Which Animal Crossing game would you like to see be remade?

Which one do you want to see a remake of?!


  • Total voters
    45

Mars Adept

Circles and spirals in mind…
Joined
Dec 25, 2015
Posts
5,412
Bells
248
Carnival Coins
0
Switch
8301-8235-7817
Mars Adept's Creature:
Fresh Balloon
Fresh Balloon
Rad Balloon
Rotating Fool's Egg
Oblivia's Ugly Christmas Egg
Quirky Doll
Weird Doll
Animal Crossing has been going on for over 2 decades, with mainline entries, spin-offs, updates, and more. But one thing that AC has yet to receive is a remake of a pre-existing game. Which older title would you like to see remade with modern adjustments?

I would choose City Folk. It would be exciting to see them expand the city!
 
I think Wild World and City Folk are similar enough anyway that I wouldn’t want either of those remade. New Leaf is a great game so a remake of that would be good, but I never played the original Animal Crossing on the GameCube so I’m going with that. I don’t have any way to experience it unless it gets remade
 
I never got the chance to play City Folk so I'd really like to play that one. I have Wild world but never got into it.
New leaf still feels too recent to remake.
 
I would prefer New Leaf to be remade. I even written a long blog entry (which is linked to my signature) on HD remake suggestions for New Leaf. For instance, I would do away with the terraforming and crafting, but keep the interior design improvements the series as the series went by.
 
I don't really want any of them remade. I'd rather they just move forward and make new games than revisit old games.

If I had to choose one, though, maybe City Folk? I could never really get into City Folk, despite trying, because I just didn't enjoy playing with the Wii Controller & Nunchuck and I didn't like the rolling camera perspective they had in this game. Maybe I'd like it more if those things were changed to fit whatever hypothetical console this remake would be on. I did enjoy the city part of City Folk, so yeah.

The GameCube game might be cool remade but, considering how the dialogue came about back then. I don't know that they'd necessarily stick with it in a remake? If they did then it would be a maybe. I haven't played Wild World yet so I can't speak to it much in this respect.

As for New Leaf, it's still my favorite game in the series in some regards and I don't think it really needs it. However, if they included the ability to place furniture outside and allowed you to pick your skin color, or even just one of those things, then this would be amazing actually. Either, or both, of those things would make New Leaf the definitive best Animal Crossing experience all around for me.

So yeah, either City Folk or New Leaf.
 
I’d really want to see a remake of GameCube. I’d love to see how they change it. But I feel like it would be the most controversial one to remake since there’s so much that’s unique about that game and they would probably take some of it out in favor of making it more modern and accessible. I’d still want to see how they’d go around remaking that game. But I wouldn’t be opposed to any Animal Crossing game getting remade.
 
If I had to, New Leaf, mostly because I miss everything that game had to offer. Especially Club Tortimer, that was the best!

But realistically, Animal Crossing isn't a type of game to get remakes. Every game is exactly the same, so what I think should be done instead is have the next installment have the best features that were added in every AC game to date. That way, a remake wouldn't be needed and everyone will be happy.
 
I have only ever played New Leaf and New Horizons, so I would be interested in a remake in any of the previous versions.

Especially on GameCube since I never owned one
 
But realistically, Animal Crossing isn't a type of game to get remakes. Every game is exactly the same, so what I think should be done instead is have the next installment have the best features that were added in every AC game to date. That way, a remake wouldn't be needed and everyone will be happy.
The problem is, "have the next installment have the best features that were added in every AC game to date" isn't feasible for various reasons. It isn't feasible because there comes a point where you're taking too long to develop the damn game because there's too much content in there (and it's bad for business to have a game come out too late in a console's lifespan, especially one that's been shown to consistently sell well over a console's lifespan like AC is), it isn't feasible because there isn't anything new there aside from Everything Good From Every AC Game and that's inevitably going to put some people off, and it's not feasible because however much AC fandom acts as if everything's just Content that can be moved from game to game with No Issue Whatsoever, each AC game's a carefully considered blend of parts that gets put together to form a cohesive whole, and just chucking them all into the same game because Fans Demand It isn't necessarily going to make The Best AC Game Ever... you're going to get something that doesn't feel like it fits together, in the same way putting a load of similarly-shaped pieces from different jigsaws together isn't going to make a complete picture. For crying out loud... think about why things are there! Hell, even think about what console it's released on, or even its year of release! Don't just go "put dialogue from WW together with the customisation from NH" because they clearly don't work together (one is based around you being a weird stranger in a town full of animals, the other's based around you having absolute dominion over said villagers)

