Mafia Themeless Mafia-Mafia Win!

[Nightmares]

I'm voting Bowie for now, but nearer the time I might remove it if I change my mind
His reasoning to vote me and weird explanation is just kinda dogdy
...lmao

Bowie said that he was sus of me, but when asked why, he just said:
"Nobody really strikes me yet. The reason I said I'd vote for Nightmares is under the condition nobody else posts anything significant"

Like, if I don't strike you as scum or whatever, then why are you voting me and not like....Luca or something, idk haha

It's like you bandwaggoned, but now you have to stick with, even if you can't come up with a legit reason
I feel like the "nothing strikes me yet" and **** is you trying to defend yourself-- bUT!! You could totally be town and I'm wrong idk...maybe I'm looking into your posts too much? Or not enough? I'm bad, sorry shshsh kms
how do i mafia

 

[toadsworthy]

I'm voting for Tensu.... I can't justify voting Bowie or nightmares based on what I've seen. Tensu just does not convince me.... if you ask me for more in depth reasoning go back and look at my long post. I am helping people and working on a Graduation night so it's going to be busy. Apologies if you are town, but I'm going with my instincts

 

[moonford]

Either Bowie is a really snervous scum.

Or a snervous (scared and nervous) noob townie.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Wait why are two people against Tensu, I'm not following?

The contradictions he made or what?

 

[xCleb]

So I've read that Bowie has very little Mafia experience, is that correct? If so, I can understand the hesitancy to really put pressure on anybody; it's very nerve wracking to have to come up with all of these points to appease everybody, while at the same time preventing suspicion on yourself. This goes for any alignment, since nobody wants to get lynched in the game. I don't really see this as a scum-tell as much as I see it as a noob-tell.

Of course, if Bowie DOES have Mafia experience that I am unaware of, this is CERTAINLY a scum-tell, since no experienced player would be hesitant to look deeper into people's posts to try and find something that can help the Town.

~~~

Regarding Tensu's response to my post about them on Page 18, I can understand this, especially looking at both posts together. There's nothing more in which I would like to press on this issue.

~~~

Moving onto Nightmares now...I don't think there's anything to pursue with this "joke" right now, but if it turns out that either him or Zendel flips scum, we should consider taking a serious look at the other, mainly because of this "joke." Right now I just see it as a pretty careless move which they didn't really see any repercussions to at the time.


Based on all the information we have, and the main people that we're looking at to lynch, I don't think that lynching either Bowie or Nightmares would be a good choice. I don't think there's enough to go off of on either of these two in order to make a more educated decision. Granted, if it comes out that Bowie has more Mafia experience than I know, I won't hesitate to vote for Bowie. Otherwise, I'm going to end up casting a NL vote by the end of the Day.

 

[Jacob]

Jacob



this post screams "gimme some brownie points"

everyone else is mostly null to town leaning

- - - Post Merge - - -



ah, sorry

I'm just being a try hard

 

[xCleb]

Oh, and to the person that said I was barely around Today...I don't normally make dozens of posts per Day unless there's something really big going down at the time. I normally like to make my posts a bit longer and more thought out, so I know exactly what my options are going forward. It's nothing to get too mad about with me; this is probably how I'll normally play throughout the game, assuming I live long enough for it to show.

 

[toadsworthy]

I posted my reasoning on Tensu and am gonna be limited on posting for the rest of the day

 

[Nightmares]

I'm honestly not agreeing with the Tensu thing
If I flip scum, then he's gonna be in deep **** thanks to defending me earlier in the game

 

[moonford]

So I've read that Bowie has very little Mafia experience, is that correct? If so, I can understand the hesitancy to really put pressure on anybody; it's very nerve wracking to have to come up with all of these points to appease everybody, while at the same time preventing suspicion on yourself. This goes for any alignment, since nobody wants to get lynched in the game. I don't really see this as a scum-tell as much as I see it as a noob-tell.

Of course, if Bowie DOES have Mafia experience that I am unaware of, this is CERTAINLY a scum-tell, since no experienced player would be hesitant to look deeper into people's posts to try and find something that can help the Town.

~~~

Regarding Tensu's response to my post about them on Page 18, I can understand this, especially looking at both posts together. There's nothing more in which I would like to press on this issue.

