a clearer vision of what we might be working with. Furthermore, your defense of Trundle is alarming. You think that because he has two votes that automatically confirms him as town in a game like this one, even though Oath himself has said it's a super-experimental setup? No. You're too clever for that, and I'm not buying it. Suspicious as ****.

Some of my reads:

Dolby - Read above post.

Karla - Not playing like they normally would at all. Blames this on the role they've been given. That is either true, or they're making something up just so they can skim by. Definitely smart enough to take full advantage of the strange setup and use it to their advantage. What could a role like Natty the Observer be limited to/allowed to do? Maybe they're not allowed to make a proper case? Maybe they can only post one sentence at a time? Maybe they must include smileys sometimes? Or maybe Karla just looked at the way Natty posted in the previous ObsChat and mimicked that meanwhile he's actually scum.

Minties - Your name has to go here because you're too scary to be overlooked. I get a feeling you might be town, because you display a large degree of anger, which you commonly do when town as a collective is acting stupid. However, you could just be hiding behind a false layer of anger to hide your true scummy nature. Please don't kill me.

Trundle - Definitely not confirmed town.

Call me Daniel - Some scummy vibes in the air. However, feels like you are trying harder to be overlooked and to stay out of the spotlight compared to last game, whilst still frequently posting. This could either be because you've decided to try harder this time around, or because you're alignment is different.

I have seen no reason to be suspicious of M3ow_ or Ayaya so far. Kit was acting odd before the game was fully confirmed to be crazy so their claim about that being a necessity for their role somehow makes sense, but this doesn't prove that they are town. Llamas is too quiet and was more previously when town-aligned.

Also, Oath might be the true prime-evil in this game and perhaps the way to win is to target and kill him!? We all know you cannot die from a headache like he implied in his opening post as the game started. He clearly faked his death. The whole game might be a conspiracy.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I am a confirmed double voter, AMA

 

[Sataric]

Furthermore, I want to point out that the following people voted to lynch Ness:
Dolby
Blu Rose
Trundle
Trundle
Ayaya
Trojan
KarlaKGB

And these people voted for Ness but withdrew their votes at one point or another:
Kit
StarryWolf
Call me Daniel

It's important to note this down for the future.

 

[KarlaKGB]

alright kiddos listen up im a blue role and my power is that during the night i predict who will be lynched the next day , and if im right, i get one shot to use on the following night. cuz im a memer i predicted that i wud be lynched, with the intention of changing it. but then night ended early so i got outmemed.

 

[Sataric]

I am a confirmed double voter, AMA

Here's some questions for you:

1. Who is your scum mates?
2. You have two votes and use both to lynch Town - Why?
3. Five minutes after Day 2 begins, you make this post:

It's StarryWolf. Lynch StarryWolf.

Then you instantly vote for him. Later, you switch that vote onto Karla.
4. If it's StarryWolf, why switch?
5. If it's not StarryWolf, why say it's StarryWolf?
6. If you're town, why are you playing worse than you normally are by far?
7. What is your opinion on Dolby?
8.

Spoiler

Are you a SHAPESHIFTER and do you change roles every day which is why were a 1-shot vigilante, then townie, then vengeful 1-shot vigilante?

 

[KarlaKGB]

im still natty the observer, just thought i'd use that to roleplay my disinterest in this game

 

[EpicGamer12]

Here's some questions for you:

1. Who is your scum mates?
2. You have two votes and use both to lynch Town - Why?
3. Five minutes after Day 2 begins, you make this post:

Then you instantly vote for him. Later, you switch that vote onto Karla.
4. If it's StarryWolf, why switch?
5. If it's not StarryWolf, why say it's StarryWolf?
6. If you're town, why are you playing worse than you normally are by far?
7. What is your opinion on Dolby?
8.

Spoiler

Are you a SHAPESHIFTER and do you change roles every day which is why were a 1-shot vigilante, then townie, then vengeful 1-shot vigilante?

