Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

You totally fooled me, I reviewed all your posts before protecting Dedenne and I thought you were definitely town

Also I had a theory toads was kingmaker claiming blue to trick scum into not killing him, mainly because I didn't know who else would keep kinging me

I had hard read Punchy as KM and so i was hoping when he died, I could use that as clout to help me look better. But then rune didn't kill him day 2....

 

[Jacob]

Good game!

Thanks for hosting Dan

 

[toadsworthy]

Miraculous Ladybug: Am town roleblocker, get inspected and said scum when actually town, gets lynched

Battle of the Nobles: Am scum roleblocker, gets inspected and said scum when really scum, no one bats an eye

the world we live in

 

[cornimer]

If you weren't kingmaker, my other guess was town roleblocker because of the "no justice for rose" tag

Altho when you first claimed I was trying to bait you to claim doctor so I could lynch you

 

[tae]

Miraculous Ladybug: Am town roleblocker, get inspected and said scum when actually town, gets lynched

Battle of the Nobles: Am scum roleblocker, gets inspected and said scum when really scum, no one bats an eye

the world we live in

wouldn't have lived if i didn't almost die at my friends house tho.
next game i cant wait to getcha.

 

[radical6]

It's all about the ethics in roleclaiming.

 

[tae]

If you weren't kingmaker, my other guess was town roleblocker because of the "no justice for rose" tag

Altho when you first claimed I was trying to bait you to claim doctor so I could lynch you

i made the no justice for rose tag. heuheueh

 

[Dolby]

Miraculous Ladybug: Am town roleblocker, get inspected and said scum when actually town, gets lynched

Battle of the Nobles: Am scum roleblocker, gets inspected and said scum when really scum, no one bats an eye

the world we live in

Your gonna be mad how arrogant I was during the first half reading obs chat

Anyway, Dan should've...said something because lets just say I found something around when I died, but he probably was busy when he put up the endgame

Anyway, we're setting up a new mafia discord and we have big plans for it! We've integrated wolfia into it to! VM me if you want an invite

(Also highkey up until you were defending Jacob I thought you were KM because king Bianca is such a Toads thing to do)

 

[toadsworthy]

Also I have no idea why Jacob got so much sus on day 1 tbh. I stand by that both of those lynches kinda sucked... and I would've hard read punchy as town too even if I didn't already know he was town. Bianca was definitely a cop out lynch, but I legitimately saw her posts and actions as scum-aligning for her. My reads this game weren't unjustified like they sometimes are when I'm scum and I did a bit better job of pushing them forward as a scum to mimic my town play, but damn did I think a lot "wow this would be so much easier if I was just town" or "this isn't really hard to write because I actually believe this rather than trying to push a fake read"

It just sucked that I was scum this time and couldn't be as vocal because I knew I would get the smack down if I had been anymore vocal about it

 

[radical6]

Inspect Toads - Inspect Vanessa - Doesn't Matter

LMFAO

 

[toadsworthy]

Your gonna be mad how arrogant I was during the first half reading obs chat

Anyway, Dan should've...said something because lets just say I found something around when I died, but he probably was busy when he put up the endgame

Anyway, we're setting up a new mafia discord and we have big plans for it! We've integrated wolfia into it to! VM me if you want an invite

(Also highkey up until you were defending Jacob I thought you were KM because king Bianca is such a Toads thing to do)

lol in scum chat I was like, kill dolby now, people will take what he is saying now and he can't progress his thoughts... so they will kill punchy and then I'll be town locked lolololololol

then we didn't even kill punchy...

SO MANY TIMES I WANTED TO SWITCH AND SAY LYNCH PUNCHY BUT I DIDNT LOL

 

[Dolby]

Btw, I don't know what post it was, but Vanessa saying that I was screaming in obs to lynch Toads was gold

 

[Damniel]

Anyway, Dan should've...said something because lets just say I found something around when I died, but he probably was busy when he put up the endgame

Thanks for reminding me

- - - Post Merge - - -

When Dolby died, he reported that when opening QT he saw a new post in an old obs game:

I know that the narrator was Antonio due to him using that name earlier in the scum chat.

