The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Jules]

Gosh I love Olivia

mine is:
Julian/ Ankha/ Sherb/ Blaire/ Tia/ Ozzie/ Stitches/ Skye/ Walt/ and soon Lucky

Post automatically merged: Jun 15, 2020

Not in ranking order just who I have..

1. Lucky
2. Skye
3. Walt (I'm actually waiting to amiibo in Walt myself, he's such a cute cranky)
4. Stitches
5. Sherb
6. Tia
7. Ankha
8. Blaire
9. Julian
10. Ozzie

My villagers: Tabby, Stinky, Raymond, Kiki, Dom, Diana, Midge, Kyle, Pashmina, Daisy

 

[Ananas Dragon]

Rank my villagers:
Reneigh
Sly


reset loneliness

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

My villagers: Tabby, Stinky, Raymond, Kiki, Dom, Diana, Midge, Kyle, Pashmina, Daisy

10. midge
9. diana
8. tabby
7. kiki
6. daisy
5. dom
4. pashmina
3. raymond
2. stinky
1. kyle

 

[Xara]

Rank my villagers:
Reneigh
Sly


reset loneliness

2. reneigh
1. sly

good luck with your new island! c:

 

[Porxelain]

1. Lucky
2. Skye
3. Walt (I'm actually waiting to amiibo in Walt myself, he's such a cute cranky)
4. Stitches
5. Sherb
6. Tia
7. Ankha
8. Blaire
9. Julian
10. Ozzie

My villagers: Tabby, Stinky, Raymond, Kiki, Dom, Diana, Midge, Kyle, Pashmina, Daisy

I really like Walt! Tbh he looks cranky but whenever I talk to him he’s real nice and positive it’s confusing?? He’s tried to leave twice and I said NOOo.

My order for your villagers would be:

Pashmina, Kyle, Raymond, Diana, Kiki, Dom, Daisy, tabby, stinky, midge
(I don’t know the last three very well)

 

[Todoroki_Fuyumi]

I know that people have tier lists for villagers, but I want personal opinions as well. Here's my island's resident history (Some moved away) I'll also be mentioning how I got them


Shari the Uchi Monkey: Starter
Antonio the Jock Anteater: Starter
Puddles the Peppy Frog (Moved): Random move-in
Moe the Lazy Cat (Moved): Random Move-in
Alice the Normal Koala (Moved): Found on first mystery island
Rodney the (ugly) smug hamster (moved thank God): First campsite
(Here's where the interesting villagers begin)
Rosie the Peppy Cat: Giveaway!
Wolfgang the Cranky Wolf: Giveaway!
Julian the Smug Unicorn: First mystery island on a Raymond hunt!
Diana the Snooty Deer: First mystery island on a Raymond hunt (1 day after Julian)
(Don't get mad from here on out)
Raymond the Smug Cat: Giveaway!!
Audie the Peppy Wolf: Bought for 10 NMT here!
Judy the Snooty Cub: Total accident, was TT to get an empty plot and she shows up in my campsite
Sherb the Lazy Goat: Bought for 200 NMT




If anyone was wondering: Raymond moved into Rodney's plot, Audie into Moe's, Judy into Puddles', and Sherb into Alice's

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Here's my personal rank for my villagers.
1. Stitches
2. Marshal
3. Bunnie
4. Punchy
5. Olivia
6. Poppy
7. Judy
8.Genji

Still searching for Ruby and Raymond.

How would you guys rank mine?

1.Genji
2. Judy
3. Poppy
4. Bunnie
5. Olivia
6. Marshal
7. Stitches
8. Punchy

if you had ruby and Raymond she’d probably be one or two and he’d be 9 or 10. I swear I did not purposely rank these In almost perfect reverse order from you!

Post automatically merged: Jun 20, 2020

10. tammy
9. jay
8. stella
7. ruby
6. dom
5. sherb
4. tybalt
3. flora
2. skye
1. audie

Post automatically merged: Jun 16, 2020

rank my guys

1. Lolly
2. Ankha
3. Scoot - how ridiculous he is; love it!
4. Audie
5. Raymond
6. Punchy
7. Cyd
8. Rolf
9. Kyle
10. Alfonso

Post automatically merged: Jun 20, 2020

I know that people have tier lists for villagers, but I want personal opinions as well. Here's my island's resident history (Some moved away) I'll also be mentioning how I got them


Shari the Uchi Monkey: Starter
Antonio the Jock Anteater: Starter
Puddles the Peppy Frog (Moved): Random move-in
Moe the Lazy Cat (Moved): Random Move-in
Alice the Normal Koala (Moved): Found on first mystery island
Rodney the (ugly) smug hamster (moved thank God): First campsite
(Here's where the interesting villagers begin)
Rosie the Peppy Cat: Giveaway!
Wolfgang the Cranky Wolf: Giveaway!
Julian the Smug Unicorn: First mystery island on a Raymond hunt!
Diana the Snooty Deer: First mystery island on a Raymond hunt (1 day after Julian)
(Don't get mad from here on out)
Raymond the Smug Cat: Giveaway!!
Audie the Peppy Wolf: Bought for 10 NMT here!
Judy the Snooty Cub: Total accident, was TT to get an empty plot and she shows up in my campsite
Sherb the Lazy Goat: Bought for 200 NMT




If anyone was wondering: Raymond moved into Rodney's plot, Audie into Moe's, Judy into Puddles', and Sherb into Alice's

Ranked most favorite to least, yes, I really do think Rodney is cute.

1. Alice
2. Shari
3. Rodney
4. Moe
5. Judy
6. Audie
7. Sherb
8. Wolfgang
9. Diana
10. Rosie
11. Raymond
12. Puddles
13. Julian
14. Antonio

 

[ZackFair77]

Just for fun here’s my current and permanent lineup! Rank em up!