1. Karla, Papa John, and Kayla
2. If I vote for someone both my votes go on them, I can't split them up.
3. This isn't a question
4. It was to get day going because no one was doing anything
5. StarryWolf is really fun to start lynches on because it makes it easy to see the bandwagoners.
6. This game is a giant meme and so is my playstyle.
7. HE DRIVES THE BUS
8. Yes

 

[Dinosaurz]

Why the claim about the doctor? All competent hosts nowadays will send out the protected person a PM if they're saved. I also found it scummy that Starry was like "get here or I'm voting you!!111!" This could all just be because everything they post is so dumb that it infuriates me to the point of wanting to smash my keyboard.

Because I was never saved before I didn't know what happened, but now I know Mafia didn't have time to use there shot. I was joking, you cause sense that from the m9 I used. I was just bored of being alone

 

[glow]

alright kiddos listen up im a blue role and my power is that during the night i predict who will be lynched the next day , and if im right, i get one shot to use on the following night. cuz im a memer i predicted that i wud be lynched, with the intention of changing it. but then night ended early so i got outmemed.

Well if this is true idk if it was a good idea to claim because now you're going to be a target...Also, is your role name rly natty?

so at this point we can lynch Karla before Mafia kills him so that he can use his shot. or we can leave him alone and hope he's not targeted?? I'm not sure its a good plan for doc to save him because he can still be mafia. The only reason I think the former is not a bad idea is because we can clear up two roles. If Karla's telling the truth, then we can use his role while we still are able to and eliminate someone that were also feeling uneasy about.

Karla if you were going to choose someone to shoot, who would you pick?

Dolby where are you. Come use ur sniping skills for good. If hes still MIA when day ends then I think he's not a bad choice to be killed

 

[illunie]

Oh look it's like Trojan and Starrywolf had a child and named it Runeraider. Fantastic.

I'm going to bed, **** this.

Dude, I was here long before Starry and Trojan. And I was the one who even REFFERED Trojan in the first place.

my feels :c

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyway from what I've seen Starry seems to be suspicious right now, I can't type a long post (iPad ) but I will do that at some point. Unless her actions are justified when I read but just bw on her while you wait.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Well if this is true idk if it was a good idea to claim because now you're going to be a target...Also, is your role name rly natty?

so at this point we can lynch Karla before Mafia kills him so that he can use his shot. or we can leave him alone and hope he's not targeted?? I'm not sure its a good plan for doc to save him because he can still be mafia. The only reason I think the former is not a bad idea is because we can clear up two roles. If Karla's telling the truth, then we can use his role while we still are able to and eliminate someone that were also feeling uneasy about.

Karla if you were going to choose someone to shoot, who would you pick?

Dolby where are you. Come use ur sniping skills for good. If hes still MIA when day ends then I think he's not a bad choice to be killed

u want to lynch me so i can use my shot when im dead??

good kappa

 

[Ayaya]

Ender hasn't voted for you but if he does you should consider him.

Maybe Karla. He was way more questioning in the last game when he was a blue role. half of his posts are shtposts and here's his only relevant ones:



I don't like this reasoning at all. it's basically saying well ya there's a chance he's town but his role is useless so who cares the best thing to do now is lynch him anyway.

With how unbalanced this game is likely to be, there will probably be a lot of deaths and we're going to need as many town sided players as possible, it's not bad that he won't be targeted by mafia. so I don't agree that his roleclaim makes him useless.

It's interesting he mentions that the only info well get out of his lynch is that mafia most likely won't vote him....Tbh that's exactly what mafia would want everyone to think. But if mafia is smart a few of them will be inclined to vote for him so that they blend in with town more.

@Ness, please kill Karla

I already elaborated on this, but just look at the way he's playing this game vs how he's playing GOT mafia as vig. He was way more questioning and actively helping town.

