The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[WaileaNoRei]

My villagers (for now at least) are:

- shari
- genji
- rex
- bangle
- vesta
- lionel
- flurry
- ruby
- kabuki
- Freya

I could say a lot more about how I feel about each one (I don’t hate any of them, but do have some favorites) but interested to see how they get ranked.

now I’m going to look through the thread again and find some villagers to rank

 

[Xara]

My villagers (for now at least) are:

- shari
- genji
- rex
- bangle
- vesta
- lionel
- flurry
- ruby
- kabuki
- Freya

I could say a lot more about how I feel about each one (I don’t hate any of them, but do have some favorites) but interested to see how they get ranked.

now I’m going to look through the thread again and find some villagers to rank

10. lionel
9. rex
8. vesta
7. bangle
6. ruby
5. genji
4. shari
3. kabuki
2. freya
1. flurry

 

[BluebearL]

My villagers (for now at least) are:

- shari
- genji
- rex
- bangle
- vesta
- lionel
- flurry
- ruby
- kabuki
- Freya

I could say a lot more about how I feel about each one (I don’t hate any of them, but do have some favorites) but interested to see how they get ranked.

now I’m going to look through the thread again and find some villagers to rank

My ranking from 1=best to 10=least favourite

1.Kabuki
2.Genji
3.Ruby
4.Bangle
5.Rex
6.Freya
7.Lionel
8.Flurry
9.Shari
10.Vesta

I actually really like all of these villagers so this was tough. I would probably have a completely different ranking if you asked me on a different day.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

If anyone would be interested in ranking my villagers, here they are! They don't really fit any coherent theme but I just find them cute
Static
Muffy
Graham
Raddle
Judy
Dom
Bob
Tangy
Gayle
Marshal

I think that’s the best way to collect villagers!

1. muffy
2. Tangy
3. Bob
4. Dom
5. Judy
6. Static ( I’d never heard of him and had to look him up!)
7. Marshal
8. Graham
9. Raddle
10. Gayle

great group you have there. Very colorful and varied in type and appearance. I can’t believe graham ended up at 8. I think he’s really cute!

Post automatically merged: Jun 8, 2020

Anyone want to rank my current villagers?

Aurora
Bam
Egbert
Murphy
Olive
Ozzie
Pecan
Pompom
Portia
Reneigh

1. Aurora
2. Pecan
3. Portia
4. Bam
5. Ozzie
6. Egbert
7. Pompom
8. Olive
9. Murphy
10. Reneigh

A great group. Makes me think I should give some species types another chance. Hope you are enjoying them, whether or not they are ‘permanent’.

 

[deleted]

My personal rating for my villagers

10. Hamlet
9. Marina
8. Whitney (I will be giving her to my boyfriend eventually because he really likes her)
7. Biskit
6. Audie
5. Sprinkle
4. June
3. Kabuki
2. Hornsby
1. Eunice

The rankings were very close. I try not to pick favorites but Eunice is my favorite villager EVER right now and 2-7 are pretty equal.

 

[Xara]

My personal rating for my villagers

10. Hamlet
9. Marina
8. Whitney (I will be giving her to my boyfriend eventually because he really likes her)
7. Biskit
6. Audie
5. Sprinkle
4. June
3. Kabuki
2. Hornsby
1. Eunice

The rankings were very close. I try not to pick favorites but Eunice is my favorite villager EVER right now and 2-7 are pretty equal.

10. hamlet
9. biskit
8. eunice
7. june
6. hornsby
5. kabuki
4. whitney
3. marina
2. sprinkle
1. audie

 

[John Wick]

All of mine are number one in my eyes. ^_^

In no particular order.

Wolfgang
Fang
Freya
Cherry
Mathilda
Daisy
Shep
Teddy
Claude
Flora.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Spoiler: Rankings

All of mine are number one in my eyes. ^_^

In no particular order.

Wolfgang
Fang
Freya
Cherry
Mathilda
Daisy
Shep
Teddy
Claude
Flora.

