The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Blueskyy]

I went for an all cats island: Not a fan of Snooty but I have all other personality types.
1. Bob
2. Punchy
3. Lolly
4. Kabuki
5. Raymond
6. Rudy
7. Kiki
8. Tangy
9. Rosie
10. Katt

I miss some of the villagers I had along the way, so may replace the last 5 on that list eventually with those I miss. F in chat for Roald, Shep, Bam, Fang and Coco.

1. Kiki
2. Rudy
3. Kabuki
4. Lolly
5. Bob
6. Rosie
7. Raymond
8. Tangy
9. Punchy
10. Katt

My favorite cat is Kitty though so I guess my taste is questionable? Lol

 

[Xara]

I went for an all cats island: Not a fan of Snooty but I have all other personality types.
1. Bob
2. Punchy
3. Lolly
4. Kabuki
5. Raymond
6. Rudy
7. Kiki
8. Tangy
9. Rosie
10. Katt

I miss some of the villagers I had along the way, so may replace the last 5 on that list eventually with those I miss. F in chat for Roald, Shep, Bam, Fang and Coco.

10. raymond
9. rosie
8. bob
7. kiki
6. punchy
5. tangy
4. kabuki
3. katt
2. rudy
1. lolly

 

[BluebearL]

I have already ranked a fair few of these so now it's my turn

My villagers:
-Dobie
-Puddles
-Raymond
-Sherb
-Reneigh
-Boots
-Judy
-Agnes
-Scoot
-Megan

I could never rank them, I love them so much myself!

 

[Epod]

I have already ranked a fair few of these so now it's my turn

My villagers:
-Dobie
-Puddles
-Raymond
-Sherb
-Reneigh
-Boots
-Judy
-Agnes
-Scoot
-Megan

I could never rank them, I love them so much myself!

Another great group of villagers, this was tricky!

10) Judy
9) Megan
8) Dobie
7) Boots
6) Reneigh
5) Scoot
4) Raymond
3) Sherb
2) Puddles
1) Agnes

 

[Xara]

I have already ranked a fair few of these so now it's my turn

My villagers:
-Dobie
-Puddles
-Raymond
-Sherb
-Reneigh
-Boots
-Judy
-Agnes
-Scoot
-Megan

I could never rank them, I love them so much myself!

10. reneigh
9. raymond
8. boots
7. judy
6. scoot
5. megan
4. sherb
3. agnes
2. puddles
1. dobie

 

[lulu9956]

Oh wow okay this is going to be hard, I do love all my villagers atm! But let's try.

10. Fuchsia
9. Sherb
8. Sterling
7. Wolfgang
6. Maple
5. Snooty
4. Pietro
3. Fauna
2. Papi
1. Flora

Did it feel weird ranking Snooty above Maple and Sherb? Definitely. Do I stand by that decision? Yes ahah

 

[Xara]

Oh wow okay this is going to be hard, I do love all my villagers atm! But let's try.

10. Fuchsia
9. Sherb
8. Sterling
7. Wolfgang
6. Maple
5. Snooty
4. Pietro
3. Fauna
2. Papi
1. Flora

Did it feel weird ranking Snooty above Maple and Sherb? Definitely. Do I stand by that decision? Yes ahah

10. snooty
9. pietro
8. wolfgang
7. sterling
6. flora
5. sherb
4. papi
3. maple
2. fauna
1. fuchsia

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

I went for an all cats island: Not a fan of Snooty but I have all other personality types.
1. Bob
2. Punchy
3. Lolly
4. Kabuki
5. Raymond
6. Rudy
7. Kiki
8. Tangy
9. Rosie
10. Katt

first off ty for doing a cat island so I dont have to

secondly here's my ranking:

10. kiki
9. katt
8. rosie
7. raymond
6. bob
5. rudy
4. kabuki
3. tangy
2. lolly
1. punchy

 

[carackobama]

this is my current lineup!

