Mafia The Hunger Games Mafia - Game Thread - Endgame - Mafia + Survivor Win

[Antonio]

I meant at the time, Your claim came three minutes before EOD, so you might have effectively just not have claimed for the purposes of my statement. Point being, I really don't think any of the voters on either you or Waffles were motivated by finding blue blood

Ah ok.

 

[amazonevan19]

I don't remember saying anything about day 1, just night 1. Even if I did, I meant night 1. Also, I have been scumming hunting. Have you just not seen my post with my reads? What have you done exactly?


@Dolby I did claim, it's in the quoted message.

Ah ok. I still think I have a point though because yes, I've read your posts, and all I see you doing is casting sus on people who should be confirmed or nigh confirmed, and not giving any actual thoughts as to who you want lynched. The inconsistency between thinking some players are scum and not actually wanting to lynch anyone is notable

- - - Post Merge - - -

wtf tbt why did that post again? I meant to post this follow up

As for what I've done (which btw I kinda find a scummy question to ask), I have at least provided some reads, though they are barebone and I should put up some more in depth ones once night results hit. I have also been trying to drive discussion and get people to express opinions where I feel they have been vague

 

[Antonio]

Ah ok. I still think I have a point though because yes, I've read your posts, and all I see you doing is casting sus on people who should be confirmed or nigh confirmed, and not giving any actual thoughts as to who you want lynched. The inconsistency between thinking some players are scum and not actually wanting to lynch anyone is notable

No your point doesn't stand. I have stated my reasons why I don't want to Lynch anyone till night 1 results. I need to see how mafia handles punchy and rune because they are visible threats to the game. If they aren't voted off, something has to be up. It's still the beginning of the day.

 

[Dolby]

No your point doesn't stand. I have stated my reasons why I don't want to Lynch anyone till night 1 results. I need to see how mafia handles punchy and rune because they are visible threats to the game. If they aren't voted off, something has to be up. It's still the beginning of the day.

Rune isn't a threat to the mafia. Should he be telling the truth, his existence means the game ends one day earlier

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Tbh I'm down for a Farobi lynch tomorrow, if I don't get rb'd or killed I want to investigate someone else. I'll repeat this, Farobi said in Woodpines scum chat that a quiet Farobi is a deadly Farobi. He also mentioned in that scum chat that it was hard to fake reactions to town deaths. Iirc he didn't react at all. If there is a vig out there I'd shoot Farobi. He's reflecting scum meta so much imo.

 

[Antonio]

beginning of the game**

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Rune isn't a threat to the mafia. Should he be telling the truth, his existence means the game ends one day earlier

Also tbh he's either a N1 kill or he's surviving until endgame. He's basically a Town Lock (but TP you know what I mean)
Rune b4 like right before night ends can you post some reads? I want to see where you stand and you haven't been saying much.

 

[Antonio]

Rune isn't a threat to the mafia. Should he be telling the truth, his existence means the game ends one day earlier

He stayed he would work to help town in his first post with an orange survivor role. Keeping him alive would just benefit town.

 

[Philemon120]

omg Antonio you don't want to lynch anyone but believe Punchy and Rune are lying
What's the truth?
Mood at that meme btw Evan

 

[PunchyTheCat]

He stayed he would work to help town in his first post with an orange survivor role. Keeping him alive would just benefit town.

what's an orange role

 

[Philemon120]

Type of TP. Btw, I have reads going up ~3 minutes before EoN.

 

[Antonio]

omg Antonio you don't want to lynch anyone but believe Punchy and Rune are lying
What's the truth?
Mood at that meme btw Evan

Please read the last paragraph of my reads, ty.

 

[Philemon120]

- - - Post Merge - - -

That logic absolutely does not apply to Rune, because mafia can out themselves and Rune will mafside and lynch town, lest he get nightkilled for retribution. His existence ends the game 1 day early for mafia, and in Punchy's case, fair, but why let someone you think is scum live? Btw, I said if you had to lynch someone, so no lynch is not an option.

 

[MapleSilver]

To anyone saying that a cop claim is too risky for scum to claim, I would like to know how it is riskier than simply being lynched on the spot. By the way things were going, Punchy would have died had he not claimed. If he is fakeclaiming, he may not live for long, but he is alive now. Plus, it got the mislynch on Waffles and has a chance of drawing out the "real" cop.

Sorry, but I am not convinced Punchy is town. If he survives the night, I want him out of here. If he is telling the truth, I do not think scum will keep him alive, since they would risk being on an investigation.

 

[Philemon120]

The reason his claim is so believable is because of no CC and another mislynch will cost us greatly. It's safer for now to focus on scumhunting nulls on most reads lists and scumleans/reads.

 

[Ghostkid]

Im still here

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm a little surprised you would call Antonio & Punchy Town Dolby, but then look at me and put me as middle-null. Lower than CalamityBot who you have never played a game of TBT Mafia with. Is there any reason in particular that you would think I should be less trusted ? Because if they're both Town to you, that would mean I moved the lynch off of two Town players and onto another one. The simplest thing for Mafia to do would be to sit back and watch Antonio get lynched in this case. I would only lead a lynch if I am bussing a teammate ( ex: Tom ) or if I am in a do or die situation ( ex: me vs. Dad final three ).

 

[Antonio]

View attachment 216401

- - - Post Merge - - -

That logic absolutely does not apply to Rune, because mafia can out themselves and Rune will mafside and lynch town, lest he get nightkilled for retribution. His existence ends the game 1 day early for mafia, and in Punchy's case, fair, but why let someone you think is scum live? Btw, I said if you had to lynch someone, so no lynch is not an option.

That makes sense. Why didn't no one vote rune off day 1 then?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

That makes sense. Why didn't no one vote rune off day 1 then?

because he's not hostile to town atm

 

[Philemon120]

For now, Rune is a vote and a voice for town, and later, we can lynch him if need be.