Mafia The Hunger Games Mafia - Game Thread - Endgame - Mafia + Survivor Win

[Dolby]

I’m gonna have problems contributing or weighing in on anything until pretty much right before the deadline, but I am more than fine with Punchy, Antonio or Silver, and consider everybody up to my null pool fair game (from my previous reads post)

 

[iLoveYou]

Haha, I was waiting for you all to see my antonio vote. I was swayed by the two others who had cast their vote for antonio. I still dont have a very good stance on punchy and id like to wait a bit more before we lynch him. At this point, i think its obvious that antonio is scum

Aren't you worried that one of them could be Mafia ? There are potentially 3 Mafia players interfering to get a mislynch today.

In all of this I see Dolby sitting back a lot. I see him not guiding as much as he usually does. I see him not challenging players like me, Evan and Farobi ( unless we challenge him first ). I see him popping into the thread but staying quiet and I'm looking into that as him waiting to see how this lynch plays out. I don't feel confident that Dolby is Town. I'm not entirely confident on Waffles either. I don't see Dolby questioning posts as much and his way of earning any Town cred was mainly via the Third Party claim by Rune ( in my opinion ). As Mafia, that's so easy to comment on while appearing Town.

IF Antonio or Punchy were Town, they are so easy to get a mislynch on due to their level of Town play in general ( generally looking Mafia even when actually Town ).

If Dolby is Mafia, all he has to do is use 2 KP ( assuming we mislynch ) on the most vocal players and then he wins by Day Two. Literally almost everyone is sheeping on who he suggests as suspicious and that's dangerous. Especially with the players in this specific game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't see Dolby voicing his thoughts as much as I did when he was Town and I really think he may be Mafia. He said at the beginning he was going to be VERY active until May 7. I believe.

 

[iLoveYou]

I would 100% prefer today's lynch be between Dolby and Waffles. Waffles didn't even question why Dolby jumped on her at the beginning. Her reply to him was weak. This is CalamityBot's first TBT game and he trusts Dolby, right off the bat, out of everyone ? No. There's something not right there. I highly doubt all three are Mafia but I do believe there is Mafia between Dolby, Waffles & potentially CalamityBot.

 

[dedenne]

oof i almost forgot to vote, voting punchy because of reasons already stated and i dont have any strong scumleans

 

[iLoveYou]

Antonio if you vote No Lynch, you might be letting yourself get lynched today and if you're Town you need to help yourself and us not have a mislynch.

You said you were looking into Rune and Punchy. Why aren't you voting for one of them then ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Literally, why would a Mafia vote for No Lynch when they are a lynch candidate ? If Antonio were Mafia I would think he would ensure his safety by voting for Punchy.

 

[Antonio]

Antonio if you vote No Lynch, you might be letting yourself get lynched today and if you're Town you need to help yourself and us not have a mislynch.

You said you were looking into Rune and Punchy. Why aren't you voting for one of them then ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Literally, why would a Mafia vote for No Lynch when they are a lynch candidate ? If Antonio were Mafia I would think he would ensure his safety by voting for Punchy.

I'm aware of it but I don't have anyone that I truly believe is Mafia. I want to see how night 1 plays out first.

 

[iLoveYou]

Dolby what are your thoughts on how the votes are going ? Where do you plan to place your vote today ?

 

[amazonevan19]

hmm Kayla does have some good points about Dolby and waffles but I really think an Antonio or Punchy lynch would help clear up some issues and help us detect alignments better. Dolby has been a bit more quiet but while he did say he was going to be active, I also understood he was going to have IRL stuff decrease his activity level somewhat.

Quick D1 reads/pools:

The confirmed TP is rune (obviously)

My townleans are Calamity/Farobi/Ghostkid/Byngo

My nulls are ILY/Dedenne/Kammm/Silver/Locket

My scumpool atm is Antonio/Punchy/Dolby/unravel/Calamity. This doesn't mean I think they're all scum, but rather that these are the people I think have a strong likelihood of being scum.

 

[Dolby]

Dolby what are your thoughts on how the votes are going ? Where do you plan to place your vote today ?

I'm trying to sort through a large amount of people who I wouldn't object to be lynched today, but currently what's going through my head is Punchy v Silver v Waffles. Antonio is prob town

Evan wtf on cala

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok, I have two hands now

Cala=TL
Cala=SL

wtf Evan

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, I am 100% placing my vote on anything that keeps the lynch off of Antonio at this point after that NL vote

 

[MapleSilver]

I'm trying to sort through a large amount of people who I wouldn't object to be lynched today, but currently what's going through my head is Punchy v Silver v Waffles. Antonio is prob town

Evan wtf on cala

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok, I have two hands now

Cala=TL
Cala=SL

wtf Evan

Wait, since when did you think Antonio was "prob town?"

 

[Dolby]

Wait, since when did you think Antonio was "prob town?"