1. Flora
2. Claude
3. Freya
4. Shep
5. Daisy
6. Wolfgang
7. Fang
8. Teddy
9. Cherry
10. Mathilda

My personal rating for my villagers

10. Hamlet
9. Marina
8. Whitney (I will be giving her to my boyfriend eventually because he really likes her)
7. Biskit
6. Audie
5. Sprinkle
4. June
3. Kabuki
2. Hornsby
1. Eunice

The rankings were very close. I try not to pick favorites but Eunice is my favorite villager EVER right now and 2-7 are pretty equal.
[/QUOTE]
1. Sprinkle
2. June
3. Halmet
4. Kabuki
5. Eunice
6. Marina
7. Audie
8. Whitney
9. Biskit
10. Hornsby

My villagers (for now at least) are:

- shari
- genji
- rex
- bangle
- vesta
- lionel
- flurry
- ruby
- kabuki
- Freya

I could say a lot more about how I feel about each one (I don’t hate any of them, but do have some favorites) but interested to see how they get ranked.

now I’m going to look through the thread again and find some villagers to rank
[/QUOTE]
1. Genji
2. Freya
3. Vesta
4. Bangle
5. Flurry
6. Kabuki
7. Shari
8. Ruby
9. Lionel
10. Rex

If anyone would be interested in ranking my villagers, here they are! They don't really fit any coherent theme but I just find them cute
Static
Muffy
Graham
Raddle
Judy
Dom
Bob
Tangy
Gayle
Marshal

1. Bob
2. Judy
3. Tangy
4. Static
5. Dom
6. Muffy
7. Marshal
8. Raddle
9. Gayle
10. Graham

1. Coco
2. Zell - happy bday Zell!!!
3. Cranston
4. Hamlet
4. Apollo
5. Margie
6. Bill
7. Canberra
8. Bubbles

1. Apollo
2. Cranston
3. Hamlet
4. Coco
5. Bill
6. Zell
7. Margie
8. Canberra
9. Bubbles

Melba
Lily
Diana
Deirdre
Pashmina
Maple
Merry
Dotty
Blanche
Bluebear

1. Bluebear
2. Diana
3. Blanche
4. Merry
5. Lily
6. Maple
7. Dotty
8. Melba
9. Pashmina
10. Deirdre

New cast member, new rating! I personally could never rank my villagers as I love them all and each of them are dreamies so feel free to rank them for yourself!

-judy
-boots
-raymond
-cube
-dobie
-puddles
-sherb
-agnes
-scoot
-Megan

1. Dobie
2. Sherb
3. Judy
4. Cube
5. Raymond
6. Megan
7. Puddles
8. Boots
9. Scoot
10. Agnes

 

[Xara]

All of mine are number one in my eyes. ^_^

In no particular order.

Wolfgang
Fang
Freya
Cherry
Mathilda
Daisy
Shep
Teddy
Claude
Flora.

10. shep
9. claude
8. wolfgang
7. flora
6. mathilda
5. teddy
4. fang
3. freya
2. cherry
1. daisy

 

[Rasha]

Did this one before but will do again since I finally managed to get all my dreamies this time, here they are in alphabetical order, my favorites are Wolfgang, Bruce, Lobo and newly Kyle:

- Beau
- Bruce
- Chief
- Fang
- Freya
- Kyle
- Lobo
- Skye
- Whitney
- Wolfgang

 

[Xara]

Did this one before but will do again since I finally managed to get all my dreamies this time, here they are in alphabetical order, my favorites are Wolfgang, Bruce, Lobo and newly Kyle:

- Beau
- Bruce
- Chief
- Fang
- Freya
- Kyle
- Lobo
- Skye
- Whitney
- Wolfgang

10. kyle
9. wolfgang
8. chief
7. bruce
6. lobo
5. fang
4. freya
3. whitney
2. skye
1. beau

you have such good villagers, this was hard

 

[Gunner]

All of mine are random, as in, they randomly moved in or were the first animals I found on islands. I have an amiibo card though, but I can't choose who I should ditch, so am hoping people can help me decide

Frobert
Broffina
Elise
Phoebe
Admiral
Teddy
Gayle
Cranston
Ken
Hamlet

 

[Xara]

All of mine are random, as in, they randomly moved in or were the first animals I found on islands. I have an amiibo card though, but I can't choose who I should ditch, so am hoping people can help me decide

Frobert
Broffina
Elise
Phoebe
Admiral
Teddy
Gayle
Cranston
Ken
Hamlet

10. hamlet
9. broffina
8. elise
7. admiral
6. ken
5. cranston
4. phoebe
3. teddy
2. frobert
1. gayle

