Would you rather have the city or Main Street?

[nintendofan85]

Would you rather have the city return from City Folk/Let's Go to the City or Main Street from New Leaf?

 

[UglyMonsterFace]

I like Main Street because it's so convenient. I haven't played any other AC game so I guess I can't really compare fairly, but the idea of having to pay every time you go to the city doesn't sound great at all. And (im assuming) having to go through repetitive dialogue every time will take away from my enjoyment.

 

[MapleSilver]

I prefer Main Street because it feels more like part of your town. Also I like the fact that it becomes nicer over time, compared to the relatively stagnant nature of the City. I did really enjoy the City's aesthetic though. Perhaps if they allowed for greater Main Street customization this game, the player could make it resemble the City more. Then we could have the strengths of both areas at once.

 

[Stevey Queen]

I'd rather have something new but something like main st. The city was inconvenient to go to with 2 loading screens and a bus scene.

 

[slatka]

I'd rather have something new but something like main st. The city was inconvenient to go to with 2 loading screens and a bus scene.

i agree with this i really want something new but to have the main st feel

 

[Lucas4080]

I personally wouldn't mind, but I feel like a City would be my pick. Main because I want stores like Nook's and Able Sisters to be in Town and the higher end stores to be in a whole new area with a completely different vibe. I just loved the city in LGTTC okay-

 

[Sweetley]

While I don't mind the Main Street from New Leaf, I actually would like it more to have
the City back. I like the idea of the City, even though they could have made more of it
back then in City Folk, as it was a small city with not so much to discover. If they would
make a big city with lots of shops and more to discover, then I would really like it.

Otherwise, they could also bring back the Main Street, but also maybe in a new look and
more shops and things to do.

 

[LambdaDelta]

the city suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuucked

 

[Coach]

I personally think that Main Street is way better if not only due to the convenience. However, in the new title since streetpass won't be around to distribute baloons and pinwheels, I would really like to see Phineas' stand back to buy from on occasion.

 

[Dacroze]

I liked the music and atmosphere from the city more, but I'd value the convenience of the main street more, if I'd had to decide between the two.

 

[Paperboy012305]

I’d rather have something new. Like for instance a pier at the beach with shops and such.

 

[Lancelot]

Main street, but maybe layered like in HHD and more modern so it's a nice contrast to the town.

Basically main street but more innovative

 

[bl00dyroar]

Main street, but maybe layered like in HHD and more modern so it's a nice contrast to the town.

i love that idea <3
honestly, what i really want is to give the able sisters the upgrade they deserve! their store has always looked the same

 

[Warrior]

Neither, I'd rather have the stores in our town itself and have the opportunity to move them around, new stores having to let you pick their location. I'd also like if we could theme the stores appearance too. Let's say your town is more wooded, the outside of nooks would look more like a large forest mansion, but if you want a more modern look you can pick that too.

I just feel like having to go all the way north for something annoying, and being able to put the shops in a location that makes sense for your gameplay makes sense. Like if you sell a lot of fish, maybe you'd want retail near the sea, or if you trade a lot with other players, near the station is better. I think at the same time having unlimited control to take away from the spirit of the game, so I think to get permission to move the stores from their start location, it would have to take a LOT of work. Not just bells, but having to befriend the animal running the store, and this would be more involved that just listening to them daily like with Sable.

 

[Raienryu]

I’d rather have something new. Like for instance a pier at the beach with shops and such.

I like this idea^

Could go well with a contrast, maybe when moving to your town you're asked if it's one with the beach pier shops or something more similar (yet, different) to that of the main street

 

[Snowesque]

I have always really preferred the Main Street; the City just felt really disconnected and away from everything.

 

[Lucas4080]

I’d rather have something new. Like for instance a pier at the beach with shops and such.

Ooo, I love that idea! Especially since I'm hoping the game has more to add for the beach and I'm planning to name my town Lucoast it would be a nice fit!

 

[carackobama]

I’d rather both honestly! I would like to have the more local stores on Main Street but also have a much improved version of the city for places like Gracie’s and Club LOL and maybe some new types of buildings. I really like Paperboy’s pier idea too!

 

[Blue Cup]

A bigger main street is all that's needed.

 

[Ossiran]

I'd prefer something new, to be honest, but given the choice, Main Street. I'm fine with something like a city, but it should be its own thing with completely different shops. Maybe a place you can meet up with people online and hosting online events or shops that refresh much less frequently to eliminate the necessity of going there so often.