 

[Ananas Dragon]

I have already ranked a fair few of these so now it's my turn

My villagers:
-Dobie
-Puddles
-Raymond
-Sherb
-Reneigh
-Boots
-Judy
-Agnes
-Scoot
-Megan

I could never rank them, I love them so much myself!

1. Judy
2. Reneigh
3.Agnes
4. Raymond
5. Dobie
6.Scoot
7. Boots
8. Megan
9. Sherb
10. Puddles

Post automatically merged: May 25, 2020

this is my current lineup!View attachment 265233

1. Diana
2. Judy
3.Cookie
4.Tangy
5Julian
6.Merengue
7. Lolly
8. Erik
9. Sherb
10. Rooney

 

[absol]

this is my current lineup!View attachment 265233

10. Rooney
9. Tangy
8. Erik
7. Cookie
6. Julian
5. Sherb
4. Lolly
3. Judy
2. Diana
1. Merengue

I kinda wanna have Judy now :-o

 

[monsieurberry]

I have already ranked a fair few of these so now it's my turn

My villagers:
-Dobie
-Puddles
-Raymond
-Sherb
-Reneigh
-Boots
-Judy
-Agnes
-Scoot
-Megan

I could never rank them, I love them so much myself!

10. Scoot
9. Puddles
8. Boots
7. Megan
6. Dobie
5. Reneigh
4. Judy
3. Agnes
2. Raymond
1. Sherb!

 

[carackobama]

I highly recommend getting Judy if you can find her! she’s only been with me for a few days but she’s a delight <3

 

[Ananas Dragon]

I’m curious to compare my own thoughts to
others’!

View attachment 265088

very late but i need something to rank
1. Aurora
2. Reneigh
3. Vivian
4. Julia
5. Raymond
6. Bones
7. Ketchup
8. Dom
9. Winnie
10. Murphy

Post automatically merged: May 25, 2020

Rank my villagers?
-Judy
-Audie
-Rosie
-Bob
-Reneigh
-Diana
-Goldie
-Marina
-Hopkins
-Marshal

 

[monsieurberry]

-Judy
-Audie
-Rosie
-Bob
-Reneigh
-Diana
-Goldie
-Marina
-Hopkins
-Marshal

They are all so cute! This is a hard one...

10. Audie
9. Marina
8. Bob
7. Hopkins
6. Reneigh
5. Rosie
4. Goldie
3. Diana
2. Judy
1. Marshal

 

[carackobama]

Rank my villagers?

Rank my villagers?
-Judy
-Audie
-Rosie
-Bob
-Reneigh
-Diana
-Goldie
-Marina
-Hopkins
-Marshal

1. Diana
2. Rosie
3. Bob
4. Judy
5. Audie
6. Marina
7. Hopkins
8. Goldie
9. Marshal
10. Reneigh

 

[Ananas Dragon]

They are all so cute! This is a hard one...

10. Audie
9. Marina
8. Bob
7. Hopkins
6. Reneigh
5. Rosie
4. Goldie
3. Diana
2. Judy
1. Marshal

1. Diana
2. Rosie
3. Bob
4. Judy
5. Audie
6. Marina
7. Hopkins
8. Goldie
9. Marshal
10. Reneigh

I appreciate you all for not putting Hopkins at the bottom of the list <3

he might become my favorite villager soon and its a good thing

 

[monsieurberry]

I think Hopkin's is adorable and I love his concept!

 

[absol]

I highly recommend getting Judy if you can find her! she’s only been with me for a few days but she’s a delight <3

If I can find her yeah ...
I tried the campsite method at first to sell her later but ran across Diana and just couldn't pass her up

Spoiler: also love her surprised face lol

 

[Ananas Dragon]

If I can find her yeah ...
I tried the campsite method at first to sell her later but ran across Diana and just couldn't pass her up

Spoiler: also love her surprised face lol

View attachment 265243View attachment 265244

I also tried that to sell her, in the end I spent 175 nmt on the search for her, found her, then realized what the fudge i want this bear she is mine