Mafia The Hunger Games Mafia - Game Thread - Endgame - Mafia + Survivor Win

[MapleSilver]

MapleSilver, who would you vote for between Punchy and Waffles ?

That same question applies to: CalamityBot, GhostKid, Byngo ( unless getting replaced or ? ), Locket

Dedenne2 already voted for Punchy so that tells me her answer I guess ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy, Waffles & Dolby actually ^

Who would you guys vote for ? I have a feeling no one will say Dolby. :/

To be honest, I have no idea anymore. This game has shown me that I clearly have no idea what I'm doing so I'm just going to shut up for a while.

 

[iLoveYou]

Why Farobi of all people ?

 

[Dolby]

Punchy, why aren't you focusing on Waffles in this case ? She is literally on the chopping block right now. But instead you're trying to bring in a bunch of other people. That comes off very suspicious.

I sus them both two, but I'm like 99% sure that they aren't a team. Punchy started out the game going after Farobi for criticizing my own push on Waffles. Waffles has Punchy as her top choice for lynch, and yes, she has changed that stance, but a more telling move I feel is sussing Punchy for his explanation on why he thought that Rune was SK. Multiple players thought that he was genuine for it and Waffles came in after the interaction AND only then said that it felt fake. Not a teamming interaction I feel

 

[iLoveYou]

To be honest, I have no idea anymore. This game has shown me that I clearly have no idea what I'm doing so I'm just going to shut up for a while.

Please don't be quiet. All thoughts on the game are very much appreciated. I get it's your first game but playing will surely give you a better experience ( to develop yourself as a player & learn ) than staying quiet. We need everyone's opinions.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Why Farobi of all people ?

Something he said in Woodpines scumchat

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy, why aren't you focusing on Waffles in this case ? She is literally on the chopping block right now. But instead you're trying to bring in a bunch of other people. That comes off very suspicious.

bruh
only you are pressuring her
and I'm only trying to lynch Antonio.

 

[Dolby]

Something he said in Woodpines scumchat

- - - Post Merge - - -



bruh
only you are pressuring her
and I'm only trying to lynch Antonio.

How is Antonio's NL vote when by voting you he takes the lynch off of himself fundamentally different than you accusing Rune of being an SK?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

How is Antonio's NL vote when by voting you he takes the lynch off of himself fundamentally different than you accusing Rune of being an SK?

I don't understand what you are trying to ask me.

 

[Dolby]

I don't understand what you are trying to ask me.

You pressuring Rune as being mafia then SK when he claimed survivor, which will eventually become confirmable on D3 or later, was counterproductive, and a lynch against him when he's confirmable has >1% chance of hitting scum. I consider that anti-town

NL votes in my mind are anti-town to, but how are Antonio's actions in any way different from yours if that is the criteria by which we're measuring?

- - - Post Merge - - -

To be honest, I have no idea anymore. This game has shown me that I clearly have no idea what I'm doing so I'm just going to shut up for a while.

A good start I feel is narrowing down who you think and know is town. That helps you narrow down who can be mafia and who you shouldn't vote

 

[Antonio]

I do not have a coach nor need one and your reasoning for my lynch bothers me. No one encouraged me to vote NL and you never quoted what was anti-town.

That being said, you been coming off as sort of (maybe on and off) aggressive during this game (or at least imo) which puts my experiment to an end and me looking at you the most. The experiment was me just moderating your posts and see how aggressive you are. The reason behind this was in the only game where I remember you were mafia (Ness recent small game which only had 1 mafia; not counting the all mafia game Ness had) and you were extremely aggressive as mafia. Other games, you were town or from what I remember.

I will be keeping my NL vote because in the games I have played with punchy, his game play has been super misleading and people voted him off but he was innocent. I would rather see how things play out during night 1. I also have to be totally honest, I'm not sure if he is a aggressive or not but this is just my perspective and he's not acting like the nice and loveable punchy that I know.

I didn't want to state my reasons earlier because I was worried punchy would change his wording to seem nicer if I stated. Anyways, this took almost 30 minutes to write on my iPhone on the way to infinity war. I'm waiting for the movie to start as of right now, so I'll be off for now. Have a nice day!

 

[PunchyTheCat]

You pressuring Rune as being mafia then SK when he claimed survivor, which will eventually become confirmable on D3 or later, was counterproductive, and a lynch against him when he's confirmable has >1% chance of hitting scum. I consider that anti-town

NL votes in my mind are anti-town to, but how are Antonio's actions in any way different from yours if that is the criteria by which we're measuring?

- - - Post Merge - - -



A good start I feel is narrowing down who you think and know is town. That helps you narrow down who can be mafia and who you shouldn't vote

mk so I never called rune Mafia, I may have called him scum which applies to hostile TP too. I really still don't understand how survivor is confirm able. Please explain it again.