 

[WaileaNoRei]

1. Lucky
2. Skye
3. Walt (I'm actually waiting to amiibo in Walt myself, he's such a cute cranky)
4. Stitches
5. Sherb
6. Tia
7. Ankha
8. Blaire
9. Julian
10. Ozzie

My villagers: Tabby, Stinky, Raymond, Kiki, Dom, Diana, Midge, Kyle, Pashmina, Daisy

1.Tabby -insofar as I have any ‘dreamies’ (still developing my preferences), she’s one.
2. Stinky underwear. mask. His catch phrase. His stupid happy flat face!
3. Kiki
4. Pashmina
5. Diana
6. Daisy
7. Dom
8. Raymond
9. Midge
10. Kyle

Post automatically merged: Jun 20, 2020

Just for fun here’s my current and permanent lineup! Rank em up!

1. Ruby
2. Judy (I decided today that I do like her. She is too much of everything, which is always fun)
3. Ankha - though i don’t know if I would want her because I feel like maybe she is too cool for me.
4. Bunnie
5. Olivia
6. Poppy
7. Marshal
8. Stitches
9. Raymond - not a raymond hater I swear! Haven’t seen him in game, which sometimes changes my mind. For now, it’s less dislike than that the others excite me more.
10. Punchy - holding an unfair and ridiculous grudge against punchy for interrupting my rock mining on a mystery island

That was fun!

 

[Xara]

Just for fun here’s my current and permanent lineup! Rank em up!

10. raymond
9. ruby
8. judy
7. ankha
6. bunnie
5. olivia
4. punchy
3. marshal
2. stitches
1. poppy

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My crew!

1. Apple
2. Agnes (these first three are so close)
3. Tangy
4. Freya
5. Dom
6. Sylvana
7. Ozzie
8. Butch
9. Eugene
10. Keaton

lovely crew!

 

[Meelie]

I restarted my island so here are my new villagers please rank them!
10. Axel
9. Tammy
8. Henry
7. Fauna
6. Stitches
5. Wolfgang
4. Marina
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Zucker

 

[Xara]

I restarted my island so here are my new villagers please rank them!
10. Axel
9. Tammy
8. Henry
7. Fauna
6. Stitches
5. Wolfgang
4. Marina
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Zucker

10. wolfgang
9. axel
8. henry
7. chèvre
6. bonbon
5. tammy
4. stitches
3. marina
2. fauna
1. zucker

 

[Ananas Dragon]

I restarted my island so here are my new villagers please rank them!
10. Axel
9. Tammy
8. Henry
7. Fauna
6. Stitches
5. Wolfgang
4. Marina
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Zucker

1. Marina
2. Bonbon
3. Tammy
4. Axel
5. Fauna
6. Stitches
7. Wolfgang
8. Zucker
9. Chevre
10. Henry

Also rate my villagers:
Diana
Willow
Hopkins
Bob
Roald
Butch
Audie
Marshal
Marina
Reneigh

 

[WaileaNoRei]

I restarted my island so here are my new villagers please rank them!
10. Axel
9. Tammy
8. Henry
7. Fauna
6. Stitches
5. Wolfgang
4. Marina
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Zucker

1. Fauna
2. Zucker
3. Marina
4. Chevre
5. Wolfgang (his coloring is very nice)
6. Stitches
7. Bonbon
8. Tammy
9. Henry (actually so cute
10. Axel

Seems like a good group!

 

[JunoHorizon]

I restarted my island so here are my new villagers please rank them!
10. Axel
9. Tammy
8. Henry
7. Fauna
6. Stitches
5. Wolfgang
4. Marina
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Zucker

10. Zucker
9. Axel
8. Stitches
7. Henry
6. Marina
5. Tammy
4. Fauna
3. Bonbon
2. Chevre
1. Wolfgang

 

[Opal]

Here are mine atm, feel free to rate them:

- Alice
- Sally
- Zucker
- Sprinkle
- Admiral
- Genji
- Pietro
- Stella
- Marcie
- Charlise
- Raymond (Charlise is in boxes and I am about to get Raymond from someone)

Post automatically merged: Jun 28, 2020

Also rate my villagers:
Diana
Willow
Hopkins
Bob
Roald
Butch
Audie
Marshal
Marina
Reneigh

1) Marshal
2) Marina
3) Diana
4) Audie
5) Willow
6) Bob
7) Hopkins
8) Reneigh
9) Butch
10) Roald

 

[Xara]

Also rate my villagers:
Diana
Willow
Hopkins
Bob
Roald
Butch
Audie
Marshal
Marina
Reneigh

10. reneigh
9. butch
8. hopkins
7. willow
6. bob
5. marshal
4. roald
3. marina
2. diana
1. audie

 

[WaileaNoRei]

1. Marina
2. Bonbon
3. Tammy
4. Axel
5. Fauna
6. Stitches
7. Wolfgang
8. Zucker
9. Chevre
10. Henry

Also rate my villagers:
Diana
Willow
Hopkins
Bob
Roald
Butch
Audie
Marshal
Marina
Reneigh

1.Willow
2. Marina
3. Roald
4. Hopkins
5. Marshal
6. Bob
7. Diana
8. Audie
9. Butch
10. Reneigh

the middle group (3-7) is very close and honestly I could probably keep changing it forever.

 

[SpaceTokki77]

Rating my villagers:
1) Raymond
2) Judy
3) Marshal
4) Coco
5) Ankha
6) Marina
7)Zucker
8) Dotty
9) Octavian
10) Erik