If possible I'd like to get the map I want, and even one villager I want.
I plan to amiibo in who I want eventually, so if I find a fantastic map, I'd probably settle down there no matter who is there.
I wouldn't bother resetting for villagers (it's not like they're permanent) but I might for a good town map. My original NL town's layout was so much of a pain that I sold it despite all the effort spent on it. I don't want to make that mistake again!