Please kill Karla, Ness

I understand why Ayaya is voting you, you were trolling.. Don't think that makes you scum bc to me it just looks like you dgaf anymore since you're dying. Understandable. but don't kill Ayaya just for revenge pls

Hayden's banned for two weeks rip

so I still want to kill Karla

I'm fine w/ Lucanosa, Dolby or Starry as well

Well if this is true idk if it was a good idea to claim because now you're going to be a target...Also, is your role name rly natty?

so at this point we can lynch Karla before Mafia kills him so that he can use his shot. or we can leave him alone and hope he's not targeted?? I'm not sure its a good plan for doc to save him because he can still be mafia. The only reason I think the former is not a bad idea is because we can clear up two roles. If Karla's telling the truth, then we can use his role while we still are able to and eliminate someone that were also feeling uneasy about.

Karla if you were going to choose someone to shoot, who would you pick?

Dolby where are you. Come use ur sniping skills for good. If hes still MIA when day ends then I think he's not a bad choice to be killed

Okay I noticed some weird posts from you earlier but it's odd how instead of building cases like you used to, you're telling town to kill a player whose suspicious behavior is because they acted differently on the last game.

Different playstyle is a ground for suspicion, but you're sure enough about it that you keep asking Ness to kill Karla. I find this odd from you as iirc you're not usually this sure in past games, leaving room for doubt like I did in your suspicions or presenting them with good cases like you did with Trundle, but not this time.

You're also bringing up players who are already suspicious enough as "kill candidates", and you're okay with them being killed when their alignment isn't clear & they could be town.

You're so set on getting Karla killed that it seems to me you're just trying to get rid of an experienced player rather than helping town. You didn't even really consider other players as a lynch candidate.

Finally I have someone I'm scumreading and it's you.

 

[glow]

u want to lynch me so i can use my shot when im dead??

good kappa

Tbh I don't really believe your claim, and you haven't been useful all game so yeah lol

Day ends in a little less than three hours guys. Still leaning towards a Karla, Starrywolf or Dolby vote but I want to hear from everyone

- - - Post Merge - - -

Okay I noticed some weird posts from you earlier but it's odd how instead of building cases like you used to, you're telling town to kill a player whose suspicious behavior is because they acted differently on the last game.

Different playstyle is a ground for suspicion, but you're sure enough about it that you keep asking Ness to kill Karla. I find this odd from you as iirc you're not usually this sure in past games, leaving room for doubt like I did in your suspicions or presenting them with good cases like you did with Trundle, but not this time.

You're also bringing up players who are already suspicious enough as "kill candidates", and you're okay with them being killed when their alignment isn't clear & they could be town.

You're so set on getting Karla killed that it seems to me you're just trying to get rid of an experienced player rather than helping town. You didn't even really consider other players as a lynch candidate.

Finally I have someone I'm scumreading and it's you.

Can't really build cases, when mostly everyone's shtposting

I wanted Ness to kill Karla because I found Karla's reasoning for pushing Ness weak. He wasn't contributing and wasn't even trying to scumhunt so IMO he was the best kill at the time.

I'm not set on lynching Karla after he claimed that, that's why I haven't voted. I was just laying down our options. his behavior seems scummy so ofc I'm pushing him. The timing of his claim was weird, if he was town he could have proved it by trying. he hasn't been contributing when he's a strong player and literally said he wasn't interested in this game.

I've been considering the same 3-4 players this whole time basically, not sure why you said I'm not considering anyone else.

 

[Minties]

Tbh I don't really believe your claim, and you haven't been useful all game so yeah lol

Day ends in a little less than three hours guys. Still leaning towards a Karla, Starrywolf or Dolby vote but I want to hear from everyone

I'm feeling the same as you, I highly doubt that we'll get much input in the next 2.5 hours because it seems most players have stopped caring really.

alright kiddos listen up im a blue role and my power is that during the night i predict who will be lynched the next day , and if im right, i get one shot to use on the following night. cuz im a memer i predicted that i wud be lynched, with the intention of changing it. but then night ended early so i got outmemed.

Something about this role seems kind of stupid and you'd think that if that was Karla's role then he'd be actively making cases on the targets that he has predicted. So far he hasn't really made any cases or done very much because he's "roleplaying" his role. I don't really buy the claim with the way he's playing.

---

Dolby is quiet, so it's hard to read him. He's usually a lot more talkative when he's mafia and trying to steer town into mislynching. We all know that everyone massively underestimates him, so I don't want to let him slide by in the shadows.