With that being said, while I don't think Nintendo's going to remake or even port games (each AC game's got a decent amount of stuff that's tied to the specific console it's on that means we're inevitably going to lose a part of it in the transition to the Switch or Swuccessor) if there's one game I'd really want to see remade, it's probably GC. The big town with railway tracks at the back, the lake for events, the bits of Japanese culture like convenience store raffles, the unmistakably Peanuts-y vibe, the funky electronic soundtrack... But even then, I'd probably just want to see a new game with the same kind of vibe, because doing a straight 1-1 remake of it'd suck for various other reasons (NES games aren't ever coming back so they'd be conspicuous by their absence, the forced horrible hats, bad storage, having a basement you can't put wallpaper or flooring up in).

Feels like WW will end up on DS NSO if it ever ends up happening, LGTTC feels like it'd just get a straight-up port (a lot of the Wii-specific stuff in it is actually pretty doable on the Switch, even if the idea of a LGTTC port's kind of "eh" to me), and while I'd appreciate a NL port in some ways, until we've gotten the next AC game it's just gonna feel like grovelling to me (also it's probably the AC game with the most console-specific features in it, taking them out leaves a massive gaping hole in the game)
 
Given that Population Growing is the oldest game in the series, the timing feels right for a remake. It would be awesome to have all of the removed villagers and the newer villagers introduced in 2021 meet together in the same game.
 
My vote would have gone to the GC version, but honestly I don't think Nintendo could do that game any justice. With the game currently being decompiled, with an HD texture pack being made with daily updates, on top of modders' intentions to port over all of the Japan-exclusive content from DnMe+ in addition to brand-new quality of life improvements and tweaks, I don't think I'd care much if Nintendo actually remastered that game because what the community is doing is so much cooler.

I don't think we'll ever see remastered/remade AC games, but I think it would be cool to have a WW+CF remake. Combine the best parts of Wild World with the best parts of City Folk to make a fully complete experience since CF is just WW2.0. The villager dialog and interactions from WW, with an expanded city and holidays from CF... that'd be pretty awesome.
 
I would love to see the original Animal Crossing from the GameCube remade because I never got the chance to play it when it first came out. I've heard so many stories from longtime fans about how special that game was. I feel like I missed out on experiencing the roots of what makes Animal Crossing so beloved.
 
I would actually like to have any of the other 3 remade that isn’t New Leaf, since I don’t have the consoles to play the rest of them. I would love any opportunity to play more Animal Crossing! 😁
 
As much as a Gamecube version remake would be nostalgia for me, I don't really see how they would do it as this is a type of series that doesn't lend itself well to remakes. What would a GCN version remake even look like? I assume they'd keep the same artstyle and over-head view, but remade in a much more crisp, HD style like NH. But where do they go beyond that? Do they allow accessories and all of the other customization added in later AC games? Doing that might change the feel of the game, but not having that feature in an AC game released post WW would feel wrong... Things like that make a remake tough.
 
Honestly, none of them. Even though I can understand why people would want some of the older games remade, the idea of any AC game being remade isn't that appealing to me. I'd rather they just make a new one and make it as good as it possibly can be, lol.
 
While I don't believe remakes are entirely necessary, I would appreciate the opportunity to revisit the original Animal Crossing and New Leaf from a more modern perspective - just imagining those games with updated models and textures would be interesting. Mainly out of curiosity but having experienced New Horizons, and how gosh darn pretty that game is, I sometimes find myself wondering when revisiting New Leaf, what those earlier games might look like with enhancements. However, despite that curiosity, I don’t think remakes are essential.
 
While I voted for new leaf, I'd rather they just work on a new game rather than do remakes. I would like it if they added the great parts from past games and added them to the new game, ie villager personalities, games with villagers, mini games, dialog, the city, Gracie grace, crafting (with some tweaks like bulk crafting, otherwise I enjoyed the feature)
 
If I had to pick one, it would be the GameCube version, it’s the only one I’ve never played and I’d say it’s the most different of the series, so that would be interesting to see how they would update it. I’ll echo the sentiments of others in this thread though that I don’t see it happening any time soon (nor do I think we really need remakes for animal crossing) and think new entries will always be the way to go!
 
Back
Top