I have my own reasons behind the 180, but as an excerpt from what I'm working on

However, I see no reason for him as scum to vote for a no lynch when he's tied in votes with Punchy and for that action alone he moves off of my sus list.

 

[iLoveYou]

MapleSilver, who would you vote for between Punchy and Waffles ?

That same question applies to: CalamityBot, GhostKid, Byngo ( unless getting replaced or ? ), Locket

Dedenne2 already voted for Punchy so that tells me her answer I guess ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy, Waffles & Dolby actually ^

Who would you guys vote for ? I have a feeling no one will say Dolby. :/

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm aware of it but I don't have anyone that I truly believe is Mafia. I want to see how night 1 plays out first.

I'm sorry
can I vote you now

 

[Antonio]

I'm sorry
can I vote you now

Oh :c

I never asked you this but what is your reason for my Lynch?

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm sorry
can I vote you now

What happened to wanting to lynch Waffles ? Why Antonio ?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

What happened to wanting to lynch Waffles ? Why Antonio ?

I still want to lynch waffles, but I highly doubt that would pick up steam. HE FLIPPING JUST DID AN ANTI TOWN THING LIKE SMH WHY. plus I could totally see the mafia, encouraging him to vote NL to basically clear him, because that's what's happened.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does Antonio have a coach?

 

[Dolby]

Hey, don't blame me for forgetting that I had to pick a college to go to by the 1st

Antonio's reluctance and inability to provide any reads, with the exception of Rune, comes off particularly bad to me, especially in comparison to last game where he came out with 5 scum leans D1 with some reasoning. However, I see no reason for him as scum to vote for a no lynch when he's tied in votes with Punchy and for that action alone he moves off of my sus list.

Personally, I find myself juggling to many possible team combination and circumstances, but I find myself with a scum pool of Punchy and Maple, with unravel and Byngo trending towards the side of mafia of null on that list as well. Waffles vasicillations on Punchy have felt particularly off to me.

So far I don't have any suspicions as of moment but I think Punchy is town and misunderstood the whole thing and rest are null (will change later...)

Girl why do I feel like its scripted?


For now I feel like Rune lynch is much more safer but I rather save it in mid game in case we have a doubt who to lynch.

R A N D O M L Y N C H G U Y S

Not saying entirely either you or Dolby is scum what if I'm a scum after all or either punchy and if you guys are right about punchy all along then we can discuss about me simple

Punchy would be the best lynch in my opinion this will determine list of people who are involved with him. Still need to reevaluate Antonio and can be discuss after Punchy lynch

Also I was about to ask Calamity the same thing but Kayla got it so eh

Waffles has held and changed her stance on Punchy four different times, from her first townlean, to slightly scum, to townlean again. Finally, this morning she decides that she wants him lynched.


Again, I'm going to state that Punchy and Waffles are 100% incompatible teammates, which leaves me somewhat conflicted on the two of them. I still feel that he feels different in his posting, and his "I was hungry" excuse doesn't hold water.

Maple's participation so far has been extremely weak so far. She opens by posting this, a CP of what Evan said

Right now I'm most comfortable with a Rune lynch.

1. He's telling the truth, so his death is neutral to town.

2. He's lying and is scum, so his death is beneficial.

3. He's lying and he's town. Would a town player ever want to do that though?

Her only substantial content has been pushing Antonio, a widely popular opinion and pretty easy bandwagon I feel

hmm Kayla does have some good points about Dolby and waffles but I really think an Antonio or Punchy lynch would help clear up some issues and help us detect alignments better. Dolby has been a bit more quiet but while he did say he was going to be active, I also understood he was going to have IRL stuff decrease his activity level somewhat.

Quick D1 reads/pools:

The confirmed TP is rune (obviously)

My townleans are Calamity/Farobi/Ghostkid/Byngo

My nulls are ILY/Dedenne/Kammm/Silver/Locket

My scumpool atm is Antonio/Punchy/Dolby/unravel/Calamity. This doesn't mean I think they're all scum, but rather that these are the people I think have a strong likelihood of being scum.

Evan has to answer for this atrocity at some point and I want an explanation and his real read on calamity

At the end of the day, I feel like I'm going to end up voting Punchy, though Maple is my first choice right now

 

[PunchyTheCat]

hey dolby, what do you think of ILY sussing you?

- - - Post Merge - - -

tbh I'm not really comfortable with a quiet Farobi, can you post some more please?

 

[Dolby]

hey dolby, what do you think of ILY sussing you?

I've been less active so far this game than I've planned, but I really see no reason why I should be a lynch candidate at this point. I don't tl or sl her for it because her grievences with me are kinda based on how I said I would play this game

(Def using my KP on the two most vocal players though, aka, me and her)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy, what do you think of my Tl of Antonio?

 

[iLoveYou]

Punchy, why aren't you focusing on Waffles in this case ? She is literally on the chopping block right now. But instead you're trying to bring in a bunch of other people. That comes off very suspicious.