 

[EmperorGandhi]

All of mine are random, as in, they randomly moved in or were the first animals I found on islands. I have an amiibo card though, but I can't choose who I should ditch, so am hoping people can help me decide

Frobert
Broffina
Elise
Phoebe
Admiral
Teddy
Gayle
Cranston
Ken
Hamlet

1. Phoebe
2. Teddy
3. Cranston
4. Gayle
5. Hamlet
6. Admiral
7. Frobert
8. Ken
9. Broffina
10. Elise

 

[-Beth_]

On my 1st island (on the Switch Lite):

Tank, Chrissy, Savannah, Henry, Mira, Louie, Rex, Ike, Derwin, Avery
Former villagers: Muffy, Anchovy, Agnes, Gaston, Maelle, Gwen

On my 2nd island (on the Switch):

Rowan, Shari, Celia, Cheri, RAYMOND, Hugh, Soleil, Vladimir and Savannah
Former villagers: Egbert and Snake

 

[river]

On my 1st island (on the Switch Lite):

Tank, Chrissy, Savannah, Henry, Mira, Louie, Rex, Ike, Derwin, Avery
(I’m keeping most of these forever except for Tank and Savannah.)
Former villagers: Muffy, Anchovy, Agnes, Gaston, Maelle, Gwen

1. Henry ♥♥♥ love him
2. Ike
3. Avery
4. Savannah
5. Tank
6. Derwin
7. Rex
8. Louie
9. Chrissy
10. Mira

I actually think you have a very interesting mix of villagers! I had never seen Rex or Derwin before, they're really cute

Currently mine are, in no particular order

Samson
Chief
Bob
Apollo
Reneigh
Kiki
Roald
Hans
Dotty
Julian

 

[Applebunny]

This could be fun. I got (in order of move in):

Katt
Nan
Bonbon
Wolfgang
Muffy
Freya
Willow
Zell
Ankha
Pietro

Post automatically merged: Jun 8, 2020

Currently mine are, in no particular order

Samson
Chief
Bob
Apollo
Reneigh
Kiki
Roald
Hans
Dotty
Julian

1. Kiki ❤❤❤
2. Chief
3. Julian
4. Dotty
5. Reneigh
6. Apollo
7. Bob
8. Roald
9. Hans
10. Samson

 

[prettygreatbee]

This could be fun. I got (in order of move in):

Katt
Nan
Bonbon
Wolfgang
Muffy
Freya
Willow
Zell
Ankha
Pietro

1.Katt
2.Bonvon
3.Pietro
4.Willow
5.Ankha
6.Freya
7.Wolfgang
8.Zell
9.Nan
10.Muffy


thought thisd be neat so here are mine currently! (in order of when i got em)
Diva, Biff, Bianca, Alfonso, Fauna, Quillson, Dobie, Bob, Mac, Gwen
i might come back to this thread if i ever get all my dreamies lol

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My personal rating for my villagers

10. Hamlet
9. Marina
8. Whitney (I will be giving her to my boyfriend eventually because he really likes her)
7. Biskit
6. Audie
5. Sprinkle
4. June
3. Kabuki
2. Hornsby
1. Eunice

The rankings were very close. I try not to pick favorites but Eunice is my favorite villager EVER right now and 2-7 are pretty equal.

1. Kabuki
2. Eunice
3. Hornsby
4. Marina
5. Biskit
6. Audie
7. June
8. Whitney
9. Sprinkle
10. Hamlet

I guess we agree in a lot of ways. Eunice is really really cute! I’m biased toward kabuki because I have him too.

 

[Loubelle]

Is this with current villagers? if so,

1. Hamlet
2. Ursala
3. Dom
4. Eunice
5. Bianca
6. Octavian
7. Klaus
8. Opal
9. Hugh
10. Bitty

Bitty is the only one that i dislike of my current villagers tbh (nothing personal, just don't have much of a connection). A lot of them were very close (top 4 could possibly tie for first) and octavian, klaus, opal, and hugh i like about the same as well, though i definitely plan on replacing hugh with derwin which makes me sad to think about :C

edit: I'm seeing some Eunice love Eunice is such a sweetie omg she was my third move in ;w;