Mafia [UNOFFICIAL] Seven Deadly Sins Mafia

[Blu Rose]

That's very possible, and if I were an SK that's exactly what I'd do.

However, Town!me would also play in exactly the same manner. Your point?

I think he's just bringing it up as a possibility. It's not like you're cleared because you're acting as you would if you were Town because, as Trundle has said, you'd act like a pro-active town member anyways...

How many people actually sent in the signup PM? I know I didn't...

 

[Endless]

Pretty sure he was trying to solicit a reaction from me, actually.

 

[Blu Rose]

oh, okay then endless i see how it is

Tina, in your neatly-made diagram, couldn't X/Y also be Sloth?

 

[Superpenguin]

If someone is saved by a doctor-esque role will they be informed that they were saved?

Players saved by other players for any reason will be notified.

- - - Post Merge - - -

How many people actually sent in the signup PM? I know I didn't...

Less than ten.

 

[Endless]

If anyone was saved they need to claim now. I assume they would've, but I'm just using this as a safety net

Past that, I believe we're dealing with a bunch of roleblocked sins, further incriminating truffle.

 

[pillow bunny]

Are days 24 or 48 hours?

 

[Superpenguin]

Are days 24 or 48 hours?

24 hours

 

[Endless]

24 hours

Oh ****.

 

[Chris]

oh, okay then endless i see how it is

Tina, in your neatly-made diagram, couldn't X/Y also be Sloth?

That was originally in there until I realised a flaw with it. I'm a little light-headed right now so I'll re-calculate and clarify my thought process on that shortly.

 

[Endless]

That was originally in there until I realised a flaw with it. I'm a little light-headed right now so I'll re-calculate and clarify my thought process on that shortly.

The flaw is that Isaac is completely unkillable to all sin non-gluttony effects.

Oh yeah, I was playing this day as a 48 hour day so I'm completely incorrectly paced and will likely miss on several things I'd set into motion, how horribly awkward.

 

[Blu Rose]

If anyone was saved they need to claim now. I assume they would've, but I'm just using this as a safety net

I protected Beardo.
Before you call me stupid for outing this, I believe that I was targeted by Pride last night. I believe the source that I have because s/he initiated the conversation out of the blue and then gave a perfectly plausible reason for saying that Pride targeted me. Not to mention, in past games it fit with their behavior and therefore I believed them. If you were to read back in the thread then you could probably tell whom it was just by their suggestions on what certain roles do.
Questions?

 

[Endless]

Why didn't Beardo out that they were protected?

Also you're golden if you vote Dad today, he's incredibly likely to flip sin given some stuff that's been exchanged in pm.

 

[Truffle]

Endless was probably just reaction testing me and/or seeing if anyone would bandwagon. His reasoning for the vote was BS.

Why didn't Beardo out that they were protected?

Also you're golden if you vote Dad today, he's incredibly likely to flip sin given some stuff that's been exchanged in pm.

Can you actually post this so-called evidence on the thread for the people not involved in your PM circle?

 

[Blu Rose]

Why didn't Beardo out that they were protected?

Also you're golden if you vote Dad today, he's incredibly likely to flip sin given some stuff that's been exchanged in pm.

I was given a confirmation PM that my action was taken in, but my Role PM doesn't state that anyone is notified if they are protected. I wasn't notified if my protection was successful, and I haven't asked Superpenguin what this means.
I probably should.

I guess I'll vote Dad? I mean, I guess that this is sort of a blind leap of faith or something, but I guess I'd like to see these PMs via copy+paste means to see if there is actually something there, but, because it's Endless it makes sense. In PM games, I'm not usually one to talk that much through PMs.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Can you actually post this so-called evidence on the thread for the people not involved in your PM circle?

^^^^^^^^^^^

 

[pillow bunny]

This might be a terrible idea, but I'm going to go with it anyways.

I'm a/the town Detective. Last night I investigated Dad, and he came back as Envy, a sin. The image in my PM was called Detective 2, so it's possible that there's more than one.

I contacted another person via PM yesterday, and they claimed to be the Doctor. They protected me to confirm this. This person was not Blu Rose, but I think there might be two Doctors to balance out the Sins.

 

[Endless]

Welp, the cats out of the bag now.

 

[Chris]

Feeling a little more human now.

The flaw is that Isaac is completely unkillable to all sin non-gluttony effects.

That was it, thank you!

• Karen couldn't be targetted by Sloth because she was immune to Sin kills bar Cory's.
• Cory is a little more complicated. He could have been targeted by Sloth, but only if he didn't kill Karen. Otherwise she wouldn't have died because his action would have been blocked.

This might be a terrible idea, but I'm going to go with it anyways.

I'm a/the town Detective. Last night I investigated Dad, and he came back as Envy, a sin. The image in my PM was called Detective 2, so it's possible that there's more than one.

I contacted another person via PM yesterday, and they claimed to be the Doctor. They protected me to confirm this. This person was not Blu Rose, but I think there might be two Doctors to balance out the Sins.

You should have found another angle to push him from - or had another player reveal this information without outing yourself.

Unfortunately, with Envy, we have the problem that this Sin can switch roles and it's not public the order in which actions are processed this game. I'm going to pray Superpenguin would have done this after Envy's role switch, assuming they used their action.

 

[Endless]

For reference, I consulted nick about how actions stacked and in what order they resolve and the result you get back is the one the person has at the end of the night. AKA Dad is presently Envy.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I'm going to go with Dad. Fortunately in this game we know it's very unlikely there will be a group starting an ill-intentioned bandwagon unless two or three of the sins found each other and grouped up. Therefore, pushes for certain people from multiple people are likely to be legitimate. Voting Dad for this reason + evidence.

 

[Endless]

Sins can't team up since they have no ability that lets them verify other sins.