• Mario Kart players, joins us in TBT Neighborly Games and earn a recolor of the new toy car collectible. Sign up in the Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Weekend thread. More sessions to be added!

Mafia The Hunger Games Mafia - Game Thread - Endgame - Mafia + Survivor Win

@Farobi explain why I am slight SL pls?
I just got here :'c

Repetition doesn't give you much merit to be townleaned yet, and null is too generous. That read can change pretty easily though.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Not saying entirely either you or Dolby is scum what if I'm a scum after all or either punchy and if you guys are right about punchy all along then we can discuss about me simple

Since Antonio/Punchy are the ones set for lynch, who do you think is the best choice for lynch?
 
Honestly I have no idea how I would defend myself at the moment. Going ahead with the Antonio lynch, I'll see if anything has happened in the morning.

Is there any reason why the points that people brought up about Antonio potentially being Mafia stood out to you more than the points about PunchydaHufflePuff potentially being Mafia ? Basically, why did you choose an Antonio lynch over a Punchy lynch ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

##VOTE: Antonio

ive caught up! i was with my friends after school got out

I think that when the day ends, either punchy or rune should be lynched, based on current events. punchys been acting suspicious this entire game thus far and im not over my InCREDIBLY WELL FORMULATED hunch about rune

oh hey, punchy is browsing the thread. punchy, tell us all about how you feel about being sussed out. my ears are wide open and eagerly waiting for you

Why the switch onto Antonio ?

CalamityBot is not new. He knows what he is doing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

CalamityBot I'm also curious where you stand on Farobi now ? You voiced suspicion on him at the beginning and said Dolby could be trusted. Where do you stand now that Dolby has said Farobi is a Town lean for him ?
 
Good morning everyone im ready for a good day of mafia
 
Who do you see yourself voting for today ? Where are your thoughts at ?

Well hello to u too. ;u;
It was the same as yesterdays no one seems overly suspicious and im just going off what other people say due to the lack of whats happening in this game
 
Well hello to u too. ;u;
It was the same as yesterdays no one seems overly suspicious and im just going off what other people say due to the lack of whats happening in this game

Sorry, hi Gavin. :p

Well some things have happened up to now. What are some things that you would consider suspicious in general ? How would you try to find Mafia ?
 
i look for the people who aren't active and determine why they aren't active. Maybe too busy disscusing with scum motives?
 
i look for the people who aren't active and determine why they aren't active. Maybe too busy disscusing with scum motives?

Okay, that's reasonable. Is there any players you feel may be busy discussing with scum motives ? You were very spot on in Tina's game about my Mafia team so I definitely would like to consider your opinion.
 
Since Antonio/Punchy are the ones set for lynch, who do you think is the best choice for lynch?

Punchy would be the best lynch in my opinion this will determine list of people who are involved with him. Still need to reevaluate Antonio and can be discuss after Punchy lynch

Also I was about to ask Calamity the same thing but Kayla got it so eh
 
Okay, that's reasonable. Is there any players you feel may be busy discussing with scum motives ? You were very spot on in Tina's game about my Mafia team so I definitely would like to consider your opinion.

No not really im keeping an eye on punchy because i becane wary of him since last game even tho the only thing scummy he did is act agressive
 
Punchy would be the best lynch in my opinion this will determine list of people who are involved with him. Still need to reevaluate Antonio and can be discuss after Punchy lynch

Also I was about to ask Calamity the same thing but Kayla got it so eh

So I'm the most towny in your opinion and I'm the best lynch?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also who added the punchy die tag
 
I'm not entirely confident but I have a feeling Punchy vs. Waffles may be a Scum vs. Town situation. I've been personally juggling around with this idea since Waffles said Punchy looked like a confused Town player amongst Farobi & Dolby. It stood out to me because in that situation Farobi's instincts to catch any potential slip, was way too town-like to ignore. Given Punchy's general way of playing, I can see why people would automatically pull Punchy and say " definitely lost Town player here " so I gave it a bit of a pass. But I'm starting to feel like there was more to Waffles saying Punchy is a confused Town player.

I don't feel comfortable voting for Antonio or Punchy. That's my biggest problem right now. Both of those players have shown signs of potentially being Mafia though, I definitely agree. I'm just playing around with different scenarios in case both of them may be giving us the classic case of " bad Town ".
 
Good morning everyone! :D

I just woke up and haven't caught up or read anything since last night but today is Saturday so it's cleaning day and I'm going to see infinity war later tonight (no spoils plz) so I might not be so active today.

I'll be on and off on discord though, just ping me if you would like to talk. c:

Hope everyone has a nice day!
 
Punchy would be the best lynch in my opinion this will determine list of people who are involved with him. Still need to reevaluate Antonio and can be discuss after Punchy lynch

Also I was about to ask Calamity the same thing but Kayla got it so eh

Waffles wants to lynch Punchy for informational purposes but I don't see a reason to want to lynch someone you called a lost Town player for information. Do you believe Punchy can be Mafia too, Waffles ? If you do, why do you think he can be Mafia ?
 
Is there any reason why the points that people brought up about Antonio potentially being Mafia stood out to you more than the points about PunchydaHufflePuff potentially being Mafia ? Basically, why did you choose an Antonio lynch over a Punchy lynch ?

At this point I really don't know about Punchy, honestly.

Also, I scumleaned Antonio before Evan and Dolby made their points on him. That's why I asked him that question on page 21.
 
Waffles, what do you think about lynching a player like Dolby for information ? If you're willing to do so on Punchy, would you be willing to do so on a player like Dolby ? He has ties to several players in this game as well and he is amongst the list of people you said you believe could be Mafia ( you, Punchy, Farobi, Dolby - was the list you said ).

- - - Post Merge - - -

CalamityBot, why did you accuse Farobi of being eager too early, but not Dolby when he jumped on Waffles at the beginning. I know Dolby did not straight up say " AKA you're scum " like Farobi did, but I'm a little surprised you didn't see Dolby's move as eager or even call him out on it since you were looking into how eager Farobi was.
 
Haha, I was waiting for you all to see my antonio vote. I was swayed by the two others who had cast their vote for antonio. I still dont have a very good stance on punchy and id like to wait a bit more before we lynch him. At this point, i think its obvious that antonio is scum
 
Back
Top