Well, first off I guess I?ll just apologize for sucking this game, and basically all of my recent games for the past while. I don?t know why but when I sign up for Mafia I generally think I?m going to clean up my play and take things seriously but it never happens. I don?t know if I?m just lazy or tired or missing old players, but these aren?t good excuses anyway, and I?m going to try my best to be useful in these games instead of letting my team down every time.
I?ve taken the time to post my thoughts on everyone in the game.
PandaDarling:
Panda has posted a lot and I don?t really want to go through all of her posts, because it hasn?t been anything huge, but her play this game reminds me of her town play in the other games I?ve been in with her. I?m quite convinced by how she?s posting that she is Town aligned. This is due to the style, which is quick short posts and constantly putting a bit of pressure on different people. She is generally someone who you think might be coasting, but realistically is an asset to Town because of her questions, pressure, etc. Another tell that reminds me of past games is her seemingly angry posts that occur because she legitimately wants to see Town win, so she thinks stupid crap is really frustrating and annoying. I?m 99% sure that Panda is Town (none of this was meant to be an insult).
mother of all llamas:
I am going to vote Area based on his scummy behaviour. I have read back and his posts just stick out to me. His RQS he seemed very over confident and I feel like it was more forced. Also to backup would be his backlash on Crys so quickly... Unless something comes up I'll be placing my vote on him
mother of all llamas has been afk this game. This is the only post they?ve made so it isn?t much to go off of. I think it?s most likely just inactive green.
Dolby:
I found a quote that I found quite interesting.
Entropy or Ashtot
Entropy stole M3ow's skin. But in all seriousness her behavior is not normal for her. I don't like the continuous excuses that she's made in avoiding putting effort in
Because you hadn't done anything
People have posted their suspicions and your using the ****posting that was at the start of the day as an excuse for half of our dozen or so posts which are ****posts and noncontributivness. Moreover, I don't like the implied OMGUS with this. The only useful thing that you've done is point out ashtot's pocket on Trundle. Speaking of Ashtot...
I don't like Ashtot's instant townread on Trundle. Moreover, this comment right here rubs me the wrong way
I don't like how Nightmares disappeared after a few minutes wondering if day had started yet.
Anyone else consider this ironic given his revenge vote? Just checked the post links and this is his only post in the game
I find it interesting that Dolby was also pushing for Entropy. This is odd because Dolby is known for being someone who can easily find blue roles in a game, and with someone as forward and active as Entropy, I would think it would be easy for him to find out. In this context, It seems like Dolby is just off his game, but he could potentially have been going after an Entropy lynch because he knew that she was blue. Dolby hasn?t said much this game, but this post seems scummy to me, and I still think Dolby is most likely scum.
Alexi:
I don?t really understand Alexi because she has done things that seem very Town but also done things that seem kind of scummy. Overall, they've been posting a lot of their reads and trying to push the game forward, rather than stopping it, which is definitely Town play. I'm leaning towards her being Town but I'm not sure.
Taesaek:
Honestly the only thing that I find is weird with Tae is how defensive they are when it comes to certain players in the game. I?m not sure if it?s worth looking into or if they?re just friends, but I?m not sure it really matters because I doubt they would defend someone blindly without considering them for scum. So far I?ve read them as Town this game. They?ve been very aggressive, seemingly ticked off, and constantly pushing in order to get answers, which is good pro-Town behaviour, except maybe with a bit less hostility, but it?s understandable. I?m about 85% sure that Taesaek is Town.
Inkling:
Inkling made a couple posts but then randomly popped in last night and starting saying a bunch of random stuff. Most of it I didn?t understand, but it seemed that they were extremely emotional and it probably affected their playing. They focused on Panda and Myself and thought that Panda was scum because she was seemingly less aggressive than her typical Town play, which I disagree with. I think it's possible that they're scum, but I'm not sure at this point.
Jacob:
Jacob hasn?t posted that much in the last day, but his posts throw me off because the wording is just weird (not in a bad way, I?m just not used to it). He?s made a lot of posts that make it seem like he?s trying to go through the game with minimal effort and give blanket statements that seem helpful to Town. I lean toward him being third party or scum.
Tom:
I?ve said a lot about Tom this game, and I think everyone knows my stance on him, but to repeat it, I believe he is playing very pro-Town, and while he claims he is third party, he is an asset to Town at this point in the game. My preference is to let him be an asset and stop bothering him for now, but I can see why others would rather have him killed, because there is a chance he is still third party or scum.
Nightmares:
I don?t really have anything to say on them. They?ve only posted a little and most of their posts are trollish or irrelevant. I think they?re most likely inactive green.
Tina:
Tina is quite interesting because, in my experience, when Tina is Town, she is very, very Town. In all of my games with Tina, she went completely hardcore when Town aligned and makes lots of giant posts, and makes it very obvious that she is Town. In this game, Tina doesn?t seem to care much, which is typical for her as third party or scum. I haven?t played with Tina that recently, but if her play is still similar to old times, I believe without a doubt that Tina is third party or scum. I?ve heard her make excuses of being busy before to counter arguments like this, but it?s always an excuse and never a reality because if she is Town she cares too much not to try.
Ares:
Ares has been afk, but they?ve apparently come back so hopefully they?ll be more active. This is the only quote of any significance that I found.
Lol you're gonna seriously regret lynching me
It?s a huge stretch but it?s possible that they were soft claiming a jester type role.
Hayden:
I honestly don?t know, they haven?t posted much, and from what I know of them outside Mafia (they sent me a flower calling me a lovely lady), they?re just as unpredictable as in Mafia.
Cory:
Cory is a weird dude, but he?s been actually trying this game. Some of his posts seem really sloppy but I think it?s because he?s on mobile. Cory used to be similar to my level of quality in this game but he?s stepped up a lot and he?s behaving very pro-Town this game. He hasn?t been inconsistent. I?m 85% sure he is Town.
Xine:
I don?t think I?ve ever played with Xine, but they seem extremely competent, as well as aggressive. So far they?ve grilled people, including myself, posted thoughtful reads, and asked questions. I think they?re most likely Town, but something about them makes me think of past players who were really great at being Town even if they were actually scum.
Tardis2016:
They've mostly been repeating what others say and just coasting off of following the leader. I don?t have a read on them.
Sorry I haven't been talking. I don't really like night talk that much. And don't want the mafia to get me.
This is the only thing I think is really weird, but it makes me think they?re just noob Town rather than Mafia.
Xerolin:
They haven?t really done anything other than defend a couple afk players and say that they are going to post reads or make a case on people but never follow through. They?re playing like scum but I don?t know if it?s that or just not interested in the game.
Caddberry:
I think they?re new, but I?m not really sure. Regardless, they seem like they?re actually trying and they?ve been playing decently pro-Town, though not putting that much effort in. They even made sure to think through things and not simply be a sheep. I think Caddberry is Town.
