Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[cornimer]

I havent scumread Bianca hard since D1 and I would way rather see punchy lynched than her at this point. I do waiver on punchy because while he has done some scummy things he has done some town things too and I am genuinely unsure of his alliance. I wanted him dead yesterday to help figure out other peoples alliance, and I still do but now that we're closer to MYLO I am scared of mislynching another potential townie. It might still be necessary to lynch him but idk why me not being 100% certain punchy is scum makes me scummy. Other people have expressed doubts too

- - - Post Merge - - -

Darn I wanted that to merge smh mog

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Kallie read me

- - - Post Merge - - -

Vanessa ISO me

 

[cornimer]

Punchy I already did (granted it was about your other game but I feel like people have done this game already)

 

[mogyay]

i just feel like ness has been brought forward to take the heat off of toad which is why i scum read you, if toad flips town then i'm sorry, if bianca flips town then i'm sorry. but in my opinion it's unlikely

- - - Post Merge - - -

if it helps all my reads are usually wrong lol

 

[cornimer]

I guess from the perspective of punchy being 100% scum then I look like I'm trying to avoid lynching scum and thus look scummy, but I just am not certain he is scum and I think we should consider both perspectives so we arent blindsided and leadless if he flips town

- - - Post Merge - - -

i just feel like ness has been brought forward to take the heat off of toad which is why i scum read you, if toad flips town then i'm sorry, if bianca flips town then i'm sorry. but in my opinion it's unlikely

- - - Post Merge - - -

if it helps all my reads are usually wrong lol

If you're convinced toad is scum I guess we look like a team that's fair
I'll be pretty surprised if he is scum though (not that I havent defended him and been wrong before rip)

 

[Biancasbotique]

but at this point, do we even care if punchy is town or scum? sorry punchy if you feel like we seem to talk about you hard but the thing is even you punchy said it will help town with your death. and you seem at peace with the idea. if i am in your position, it's a no brainer, i would want town to lynch me to get some rest for town.

unless ur a powerrole which you are not, i know you like to claim if you are and even you said that you are not blue.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I must say if you don't like the idea of Punchy being lynched, you guys are just being stubborn just to make a point.

 

[cornimer]

Yeah I agree lynching punchy is kinda necessary to determining peoples alignments, but if he isnt town we only have one shot left so it's just a bit risky

 

[mogyay]

but at this point, do we even care if punchy is town or scum? sorry punchy if you feel like we seem to talk about you hard but the thing is even you punchy said it will help town with your death. and you seem at peace with the idea. if i am in your position, it's a no brainer, i would want town to lynch me to get some rest for town.

unless ur a powerrole which you are not, i know you like to claim if you are and even you said that you are not blue.

yeah but at this rate town might lose sigh hence why people are now hesitant i still think he's the best candidate though bc i do think he's scum

 

[cornimer]

I'm not saying we definitely shouldnt do it I'm just saying we shouldnt do it without thinking

 

[Biancasbotique]

and one more thing Punchy, after your 2nd or third life, I really did not see any effort on your part to establish or help with town. I would think that a second chance like yours would give you the motivation to help and not give vague reads.

 

[cornimer]

Yeah I agree lynching punchy is kinda necessary to determining peoples alignments, but if he isnt town we only have one shot left so it's just a bit risky

*if he is town

- - - Post Merge - - -

and one more thing Punchy, after your 2nd or third life, I really did not see any effort on your part to establish or help with town. I would think that a second chance like yours would give you the motivation to help and not give vague reads.

Second or third life lol if that ain't the truth

 

[Biancasbotique]

yeah but at this rate town might lose sigh hence why people are now hesitant i still think he's the best candidate though bc i do think he's scum

this should have been done a long time ago and i dont know the hesitation now. I can understand rune and why she did that , but the next lynch should be straightforward

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not saying we definitely shouldnt do it I'm just saying we shouldnt do it without thinking

I know what you mean, but we already have done enough thinking. and besides, only person is really against Punchy being lynched and it is toads. IF he is town! toads, he is just being stubborn I should say and doesn't want to even consider a smidgen that Punchy could be scum. Why can't he be scum?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Bianca is literally just saying "kill punchy idc if he's scum or not"

how is she not scumread

 

[cornimer]

Bianca is literally just saying "kill punchy idc if he's scum or not"

how is she not scumread

We were all saying that yesterday lol

 

[Heyden]

I’ll be back later but looking at numbers
9 vs 3
7 vs 3 after n2
5 vs 3 after d3 (mislynch/tae mk)
3 vs 3 d4 scum win

So um a tae mk will be really bad if they’re town unless we find them a replacement.
Also reading back my pool is narrowed down to Bianca/Chele/Ness and maybe Tae/Punchy

I hate myself for doubting Punchy now but idk ugh

 

[cornimer]

Because of alignment tells

- - - Post Merge - - -

I’ll be back later but looking at numbers
9 vs 3
7 vs 3 after n2
5 vs 3 after d3 (mislynch/tae mk)
3 vs 3 d4 scum win

So um a tae mk will be really bad if they’re town unless we find them a replacement.
Also reading back my pool is narrowed down to Bianca/Chele/Ness and maybe Tae/Punchy

I hate myself for doubting Punchy now but idk ugh

So if tae is town and modkilked and we mislynch tomorrow we are already done?
Yikes

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean that's if doc is not successful at all but still

 

[Damniel]

I prodded tae last night. I’m also trying to look for a replacement just in case, but it’s not going so well. If anyone knows someone please Pm me

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I prodded tae last night. I’m also trying to look for a replacement just in case, but it’s not going so well. If anyone knows someone please Pm me

Try Dad

 

[Heyden]

I'll elaborate later but here is a hot take: heyden/tae/toadsworthy/biancasbotique have the scum in them. Some of these players that are being super townread need to be reevaluated.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and I guess Punchy or Chele are alternatives in that list, but I'm not so sure about either of them at the moment.

can i lynch you if im king...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Try Dad

hes in obs

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Subs:

Locket
SensaiGallade
Gavin (Ghostkid)