Now fortunately Dolby reported this to me quickly and Antonio used a different name. However, in other circumstances it could've easily ruined the game. I'm not sure whether this was intentional breadcrumbing, or an actual accident like Antonio claims, but this isn't okay. Extreme caution in reading the rules, and posting game telling information must be taken.

Also with the Punchy tags, Punchy himself wrote them. Had Justin not told me it was him, I would've thought someone was making actual bullying tags. Even if its to yourself, stop making these kinds of tags

 

[Antonio]

The downfall of this game was punchy and the fact that he survived till day 3. You can both blame this on Rune and Punchy but the whole town could be a fault. Rune deciding to vote off evan rather then punchy on day 2 even when punchy was maj was idiotic and left the conversation going on longer then it has to be. Going against the majority is a stupid move, especially when you vote off a town member who wasn't even voted for. You left the discussion open unntil day 3. Punchy begging to be voted off was idiotic aswell. Yes, he should've tried to stay in the game but making useless tags and pounting to stay in the game isn't helping your case. Here are some of my observations:

- Inactive users during day3 and above are most likely scum, just letting the bull**** happen.
- Don't rely on a single person lynch to move the game forward, especially when it's day 3.
- Meta is bull**** unless it's from the last 2 games then maybe it's like 25% bull****. Don't rely on meta alone for susing someone.
- Question everything, don't believe what a perso says!
- Don't think that because mafia read someone as town/scum, that means they are the opposite of what the town read or the same. Most likely, mafia would town read some of his/her team and scum read some of his/her team in order to not leave connections.
- Don't be inactive or join a game when you know you are gonna be busy. Same with replacing.

This game was fun to obs and I am sorry for discussing kingmaker. Maybe if i was modkilled rather then replaced, town would've won.

 

[Damniel]

You totally fooled me, I reviewed all your posts before protecting Dedenne and I thought you were definitely town

Also I had a theory toads was kingmaker claiming blue to trick scum into not killing him, mainly because I didn't know who else would keep kinging me

Red inspect
+ Not actually claiming
+ Defensive reaction
= Scum

The chances of a frame are always incredibly low (Unless the cop was already outted). Lynching a red inspect is always the safest choice

 

[Antonio]

Thanks for reminding me

- - - Post Merge - - -

When Dolby died, he reported that when opening QT he saw a new post in an old obs game:

I know that the narrator was Antonio due to him using that name earlier in the scum chat.

Now fortunately Dolby reported this to me quickly and Antonio used a different name. However, in other circumstances it could've easily ruined the game. I'm not sure whether this was intentional breadcrumbing, or an actual accident like Antonio claims, but this isn't okay. Extreme caution in reading the rules, and posting game telling information must be taken.

Also with the Punchy tags, Punchy himself wrote them. Had Justin not told me it was him, I would've thought someone was making actual bullying tags. Even if its to yourself, stop making these kinds of tags

Yeah, all these old chats are in my history. I almost typed in scum chat aswell when i was modkilled but check before I hit send. Again, apologies.

 

[dedenne]

im so happy i played well as scum this is revolutionary

: D
good game i might kinda get back into mafia

 

[Antonio]

Thanks for reminding me

- - - Post Merge - - -

When Dolby died, he reported that when opening QT he saw a new post in an old obs game:

I know that the narrator was Antonio due to him using that name earlier in the scum chat.

Now fortunately Dolby reported this to me quickly and Antonio used a different name. However, in other circumstances it could've easily ruined the game. I'm not sure whether this was intentional breadcrumbing, or an actual accident like Antonio claims, but this isn't okay. Extreme caution in reading the rules, and posting game telling information must be taken.

Also with the Punchy tags, Punchy himself wrote them. Had Justin not told me it was him, I would've thought someone was making actual bullying tags. Even if its to yourself, stop making these kinds of tags

I knew he was making those, just like the last game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

im so happy i played well as scum this is revolutionary

: D
good game i might kinda get back into mafia

You were a good replacement. <3

 

[Dolby]

Lets be real, that isn't accidental. No scum says "I want to kill my teammate tonight" naturally because they were confused on his alignemtn

 

[cornimer]

Red inspect
+ Not actually claiming
+ Defensive reaction
= Scum

The chances of a frame are always incredibly low (Unless the cop was already outted). Lynching a red inspect is always the safest choice