Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[Chele]

not if i dont want to, its not a set in stone rule

Ok true
But who’d you lynch then

 

[mogyay]

I’d say the confirmation list would’ve been: Trundle, Waffles, Vanessa, Dolby in that order.

i would put dolby far above vanessa but regardless, in that case he was on to something, and mafia wanted to silence him. the most obvious guess is toads, he was the only really pushing for a toad lynch as most people were doubting toad could actually be mafia due to his initial towny type posts. anyway let's just see how punchy goes

- - - Post Merge - - -

if u don't lynch punchy or toad u're basically scum to me now

- - - Post Merge - - -

unless there's some kind of breaking news

 

[illunie]

i would put dolby far above vanessa but regardless, in that case he was on to something, and mafia wanted to silence him. the most obvious guess is toads, he was the only really pushing for a toad lynch as most people were doubting toad could actually be mafia due to his initial towny type posts. anyway let's just see how punchy goes

- - - Post Merge - - -

if u don't lynch punchy or toad u're basically scum to me now

dolby was super wrong about punchy in ctstp tho, and this situation is rly rly similiar

 

[Chele]

i would put dolby far above vanessa but regardless, in that case he was on to something, and mafia wanted to silence him. the most obvious guess is toads, he was the only really pushing for a toad lynch as most people were doubting toad could actually be mafia due to his initial towny type posts. anyway let's just see how punchy goes

- - - Post Merge - - -

if u don't lynch punchy or toad u're basically scum to me now

- - - Post Merge - - -

unless there's some kind of breaking news

If Punchy flips town (in some kind of broken situation) then would you have the same read on Toads?

 

[toadsworthy]

i just got three stocked in smash and waiting for the match to end...

Trundle seems like the more logical kill since yeah he was among the first to really drive scum say jacob.
Dolby is a strange one, because I feel like he was null to a lot of people, not really cleared since he didn't even vote jacob...

I think we should definitely lynch in the people who didn't vote jacob

and I'm kinda glad its rune raider and he doesn't want to lynch punchy because punchy isn't scum

 

[mogyay]

dolby was super wrong about punchy in ctstp tho, and this situation is rly rly similiar

ok maybe it's a set up to frame punchy but regardless, who's a better choice? no one really. it sucks if punchy's town but he hasn't done much to really prove himself and i think we can learn a whole lot on allignments whatever he is

 

[Chele]

dolby was super wrong about punchy in ctstp tho, and this situation is rly rly similiar

What’d be your explanation on his death then?

 

[mogyay]

i'm gonna honestly cry, we need to lynch punchy

 

[illunie]

What’d be your explanation on his death then?

bc he was right about literally everyone else maybe, mafia didnt know they were gonna successfully roleblock the vig or we happened

 

[Heyden]

I’m sorry but even if you believe Punchy is town, it’s so anti-town to keep him alive bc he will obviously be kept alive until endgame and will ALWAYS be a topic of discussion. Failing to eliminate him now will just have a detrimental effect on town in the future.

 

[unravel]

If you're really iffy about punchy then tell us who is you're most suss with and why? Cuz of me punchy's role will be determine Toads and other peoole who def him alignment. I still don't understand why they didn't kill strong tls such as mog etc.

 

[Biancasbotique]

The only possibility that I think that Punchy didn't die is because

a) there is no vig
b) Punchy is vig , which I refuse to believe he is because we all know Punchy loves to roleclaim before he gets lynched- or am I wrong

The only possibility that I think Dolby died

a) Dolby got shot by the vig- fear kill?
b) Dolby got shot by mafia and because he is onto something

The only possibility that I think Trundle died

a) Trundle is the only mafia kill I think I am almost certain...

But you guys are right, killing Punchy will answer a lot of questions.

 

[unravel]

For me*

 

[mogyay]

low key sussing rune now honestly just bc of this

 

[illunie]

its ****ing ctstp all over again but now im the sole decider of if my gut is right or not pls kill me

 

[Heyden]

low key sussing rune now honestly just bc of this

Ya I can’t tell if shes trying to portray a ‘cautious town’ image in the case Punchy flips town to make her look better. Or defending him. Either way I’m rlly not liking her behaviour

- - - Post Merge - - -

its ****ing ctstp all over again but now im the sole decider of if my gut is right or not pls kill me

your being rly anti-town rn but go off

 

[Chele]

The only possibility that I think that Punchy didn't die is because

a) there is no vig
b) Punchy is vig , which I refuse to believe he is because we all know Punchy loves to roleclaim before he gets lynched- or am I wrong

The only possibility that I think Dolby died

a) Dolby got shot by the vig- fear kill?
b) Dolby got shot by mafia and because he is onto something

The only possibility that I think Trundle died

a) Trundle is the only mafia kill I think I am almost certain...

But you guys are right, killing Punchy will answer a lot of questions.

Hi where’d you come from
My opinion is that an inactive (probably Tae) could be vig? And maybe they didn’t shoot. Or perhaps there’s none overall.
Unless the Mafia roleblocked the vig by chance.
The only explanation we could really get for Dolby is because he had a huge case on Toads and Dolby, perhaps Mafia wanted to frame one of them or just shut Dolby’s mouth.

 

[mogyay]

its ****ing ctstp all over again but now im the sole decider of if my gut is right or not pls kill me

no one's gonna blame u rune, we're literally all pushing u. i will take all of the blame if i'm wrong idc, we need punchy's alignment

 

[illunie]

o just remembered theres no garuntee of having a vig so punchy just prob wasnt shot bc there was noone to shoot him

 

[Chele]

Toads and Punchy