The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Shawna]

I didn't realize it was mandatory based on earlier posts, my bad!

no worries, but this is like a forum game. Each poster ranks the previous poster’s villagers. I’m surprised the OP didn’t put this thread in the basement instead.

---

• Antonio - 6/10 - he’s not a favorite, but he was one of my very first villagers ever when I first played City Folk (my first AC game) so we do go way back.
• Bubbles - 5/10 - I’m not a fan of the hippos, she’s OK.
• Benedict - 7/10 - He’s pretty cute ^^
• Stu - 5/10 - Meh. I’m not a fan of the bowl villagers either, not much to say about him.
• Stella - 7/10 - She’s cute and I like the name Stella.
• Limberg - 6/10 - He’s goofy. XDDD
• Yuka - 6/10 - she would send me letters and cityfolk because I would talk to her in a town my brother had. Other than that, nothing much to say.
• Azalea - ?/10 - I had to look this one up.
• Ione - 8/10 - She’s absolutely beautiful. I would love to get her in my southern hemisphere town, especially considering I intend to make it astronomy themed.
• Huck - 7/10 - Very cute ^^

---

Here are mine (AC:NH)
* Ava
* Gabi
* Blanche
* Snooty
* Cherry
* Sherb
* Teddy
* Rooney
* Apollo
* Phil

 

[rocketspruggs]

৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७

♥ Ava - 6/10, she's kinda cute.

♡ Gabi - 4/10, meh, she's one of the least cute rabbits in the game.

♥ Blanche - 7/10, her design looks pretty.

♡ Snooty - 5/10, average.

♥ Cherry - 6/10, she's cool, I like her.

♡ Sherb - 8/10, he's so adorable!

♥ Teddy - 7/10, I like his expressions!

♡ Rooney - 8/10, he's one of my favorite cranky villagers!

♥ Apollo - 7/10, he's another cool cranky I like.

♡ Phil - 5/10, average. I like the anime sweat drop he uses when he's shocked.

৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७৶ꕤ७

Here are my villagers:

☆ Doc

☆ Stu

☆ Tipper

☆ Patty

☆ Chrissy

☆ Snake

☆ Toby

☆ Sasha

☆ Bonbon

☆ Genji

 

[himekirako]

1. sasha - i love him!! i love bunny villagers
2. toby - again, i'm biased towards the bunnies but it's also because keroppi has such cute items
3. tipper - my friend had her on his island and she was soooo sweet
4. patty - she seems so sweet
5. chrissy - can never hate a pink option heh but where is francine !!
6. snake - he seems so silly
7. stu - he seems so wholesome
8. bonbon - i loooove her name sm
9. doc - he seems so sweet
10. genji - i do find her really unique and would love to design a vacation home for her!!

my villagers:

• sparro
• apple
• maple
• zucker
• jitters
• ruby
• marina
• raymond
• marshal
• ankha

 

[WaileaNoRei]

1. sasha - i love him!! i love bunny villagers
2. toby - again, i'm biased towards the bunnies but it's also because keroppi has such cute items
3. tipper - my friend had her on his island and she was soooo sweet
4. patty - she seems so sweet
5. chrissy - can never hate a pink option heh but where is francine !!
6. snake - he seems so silly
7. stu - he seems so wholesome
8. bonbon - i loooove her name sm
9. doc - he seems so sweet
10. genji - i do find her really unique and would love to design a vacation home for her!!

my villagers:

• sparro
• apple
• maple
• zucker
• jitters
• ruby
• marina
• raymond
• marshal
• ankha

Can’t help but feel nostalgic whenever this thread comes around, cause it was the one where I made the jump from lurker to participant on this forum. Always had fun with this game. I like seeing people’s different opinions on the villagers. Overtime I find i like more and more villagers.


Sparro - 6/10 - he’s one of my favorite birds, though I’ve never had him on my island and probably won’t ever be a number one jock for me.

Apple - 11/10 - cause she is a cute, colorful, slightly crazy looking hamster. And I really like the peppies

Maple - 5/10 - she’s cute, but for me forgettable.

Zucker - 7/10 I find him really cute, and I love takoyaki, but I get a little weirded out by the food villagers. He’s one of the best of them though.

Jitters - 1/10 - I find him scary, sorry.

Ruby - 10/10 - love her, she’s so cute. On my long list of favorite peppies.

Marina - 7/10 - she’s cute but just not a favorite. I’ve gone back and forth on her and am currently on an upswing and so am liking her more

Raymond - 7/10 - he’s cute, and I don’t like that many of the smug villagers so he scores higher because he’s in that group. Not a fave, but I didn’t dislike having him when I briefly had him either. His house makes me sad - no one should have to live in an office.

Marshal - 7/10 - same as Raymond, he’s cute enough, but not a fave (my fave snugs are Rodney and Graham). When he came to my campsite I found I liked the idea of marshal, being all small and grumpy looking, more than the actual character.

Ankha - 7/10 - very cool design, I have no idea why I don’t like her more. She’s a snooty, which is not my favorite personality, but even so. Objectively I think she is really cool and a good looking villager. But I don’t have strong feelings about her.

——

My villagers - at least for now

1. Genji (permanent)
2. Bangle (permanent)
3. Tabby (permanent)
4. Rodney (permanent)
5. Soleil (permanent)
6. Daisy (probably permanent)
7. Goldie (maybe permanent)
8. Megan (probably short term)
9. Grizzly (probably short term)
10. Apple (not sure yet)

 

[Irescien]

1. Genji - 5/10 I really like him! hes kinda midrange to me but i definitely see the appeal
2. Bangle - 6/10 I think shes currently in my NL town, I do want to kick her out but I think she's very cute
3. Tabby - 6/10 I do kinda like tabby, she has a certain charm to her
4. Rodney - 2/10 sorry i do not like this man
5. Soleil - 5/10 She is cute! Just a little bright (also minus points for showing up too many times while im island hunting)
6. Daisy - 10/10 I love daisy honestly, such a sweetheart <3
7. Goldie - 8/10 very cute just never really clicked with her
8. Megan - 6/10 I also found her a little too bright, but shes a sweetie
9. Grizzly - 9/10 I find Grizzly very cute, he has a rough charm to him
10. Apple - 7/10 very cute! but I also feel like she's hiding something behind those eyes


✦ . 　⁺ 　 . ✦ . 　⁺ 　 . ✦ . 　⁺ 　 . ✦ . 　⁺ 　 . ✦

My villagers atm

1. Poppy
2. Rolf
3. Stitches
4. Judy
5. Kidd
6. Rudy
7. Katt
8. Shep
9. Leopold
10. Vivian (she just moved out, but shes an empty plot rn but, sure, judge her lol)

 

[Zerous]

1. Poppy - She's cute! Doesn't stand out to me that much though
2. Rolf - Never been my favourite design wise, but I love cranky villagers
3. Stitches - Also cute, never had him though and prefer other lazy villagers personally
4. Judy - Never been the biggest fan unfortunately, but I think her colour palette is pretty
5. Kidd - I like him! I was going to scan him into my town as my smug before cephalobot was released
6. Rudy - I've never had him but I've always liked his design!
7. Katt - yess I like katt, I think i had her at some point
8. Shep - Like him but not much of an opinion
9. Leopold - I like his green hair, but never had too much of an opinion on him
10. Vivian - again no strong opinions sorry, I think she's okay

Mine are:
1. Octavian
2. Punchy
3. Sydney
4. Purrl
5. Zucker
6. Cephalobot
7. Marina
8. Piper
9. Tasha
10. Agnes