I'm a little surprised you would call Antonio & Punchy Town Dolby, but then look at me and put me as middle-null. Lower than CalamityBot who you have never played a game of TBT Mafia with. Is there any reason in particular that you would think I should be less trusted ? Because if they're both Town to you, that would mean I moved the lynch off of two Town players and onto another one. The simplest thing for Mafia to do would be to sit back and watch Antonio get lynched in this case. I would only lead a lynch if I am bussing a teammate ( ex: Tom ) or if I am in a do or die situation ( ex: me vs. Dad final three ).
We both know why Punchy is 100% town, and I think that you agree with me that Antonio is probably town as well. No mafia makes that appeal at the end of day when they think they have been lynched by calling out and excluding certain names which could be analyzed.
Now, the key thing with Punchy and Antonio are that they're townlocks, you aren't. As I said in my post, I feel both of your and Evan's content to be town motivated however there are reasons that each of you are low on my list, despite me feeling that you're town, I don't really have a strong feeling that you aren't mafia that's key to be putting out a read. Evan has a pretty strong scumgame I feel in terms of feigning town content (for example, in two separate games when he was scum and I was town he was the only mafia member who I townleaned D1) and I feel that he's been putting forward town content. However, he has a tell that I base my read on him about most of the time now, being overprotective of his teammates. You've been forward good content, and while I do have the feeling you're a player who has a could control of making how they act as scum similar to how you act as town, I haven't played as town with you in years which makes me uncomfortable townreading you at this point
As for switching it from Antonio to Waffles, that's totally something any experienced scum to do. A great way to get cheap temporary towncred for "why would they stick out their neck to save x by lynching y when x was town?. It's one of my two favorite ways to get towncred through voting (the other being staying within the minority). Point being, pushing off of Antonio onto Waffles could easily be a move to gain towncred.
dolby has been iffy for me this entire game thus far, through him advocating against a rune lynch because it would "hurt the town", despite it having no effect on the town.
For the 1000th ****ing time, if we lynch Rune, we lose a chance to hit mafia and lower their KP. Rune is confirmable anyway since all he has to do is out at MYLO or LYLO for scum to win, so he pretty much can't be mafia. While yes, town isn't hurt by lynching him, we do lose a chance to lynch mafia by going after him
also, with the way hes been defending antonio. due to antonios new-ness to mafia and his end of day post begging to not be lynched, i feel like dolby has been telling antonio what to do in their very own mafia chat. dolby, thoughts?
Antonio's end of day post definetely caused no votes to be changed because it occured so late, thus not having an affect on changing who was lynched. Why would I tell him to name name if we were scum together? Heck, I wasn't even a primary voice in getting the vote off of Antonio, I switched to him pretty much the minute Punchy claimed and made furthur effort to get the vote off of him until Kayla began coalition building
Do you all seriously think that I'm scum with Punchy and Antonio? Antonio I can understand why people don't think he's town even though I heavily disagree with it, but Punchy should be townlocked by every single one of you
town: maplesilver, ghostkid, farobi, ily, evan
null: punchy, rune, dedenne, philemon
scum: antonio, dolby
I still want to think that you're town for that thing with Farobi, but why are Punchy and Rune, who should be pretty much confirmed, null and not town. Why is Maple so town and what prompted your 180 on Farobi?
- - - Post Merge - - -
tbh Antonio's play is reminding me of my play in CTSTP
at this point idk what to think of Antonio or Dolby
I mean I kind of see where cal is coming from, Silver seems like noob town imo, and Dolby might have been trying to get a ml. I think vig shot should be Farobi/Antonio. both seem scummy, both are going to be up for lynch tomorrow. I strongly encourage vig to shoot tonight, they probably won't be rb'ed unless there's a strongarm. Also if you're a ONE shot vig claim day 2 if your shot went through
How is Silver noob town? Literally the only opinion that she's put forward since the lynch is that she does not trust you
Vig should not shoot tonight, give me like 5 minutes to verift that I'm right on this
