The Best (and worst) bird villagers and why? 🐦

[Wolfieocelot]

Ok, so this thread is a little different from my other threads. This thread will still have a poll, but only for your favorite villager. You can now share your least favorite villager as well

DISCLAIMER: Birds are different from eagles, penguins, ducks, and ostriches. Pls dont get confused

BEST: Piper. She looks really cool and reminds me of daisy duck. Not to mention she has my favorite personality, peppy.

WORST: Anchovy. Probably because he wants to look derpy, but he kinda took it too far...

 

[t3llusagi]

Best: Midge. She looks really cute and so is her house.

Worst: Lucha. I detest lucha, and his silly little mask with his beady little eyes. Everyday I beg the animal crossing god of rng to keep him away from me and my villagers, I will NOT sit here and wait for him to burn down my house and eat my crops.

 

[LadyDestani]

I voted for Peck because I've always thought he looked really cool. Piper would be a close second, though.

I don't really have a least favorite. I think all of them are cute in their own way.

 

[nightglow]

Havent had any bird villagers but Jacob interests me the most so i voted for him.

 

[Nefarious]

I love Piper sooo much. I had both her and Robin in the Gamecube game, so there's some nostalgia there, but I just think their designs are fantastic. I also love how Piper has a bit of a gothic vibe, but is a Peppy despite that. Hoping to move her on my island some day.

I don't really have a least favorite truthfully. Maybe Jacob or Midge? I don't dislike them though.

 

[maria110]

Jacques came to my island from the void and I thought I'd move him out right away but then I loved him and kept him until I received his photo. He's got a great design and his house is cool, like a DJ's place. Piper has the cityscape wall in her house and is a nice combo of peppy enthusiasm and coolness.

 

[ayeeprill]

I like Midge, Piper, and Jay best! Midge is adorable, Piper is classy, and Jay is just a classic villager.

Worst is a tossup between Twiggy and Jitters. Twiggy annoyed me in Wild World and Jitters is just...ugh.

 

[Marshmallows]

Absolute best is Twiggy. She was my first peppy and she's still on my island... I love her coloring and her personality is completely opposite her angry face. Midge is pretty cute, too.

Worst.... maybe Lucha or Jacob.

 

[Mr.Fox]

Lucha was actually the first smug I found imitating/making fun of snooty villagers, so he's good in my books.

Worst...easily Jacob...he lives in a garbage dump.

 

[Plume]

Anchovy! I feel like he's the type of bird who would have a super impressive record collection.

 

[Xara]

my vote went to midge! i might be a bit biased as the normal villagers are my favourite aha but she’s such a pretty gal and i like her a lot! piper is also pretty great, too; she was my starter peppy and she was really nice to have around!

anchovy, robin and jay are the worst birds by far - no idea what my problem is but they honestly irk me so bad lmao.

 

[DaisyFan]

I go for Anchovy, Midge, and Piper because they look nice!

I don't have a least favorite bird villager though.

 

[Jam86]

best is my boy jacques, he is so groovy ♡

worst is lucha, but only because he is not a jock, why is he smug?????

 

[moon_child]

Midge and Piper are cute. Jay is okay. Jitters...uhhh...Jitters looks like HE’S SEEN THINGS. Bad things. Very very bad things.

 

[Che5hire Cat]

I absolutely adore Anchovy and Piper a lot, mainly because of their design.

As for the rest of the birds, I don't care for them that much, there are overall fine/acceptable.

 

[JemAC]

Robin is my favourite bird, her design uses both my favourite colour and favourite personality (blue and snooty) and I really like robins in general so I'm often drawn to her when it comes to the bird villagers (though her design doesn't overly resemble a robin but she has the right name). I did also vote for Midge and Admiral too as I think Midge has a very pretty design and Admiral always reminds me a little bit of a character from a film I watched a lot when I was young, Chicken Run, obviously he's a bird and not a chicken but there was an old cranky chicken in the film that I always think of when I see Admiral - if they ever did a sequel called Bird Run then he'd be a great character for it.

My least favourite is Peck, I'd never realised how much I disliked him until I ran into him while island hopping recently and he freaked me out, his eyes are just too creepy for me.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My favorites are anchovy and sparro. I am not generally a fan of the birds, but these are two I would consider inviting to my island. I dinner have any deep reason, just think they are very cute.

least favorite is Jacques, I generally don’t like the animals that have the soul patch/ goatee because i associate it with a specific unpleasant personality, and Jacques’ design especially just rubs me the wrong way.

 

[Nunnafinga]

Jitters is my favorite bird.He popped up in one of old New Leaf cycling towns and I really liked his color scheme and although he's a jock he was on the milder side of that personality.

 

[oranje]

Jacques is my favorite bird, hands down. He has a great design (smug is a great personality for him since he looks like an struggling artist type), and a great interior (DJ themed). I also really like Piper and Sparro for their more natural looking designs. I think a lot of the birds are very cute and I wish more people gave them a chance.

I think the only design I don't like is Jacob's just because I have no idea what's going on there. Why those clashing colors? Why the teeny eyes? Why the very long eyebrows? It's a bit of a mess.

 

[Jinglefruit]

They are all best birbs. All birbs are good birbs.
Picking Twiggy as best of the best, for being the closest to a 'tiel and also sharing my birthday.