Trading Who would you trade for Shep?

[Leebles]

I recently lost both my Uchi and Lazy villagers because of sloppy time travelling. I started to cycle my campsite in a smarter way and found Shep. I could ask him to move in and try and move him out, but I would only do that if I knew I would get a great Uchi or Lazy out of it. With that in mind, would anyone be willing to trade any of these villagers for Shep?

Beau
Cole
Erik
Lucky
or, to break up the sausage fest, Renee or Muffy?

 

[Leebles]

Alright I went ahead and reset.