I'd be devastated if Snake or Pekoe would move away. Pekoe is so sweet and I've had snake in my town since the very beginning. Which would be a few years now. I also loved Cole and he moved away too when I didn't talk to him as much as I used to (I didn't have the time bb come back ;-;;; )
I think I'd be devastated if Julian, Pheobe, Lucky, or Skye every moved out. They're all dreamies of mine. Pheobe and Lucky don't even fit the theme of my town, but I'm keeping both of them because of how much I love them.. I remember once Julian tried to move out and I was actually sad even though I told him to stay and he did, lmao
SAME!! Someone else who shares my obsession... Never thought this day would come!
Pietro did move out of my first town and moved into my brothers, and I was so devastated I reset my whole town, bells and rare items and all, just to make a new one where I could get Pietro back. Worth it!
Keaton. Seriously I really like his design and he is never mean, so I always make sure I say yes to all of his requests. If he were to move out, I don't think I would play Animal Crossing for a while.
Punchy, definitely... when I lost my first town that had him in it, I cried for days D,: Thankfully I have his amiibo card now, so I'll never have to be without him again