Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[dedenne]

@chele would you consider punchy not being scum and just being plain old punchy? idk bc from vanessas iso all his posts kinda just remind me of punchy being punchy.

 

[Chele]

@chele would you consider punchy not being scum and just being plain old punchy? idk bc from vanessas iso all his posts kinda just remind me of punchy being punchy.

Honestly I?m against using meta for everything and Vanessa had a good comparison in posts to Punchy?s play. However, this got argued back by Toads who claimed that it wasn?t, which is why I don?t trust meta. Anybody could?ve improved.

I just want him dead regardless of his alignment so we could find scum easily by PoE. As we have had night kills and lynches, this narrows down the scumpool. If Punchy were to be Mafia, this would be the PoE:
Toads
Dedenne - Antonio had a very townie vibe and had a right to defend Punchy
Vanessa - Depends on whether she lynches Punchy
Bianca - Would be 100 percent clear if Punchy were to flip
Waffles - Obvious universal townread
Gallade
Chele - I would be 100 percent clear if Punchy were to flip as well as Bianca
Ness
Mog - Has pocketed Mog and pushed for a Punchy lynch

So the remaining two mafia would be between Ness/Gallade/Toads. I?m unsure on all three. Ness has been scumread by Punchy, Tae hasn?t had much to say so I think Gallade should have some space and I?m not sure about Toads due to his defence on Punchy.

Also I?m really busy, I?ll be back in a bit.

 

[cornimer]

Sensai I know you had a lot to catch up on but can you post and maybe claim today
Also can everyone vote in the thread pls, I want to see how many people really want to lynch punchy

 

[dedenne]

Sensai I know you had a lot to catch up on but can you post and maybe claim today
Also can everyone vote in the thread pls, I want to see how many people really want to lynch punchy

i dont really kno who to lynch rn but i think punchy would be our best bit since it will reveal a lot of alignments.

also if punchy does flip town i wont sus chele bc as scum she wouldn't be pushing for a lynch this badly as she knows that she would basicallly be a scumlock if punchy flips town


does that make sense

 

[cornimer]

i dont really kno who to lynch rn but i think punchy would be our best bit since it will reveal a lot of alignments.

also if punchy does flip town i wont sus chele bc as scum she wouldn't be pushing for a lynch this badly as she knows that she would basicallly be a scumlock if punchy flips town


does that make sense

Yeah honestly I think chele is town either way
If he's scum it will clear Bianca but I think everyone else's alignments are independent of him at this point?

 

[SensaiGallade]

Sorry for the brief inactivity, I've finished my portfolio (I think?) so that can be sent off to Uni if they like my Personal Statement

Sensai I know you had a lot to catch up on but can you post and maybe claim today
Also can everyone vote in the thread pls, I want to see how many people really want to lynch punchy

I have said already I am not scum:

Welp I have a lot of work to do then. Tae and myself is and not scum I know typical "iM nOt sCuM" post[s/]

Guess I have my work cut out for me

If you want more info, i'm literally just a basic townie with no powers. There's nothing else to it. Believe me if you want or not, that's your decision. tae's lack of activity has clearly formed a strong opinion on her alignment and that's now reflecting onto me.

 

[cornimer]

Thank you for claim, and who are you going to vote for to be lynched today?
Also congrats on finishing your portfolio!!

 

[SensaiGallade]

Thank you for claim, and who are you going to vote for to be lynched today?
Also congrats on finishing your portfolio!!

I've barely started reading up so I'd unfortunately have to trust others judgement, though only those who I trust myself.

I did find that Punchy begging to be ISO'd could tip him to be either scum or town evenly. On one hand, he could be begging because he wants to show that he is town. You don't get people begging to be read everyday do you?. On the otherhand, this sort of activity could be seen as tactical to try and throw people off in an attempt to change their opinion of Punchy, and hopefully clear his name.

So it could go either way.

