I fell into the Raymond hype and went on the hunt for him as a "permanent" villager in my line-up; when I finally got him I was excited and told all my friends and had him for a really long time actually!
But once that star-struck effect wore off, and I had gotten to know the villager pool better and what I liked/was looking for in a villager, I found that he was just "meh" for me
The cat villagers are just okay to me, so him being a cat wasn't doing anything for me, the "hipster" look I don't find all that charming, and smug's aren't at the top of my favorite personality list
Another thing that really bothered me was, of everyone I had, he was the one villager that wasn't there based solely on *my* choice, it was the hype influencing my choices; because of that I decided that he didn't fit my island and let him go for free
Replaced him with someone that I feel fits much better cause I want them there (O'Hare), and I feel my island "ecosystem" is in balance again lol
But once that star-struck effect wore off, and I had gotten to know the villager pool better and what I liked/was looking for in a villager, I found that he was just "meh" for me

Another thing that really bothered me was, of everyone I had, he was the one villager that wasn't there based solely on *my* choice, it was the hype influencing my choices; because of that I decided that he didn't fit my island and let him go for free

Replaced him with someone that I feel fits much better cause I want them there (O'Hare), and I feel my island "ecosystem" is in balance again lol