Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[Damniel]

I have a replacement, but I'll need to give tae time to respond before I can replace

 

[dedenne]

ok im gonna slep soon but ive started looking through punchys posts and tbh the more i think about it the more its just typical punchy. but i need to think more about it

 

[Heyden]

is vig shot refunded?
can mafia kills be roleblocked?
can mafia send in actions for other mafia if one’s inactive

 

[Damniel]

is vig shot refunded?
can mafia kills be roleblocked?
can mafia send in actions for other mafia if one’s inactive

Yes
No
Yes, only one of them has to send it in

- - - Post Merge - - -

Though I'm not confirming the presence of any certain roles

 

[Chele]

Chele’s day one posts asked a lot of questions but I don’t really see what any of it has done... and have we gotten full reads for her on everyone? Her questions seemed directed mostly at punchy to build up a case and she’s doing that thing where she hyper focuses on one person the whole time to avoid giving reads on anyone else. If her and punchy are scum together then wtf, I highly doubt punchy is scum which means she could be picking on him. Her and Jacobs interaction was like nonexistent too which looks like subconscious bussing on their part.

The doing votes end of day looks like trying to be active with doing as little content wise as possible and really rubs me the wrong way. Combine that with how she was the one to jump at showing the numbers for lynches and kills and it looks like trying to look townie, but upon reading through... it doesn’t get us much and all I know of her from this game is that she really wants punchy dead

I’m fonna do reads later with analysis of possible partners before the end of the night. Stay tuned

What? Umm I did do reads. However, I kept them short for N2. And why are you acting as if I haven’t talked to any other player in this game except Punchy? As well as that, how is counting the votes even AI? And plus, you can’t even blame me. I’ve been pushing for a Punchy lynch D1 and yet he’s still not dead, so what do you expect me to do? I even said in thread that I can’t make judgements and confirm them if Punchy’s alignment hasn’t been shown to us.
And also I asked this in thread before, but you’re townreading Rune when she was inactive through most of EoD, and now you’re scumleaning me just because of EoD? I don’t see how Rune gets the free pass.

Speaking of which, I hope for the best Rune <3 and welcome Kallie.

You two are different people. In two different situations. It's not easy to just compare like that.

What I’m saying is that Toads scumleans me because me counting the votes seems scummy and AI to him. He thinks that I was trying to coast on EoD. The thing is, Rune was inactive through almost all of EoD and just came to place a vote on Jacob.

 

[toadsworthy]

I haven?t done a reads list yet but I?m sick of what?s been happening so far so here:

Waffles - Would never have defended Mog and Toads from the start, and was the first one to call out Jacob.
Vanessa - I?m just glad that she?s going for a Punchy lynch and also that she lynched Jacob. Her tone seems genuine, laid back and unforced.
Mog - I?m happy with your contribution so far. Don?t know what else to say tbh, you?re obvious town.
Heyden - He has made good points and examined and questioned players with no filler content.
Ness - Please come back and answer our questions. By PoE, you?re also in the scumpool.
Tae - I would?ve actually put them in slight scumlean tbh. They should actually be set up for modkill. Otherwise, they?re just swimming in my scumpool.
Bianca - I?ve struggled to read her in the past but she?s a slight townlean because of her play, it doesn?t have any AtE and in all honesty I can?t see her being scum with the possible people I?ve mentioned. But then again, we have to wait until Punchy?s alignment gets revealed to justify her.
Toads - Has been actively defending Punchy but at the same time, he wouldn?t make it THAT obvious to sus Punchy for a long period of time without just coming to accept it and ride along with town. I honestly don?t know if I?d go straight onto a Toads lynch if Punchy flips scum.
Dedenne - Antonio wasn?t acting very suspicous at the time, so I?m giving Dedenne benefit of the doubt for now. Also she has pages to read up on, so I can?t really clear her out right now.
Rune - I?m still waiting for you to come back and tell us why on earth you voted for Evan. Since the start, you?ve been lurking. At the beginning of your queenship, you?ve been sus because of being so anti-town and not wanting a Punchy lynch. Then as we?re arguing about Ness or Punchy, you go and vote Evan (which didn?t help town at all). You even asked for evidence and all that, and we gave you the mislynch stats and repeatedly described how Punchy?s alignment would help town so much. I don?t see any other reason to vote Evan other than trying to help your scum mate Punchy live. Not only that, but you left straight after the incident without saying a word (you didn?t even back up your reason for Evan to die).
Punchy - I?m sick and tired of even talking about him. Just shoot or kill him. This is actually giving me a migraine.

oh you did do reads my bad

 

[PunchyTheCat]

hi I'm not going to be here for EoD

check recent teams and reads

 

[toadsworthy]

hi I'm not going to be here for EoD

check recent teams and reads

its night silly

 

[Damniel]

25 minutes left to submit final actions. After 10 I'll review the actions and post the results

 

[PunchyTheCat]

end of night

it feels like I've broken every bone below my waist

(first time ice skating lmao)

 

[Heyden]

Some quick reads before I die cos doctor is gonna do something obvious like protect mogyay while me and waffles get killed, yeehaw.

Mogyay, Vanessa, Waffles, Rune/Kallie are all hopefully town, or at least everyone agrees.
Antonio/Dedenne is town to me, I know ppl disagree but Antonio is not scum bc when he said 'Dolby, Vanessa, Dad can't be scum bc they were scum last game' its just so town telling imo. So leave Dedenne alone.
Toads feels town, he's hard to read but I think his Chele fos based on her doing nothing at EoD is pretty legit cos when she did that I initially thought its such a scum thing to do, participating but not really. I could be wrog about this tho.
Punchy honestly idk

Scum is Ness/Bianca/Chele/Tae.
Tae's replacement is Sensaigallade I think and he's a naturally very scummy person so pls be careful making harsh decisions on him. i know its hard to read someone who's 6 phases into the game but just be wary. I was gonna say the fact that night is ending early means scum doesn't want to wait, and I'm pretty sure if Tae was scum they'd wait for them to come online??? idk but also notice tae dipped after jacob was lynched so pls still be vigilant about them.

 

[mogyay]

hi incase i die, kill toad, he is mafia. i think punchy is too with that level of protection from toad but whatever

 

[Heyden]

did i forget someone

 

[Damniel]

Day Three

Lord Kallie and Lord Heyden were found murdered last night. Tragic and sudden deaths.

Vanessa has been crowned King again.

You have until Sunday 10PM EST to execute the next noble.

Time Until Day Three Ends

​

 

[Heyden]

oop there it is, thx a lot doc ;(

 

[PunchyTheCat]

ok wtf ness might not be scum

ness wouldn't fearkill both of those people

 

[cornimer]

Again??

 

[toadsworthy]

ok wtf ness might not be scum

ness wouldn't fearkill both of those people

that was a quick thought to have?

 

[mogyay]

vanessa ily i'm sry, lynch punchy pls

 

[Damniel]

SensaiGallade has replaced tae, welcome!