Alright. Let me gather my thoughts for the last part. After thinking a bit, I think I am going to vote Waffles. She seriously hasn't said much since she began to be sussed which reminds me of APM.

- - - Post Merge - - -

oh
I thought that last part was directed towards me lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

also I can kind of see a link between ILY and Dolby, I will have to look back at their interactions with the lynched person after EoD.

- - - Post Merge - - -

also Kamm please vote. Waffles is my preferred lynch canidate.
this goes to everyone else too.

 

[Kamzitty]

I'm going to vote for punchy now since I don't know if I'll be on later to vote. I haven't been home and my only way to access TBT is through my phone but it's been giving me problems :/ so I'm very behind in this game so far. From what I've seen punchy has been the most sus so far.

 

[cornimer]

I need a replacement

 

[iLoveYou]

In the case of Waffles vs. Punchy, I was leaning towards Waffles being Mafia. I'm not understanding how Punchy as Mafia, with a Mafia chat, would be able to play this badly ? Wouldn't someone be telling him how to blend in more and play it out better ? He's just throwing out random names now and sus'ing random people, which looks so bad.

That's my issue. I want to vote for Waffles but right now that means splitting the votes and potentially Antonio ( who reached 3 first ) would get lynched.

I don't know what to do. :{ My gut says Waffles in the case of Waffles vs. Punchy.

 

[amazonevan19]

I'm trying to sort through a large amount of people who I wouldn't object to be lynched today, but currently what's going through my head is Punchy v Silver v Waffles. Antonio is prob town

Evan wtf on cala

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok, I have two hands now

Cala=TL
Cala=SL

wtf Evan

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I am 100% placing my vote on anything that keeps the lynch off of Antonio at this point after that NL vote

gdi copypaste

I meant to cut instead of copy because I had the list of names and was putting him in the scumpool but I did not notice his name was still in the townleans. I definitely have a hard time seeing him as town after he went after punchy so hard (potential d1 bus) and he does know a lot more about mafia then he's letting on, which is shady.

 

[Kamzitty]

In the case of Waffles vs. Punchy, I was leaning towards Waffles being Mafia. I'm not understanding how Punchy as Mafia, with a Mafia chat, would be able to play this badly ? Wouldn't someone be telling him how to blend in more and play it out better ? He's just throwing out random names now and sus'ing random people, which looks so bad.

That's my issue. I want to vote for Waffles but right now that means splitting the votes and potentially Antonio ( who reached 3 first ) would get lynched.

I don't know what to do. :{ My gut says Waffles in the case of Waffles vs. Punchy.

Tbh I haven't been able to look into waffles much, but in response to the punchy thing it's a possibility that the whole suss'ing random people and bad play could be a ploy to make us think it's just regular old town punchy playing badly, so I wouldn't say that makes him the least likely to be mafia between the two of them.
I will look more into waffles when I get the chance but the forum has been loading so badly on my phone.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

ILY
vote waffles. SHE IS EXACTLY MIRRORING HER BEHAVIOR IN APM. oh my god. DOLBY. Look at Waffles' behavior in the last like 12 hours and right before Waffles was lynched in APM

 

[iLoveYou]

ILY
vote waffles. SHE IS EXACTLY MIRRORING HER BEHAVIOR IN APM. oh my god. DOLBY. Look at Waffles' behavior in the last like 12 hours and right before Waffles was lynched in APM

But she doesn't even know she can potentially get lynched. Unless she is Mafia and she's relying on a Mafia chat. So you can't say that she's playing ( or her behaviour ) is to prevent herself from getting lynched.

 

[amazonevan19]

I'm still sticking with Antonio. Organizing my scumpool, from most to least likely to be scum: Antonio, Punchy, unravel, Dolby, Calamity. Fine with an Antonio/Punchy lynch; would like to see more information before lynching unravel, dolby, or calamity but think they're likely scums as well.

Kayla: What happened to wanting a Dolby vote?

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm still sticking with Antonio. Organizing my scumpool, from most to least likely to be scum: Antonio, Punchy, unravel, Dolby, Calamity. Fine with an Antonio/Punchy lynch; would like to see more information before lynching unravel, dolby, or calamity but think they're likely scums as well.

Kayla: What happened to wanting a Dolby vote?

My vote is still on Dolby. I believe there is Mafia between Dolby, Waffles and potentially CalamityBot, like I said. It's coming down to Waffles vs. Punchy and I tried to convince people that the lynch should be between Dolby and Waffles but people still posted after that that they want it between Punchy and Antonio. Then Antonio voted No Lynch & everything else happened.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Considering Waffles was in my scum pool and the only other person likely to be lynched, she's the only one I can consider in the case of Punchy vs. Waffles as potential lynch candidates.

 

[Ghostkid]

Ask Gavin time 2!
You know the drill i wanna feel usful in this game