---

Starrywolf's claim is not backed up, despite them saying they used it on Daniel. Since there's "no PM" sent to the player, we have no way to know if they pulled the claim out of the mafia wiki or not. They kept saying they might have been roleblocked or were protected, which to me just gave me the wrong vibes. It seemed more like someone waving a flag around screaming that they're town because their unprovable action might have been blocked. Reminds me of when Trundle claimed vig in GoT mafia.

Because I was never saved before I didn't know what happened, but now I know Mafia didn't have time to use there shot. I was joking, you cause sense that from the m9 I used. I was just bored of being alone

Also we still don't know what killed Panda1376. Is there some reason that Starrywolf knows that it wasn't mafia?

 

[Kit]

Eeyy guys so it's been days since I last put any sort of effort into a post and thought I'd remind you all that I'm still playing. Y'know I don't wanna bore you guys too much with my IRL crap but let's just say I've been very busy and haven't really had much time or effort to put into mafia. Oh, now though, I've got a three day weekend to relax and start posting.
Urm.. if you know me, you know I'm crap at reads and you know that I'm going to push anyways, SO ABOUT STARRY, MAYBE NOT? LET'S LYNCH m3ow INSTEAD????!!!
OKAY QUOTING ONE LINE FROM A BIG PARAGRAPH IS TOO MUCH WORK SO HERE
"Can't really build cases, when mostly everyone's shtposting"
VUD IT'S NOT JUST THAT, WHERE'S THE SHTPOSTING BECAUSE ALL I'M SEEING ON THESE RECENT PAGES ARE ACCUSATIONS BACKED UP WITH QUOTES. EY MAN, CAN'T MAKE A READ ON ANY OF THAT? Please tell me guys why is Karla bad again I can't remember why we're accusing her of faking her claim when literally all the claims this game have been random as hell.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Uh, Honestly, Karla is playing different here than in GOT mafia (granted that's all M3ow has experienced really) probably because GOT mafia was really active and everyone was super into it. This game.. not so much, even Daniel isn't posting much and he's DANIEL! My apologies, this game is a really creative set-up but I've had trouble getting into it because I'm really having trouble with people's claims, I've got nothing to go off of to see if they're right or wrong, I don't even understand the whole % power thing or why it was needed in the first place, so I don't know how to feel about it really :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

-EXTEMPT-
Tysm ness for helping me get my avvie u are the bae

 

[glow]

@ Kit

The recent long posts have all been by Minties, Sataric, Ayaya, Call me Daniel and myself. I believe that they're all most likely town (although Daniel is null for me atm, need to ISO) since they've been contributing. With the exception of Dolby, he made 1 long post tunneling Sataric for weak reasons imho. I could go into that more but I have more reasons to suspect Karla.

our lynch needs to be someone that isn't contributing to town.

 

[Kit]

@ Kit

The recent long posts have all been by Minties, Sataric, Ayaya, Call me Daniel and myself. I believe that they're all most likely town (although Daniel is null for me atm, need to ISO) since they've been contributing. With the exception of Dolby, he made 1 long post tunneling Sataric for weak reasons imho. I could go into that more but I have more reasons to suspect Karla.

our lynch needs to be someone that isn't contributing to town.

Yyyyyyy.... so you then? :3
(Sataric strikes an odd chord with me too but I don't have the smartness to back it up yet, they're just acting really.. off.. Weren't they the one who made that post on trundle AFTER he was confirmed to be a double voter still insisting he was mafia? Yeah. That happened. Just gonna point that out we seemed to have overlooked it.)

 

[Damniel]

I don't even know how to play this game so I'd say lynch Dolby and see what happens

 

[Kit]

I don't even know how to play this game so I'd say lynch Dolby and see what happens

heyyyy daniel what's up mannnnnnnnn. Eh IMO Dolby is always mafia (like 9/10 he's mafia he's been town like once since I came back to mafia so) so if you wanna take a stab in the dark go ahead. Ahhhh, but I'll be leaning more towards M3ow and Sataric.