Kyle. I couldn't understand why he we so popular until I visited a town with him in it for signatures and went 'oh NO' after I talked to him. Safe to say I picked him up from someone else a few days later.
Cyrano!! Stupid thing has grown on me. I had him in my very first town. When I decided to restart I brought my villagers to my new town (with my brothers DS) and left behind a few, including cyrano. In the end I ended up trading stitches just to get him back
I can't believe I'm saying this but for me it's Quillson. In the beginning I wanted him gone the instance I saw him (horrid colour combination + that hairdo) when he moved into my town. But after talking to him a few times I've realized that I've grown attached to him. Mainly because I did not expect him to have a smug personality based on my first impression of his appearance, so it's like this dork is trying his best to be cool which I thought was cute lmao. Plus I love his catchphrase a lot, as ridukulous as it may sound.
Katt's really weird face threw me off when she moved in. I ended up adoring her, but when she asked to move I still let her leave. I wish I hadn't though.