~~~

Moving onto Nightmares now...I don't think there's anything to pursue with this "joke" right now, but if it turns out that either him or Zendel flips scum, we should consider taking a serious look at the other, mainly because of this "joke." Right now I just see it as a pretty careless move which they didn't really see any repercussions to at the time.


Based on all the information we have, and the main people that we're looking at to lynch, I don't think that lynching either Bowie or Nightmares would be a good choice. I don't think there's enough to go off of on either of these two in order to make a more educated decision. Granted, if it comes out that Bowie has more Mafia experience than I know, I won't hesitate to vote for Bowie. Otherwise, I'm going to end up casting a NL vote by the end of the Day.

Actually that joke wasn't made by me it was Nightmares and Nightmares alone. Yes it was pretty careless and she definitely didn't think it through.

You don't honestly think Nightmares would've been stupid enough to giveaway her alignment do you?

 

[Bowie]

I regret proclaiming my trail of thoughts too much. A lot of misinterpretation is going on, in my eyes.

Thoughts are the same.

 

[moonford]

I'm honestly not agreeing with the Tensu thing
If I flip scum, then he's gonna be in deep **** thanks to defending me earlier in the game

"If I flip scum".

Hmmmmm.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm going to post some reads soon.

 

[N e s s]

Lucanosa feels a bit scummy.

what

is it just me or does this post sound kinda... off? Everyone else answered, even if it was vague. Not trying to push you to answer, just wondering why 3, 4, and 5 were "too specific."

This post reflects what most people were thinking in the thread at the time, but I sense that his voice of reasoning is not genuine and more oportunistic. It sounds contrived with the "sounds kinda....off?" part of the post.

He only has one other post pertaining to people he thinks is suspicious, which he says that he'll go into further detail in his upcoming reads post. I'll be looking forward to seeing what his reads are.

 

[Nightmares]

I don't see how Luca can be scum when he posted like once

Come online gdi

 

[N e s s]

I don't see how Luca can be scum when he posted like once

Come online gdi

Posting once =/= Having a reason for suspicion. Just because someone has posted less than someone else doesn't give said person impunity.

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Nightmares

Like, if I don't strike you as scum or whatever, then why are you voting me and not like....Luca or something, idk haha

???

 

[Tensu]

Can someone tell me how my slip up using the wrong word makes me sus as scum? I'd especially like to get an answer from glow and why this caused her to vote me.

I'm gonna repeat this. I honestly don't see the connection.

 

[Bowie]

I'm a little creeped out by Nightmares voting for me, so I'm gonna just go ahead and vote now in case I forget.

My reasoning remains the same. The only person who remotely strikes me as suspicious, and I don't wanna take any risks by voting for someone otherwise random, and I don't think no lynch is a good idea at this point.

 

[xCleb]

Actually that joke wasn't made by me it was Nightmares and Nightmares alone. Yes it was pretty careless and she definitely didn't think it through.

You don't honestly think Nightmares would've been stupid enough to giveaway her alignment do you?

Of course now. All I'm saying is that we should take a look at your posts if Nightmares does in fact flip scum. It's all WIFOM this early in the game, but I think it's something that hold some merit going forward.

 

[toadsworthy]

I'm gonna repeat this. I honestly don't see the connection.

For me, I'm looking at you, zendel, primarina, and nightmares in the same boat as like experience (yes you have your own styles and stuff). Primarina and Nightmares are coming across as more obvious town, while Zendel has a lot more effort and helpfulness put behind their posts. Yours on the other hand... they mix between being half putting in effort, but still feel like you don't want to put too much effort in because you want to draw attention, and very defensive. I don't like the feel of it, nothing has convinced me otherwise yet, so I'm going with my instincts.

 

[glow]

I'm gonna repeat this. I honestly don't see the connection.

but even if you meant to say "let's not dismiss him, let's wait for him to answer and keep our eyes peeled"

how is that any better. you say that you weren't defending him but i don't believe you, i feel like you're just backtracking now

but even if that WAS your intention with that sentence, i don't see it as any better. it just looks like an attempt to throw words out there, words that really don't have any meaning or pursue any reads. i don't really see any motivation behind it.

 

[moonford]

Of course now. All I'm saying is that we should take a look at your posts if Nightmares does in fact flip scum. It's all WIFOM this early in the game, but I think it's something that hold some merit going forward.

Ah right okay.