I am... not an elephant person (at least not in AC). But Tia gets my pick for best lady (love the teapot theme) and Tucker gets my pick for best boy because mammoths are fantastic.
I’ve had Cyd and Eloise and I liked neither of them. I’m not a big fan of the elephant villagers but Tia and Margie grew on me quite a bit thanks to @Xara; I’m also starting to like Dizzy a little too, I think .