 

[dedenne]

Yeah honestly I think chele is town either way
If he's scum it will clear Bianca but I think everyone else's alignments are independent of him at this point?

yea i agree

 

[unravel]

I personally think it would be the best to say good bye to punchy, it made me really overthink really well and I don't really see the point or else we will ended up taking to him every day and night phase. Lynching him will be maybe the only option and find out the possibility outcomes, this is like day 1 all over again if punchy is town then I think Toads and Chele are town too. Gallade is null for me and if you guys have slight doubts lynching punchy then maybe we could lynch Ness/Bianca for now I don't really see the point investigating Punchy because we need to get rid of framer first.

But at the same time it really made me iffy cuz day 4 is really mylo if punchy is town I think we can ask the vig to shoot ness/bianca on night phase.

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Vanessa

I'm gonna be as blunt here as possible, you can take my Hero claim as it is and lynch me and Town will likely lose since we will be down 2 people that can be kinged. The scum team by PoE is in Chele/Bianca/Sensaigallade/Toadsworthy/Punchy. Those first three are very likely the scumteam here. Unless Toadsworthy is implying he is the Hero (if he says he is, I want him dead because he'll just be doing it in an effort to lynch me), then he is very likely Town. With punchy IDEK at this point but I don't think he should die for a few reasons;

Did anyone CC????

 

[toadsworthy]

Yeah honestly I think chele is town either way
If he's scum it will clear Bianca but I think everyone else's alignments are independent of him at this point?

I don't know why everyone thinks Chele is town at ALL... and nothing can clear her more than mog, unravel, or ness hence why i think she is a possible lynch candidate. I'd vote bianca then her... but obviously it doesn't sound like you would lynch her today

 

[cornimer]

I don't know why everyone thinks Chele is town at ALL... and nothing can clear her more than mog, unravel, or ness hence why i think she is a possible lynch candidate. I'd vote bianca then her... but obviously it doesn't sound like you would lynch her today

It's kind of like how I don't think you would defend punchy so hard as scum...I don't think she would push for punchy so hard as scum because it would look bad when if flips town

- - - Post Merge - - -

*it would look bad if he flips town

- - - Post Merge - - -

I personally think it would be the best to say good bye to punchy, it made me really overthink really well and I don't really see the point or else we will ended up taking to him every day and night phase. Lynching him will be maybe the only option and find out the possibility outcomes, this is like day 1 all over again if punchy is town then I think Toads and Chele are town too. Gallade is null for me and if you guys have slight doubts lynching punchy then maybe we could lynch Ness/Bianca for now I don't really see the point investigating Punchy because we need to get rid of framer first.

But at the same time it really made me iffy cuz day 4 is really mylo if punchy is town I think we can ask the vig to shoot ness/bianca on night phase.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Did anyone CC????

Nobody CC'd but toads still hasn't said his actual role

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm either going to lynch punchy or sensai today just because I think he is VERY likely scum by PoE and fits on all the teams.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

ok so if I'm lynched it confirms bianca and chele, literally two people

so why am I a lynch if you think I'm town

 

[Biancasbotique]

If anyone'alignment would be revealed if Punchy were to flip scum is Chele. She has been pushing for lynchy Punchy since day 1. If he were scum, the mafia team must love bussing each other if Chele is scum too.

 

[cornimer]

ok so if I'm lynched it confirms bianca and chele, literally two people

so why am I a lynch if you think I'm town

To confirm 2 people
I think you're like 65% scum 35% town

 

[PunchyTheCat]

If anyone'alignment would be revealed if Punchy were to flip scum is Chele. She has been pushing for lynchy Punchy since day 1. If he were scum, the mafia team must love bussing each other if Chele is scum too.

yes, so literally two people

also we're at MYLO if we lynch a townie and then scum kills the last two or three townies

 

[Biancasbotique]

yes, so literally two people

also we're at MYLO if we lynch a townie and then scum kills the last two or three townies

are you okay with being lynched?

 

[unravel]

Wait so today is actually mylo???? Wtf????

 

[cornimer]

Wait so today is actually mylo???? Wtf????

No tomorrow is

- - - Post Merge - - -

Everyone just vote in the voting thread, I'll go with maj and if punchy is maj I'll lynch him

- - - Post Merge - - -

I would like to end day before 10pm so we can discuss the results before and I can actually sleep at 10 since I have to be up early

 

[unravel]

Does anyone have magic 8 ball and ask if Punchy is scum or should we lynch him ty.