Mafia Xenoblade Chronicles Mafia-Endgame

[Cory]

If you know what I am, what am I? OuO

...
I don't want to say

 

[mother of all llamas]

...
I don't want to say

So should I say it or not? You wanted everyone to claim and I don't know whether to or not because that is super scummy...

 

[Cory]

So should I say it or not? You wanted everyone to claim and I don't know whether to or not because that is super scummy...

are you dunban?

 

[Kirbystarship]

Why are we claiming

Here comes the mother of all coasters.

 

[mother of all llamas]

No I am not Dunban

 

[Cory]

No I am not Dunban

oh ok
claim then

 

[mother of all llamas]

Why do we need to claim? Can we have at least some reason? I don't trust you at all, I don't trust anyone at this point except for a select few. I'm not going to claim unless it's under circumstances, I don't want town to be at fault because everyone outed

 

[Cory]

Why do we need to claim? Can we have at least some reason? I don't trust you at all, I don't trust anyone at this point except for a select few. I'm not going to claim unless it's under circumstances, I don't want town to be at fault because everyone outed

you're either scum or blue

 

[mother of all llamas]

you're either scum or blue

If I was blue you would be very scummy or a bad townsperson for pointing it out, but luckily I'm not. I am Talia the Townie

 

[Cory]

I have a possible theory.
But it need to wait.

 

[mother of all llamas]

I claimed townie and you are voting me? Cory is bad townsperson or scum guys...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Can you tell me why I'm being voted?

 

[Cory]

I claimed townie and you are voting me? Cory is bad townsperson or scum guys...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Can you tell me why I'm being voted?

no need to get defensive after 1 vote

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's a possible part of my theory

 

[Kirbystarship]

I claimed townie and you are voting me? Cory is bad townsperson or scum guys...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Can you tell me why I'm being voted?

The vote is just a reaction test

 

[PandaDarling]

Llama your scum again ? lol

 

[Cadbberry]

You know what?
Everyone state their role name.

- - - Post Merge - - -

post glitch

I hope I can trust you and this gets us somewhere , I am Rozeal

 

[Jacob]

Sorry for being quiet all day, haven't had enough free time to read the thread until now

You know what?
Everyone state their role name.

- - - Post Merge - - -

post glitch

I'm Vangarre

 

[xine]

Hey Xine could we get updated reads? It seems your opinion has changed on a few users and well with a few dead now, some updated reads from you would be really helpful.

Do not act like you need to prod me.

I have a large analysis about half written up. When I post it, it will be shortly before night ends. We lynch Dolby. Do not assume this means that I believe Ashtot. Here is another case on Dolby if any of you are hesitant. Or you can TL;DR and look at the fact that he was pardoned from being modkilled, for missing votes two days in a row, and the fact that he avoids this thread more than I avoid my high school exes.

I'm a bus driver

Spoiler: you Kolechian scum

What the **** did you say about me, you Kolechian scum? I'll have you know I graduated top of my class in the Ministry of Admission, and I've been involved in numerous secret raids on EZIC and Kolechia. I am trained in Stamp Warfare and I'm the top inspector in Ministry of Admission. I'll have you know that I have over 300 confirmed denials. You are nothing to me but just another target. I will deny you with the precision the likes of which have never been seen on earth. As we speak, I am contacting my spy network across Arstotzka, so you better prepare for a storm. I can be anywhere, everywhere, and I can deny you in over 700 different ways, and that's just with my stamps. Not only an I extensively trained at detainment, but I have access to the entire arsenal of the Ministry of Admission, and I will use it to it's full extent to deny and detain you out of Arstotzka, you Kolechian scum

Glory to Arstotzka

****post filler. Joking around is actually no reason to suspect someone, but just wait. This is important, I promise you.

What time Zone are you in?PST, west coast best coast
How many games have you played? 44
How do you react under pressure? Calmly
What role do you want to be?I prefer being mafia
What will you be notable for?Hunting down Kolechian EZIC scum
Pronouns. He

I am gracefully acknowledging the fact that Dolby has played 44 games and therefor he has the CAPABILITY of playing at least a little, I mean with this amount of experienced you should be able to half-ass a game and manage to get by. But you are not even trying. Nearly 20 of your posts are pre-game posts.

When you were town in Tarot Mafia you had more posts in a game that lasted six days total than this game, where we are very quickly approaching MYLO. If we subtract your posts made pre game you have made 26 posts. You made over TWICE that amount in Tarot. And I am being super generous here and counting your ****posts as posts.

Here?s an example of Town Dolby?s read posts.

Why I think that Inkling is scum​

Inkling is for more aggressive in this game than in newbie mafia 5, where he was a one-shot bulletproof, meaning that he had night immunity. I believe that this change in behavior comes from him having a different alignment, specifically scum, as he feels more motivated to help his scum team. He's made more posts by now than in the entirity of his most recent game

What tipped me off to compare inkling's meta to this game was this:



This is very hypocritical, moreover, why are there so many people that you are townreading? At this point, something like 40% of the playerlist has only had one or two posts checking in. There are many of us who pointed out Cry's odd behaviour


...
Hypocritical much?

...
There are like, at least 7 people more quiet than Cory



Still Waiting for this


Wtf man, you are giving absolutely no reasoning

...

Why haven't you made a case? All that you said was that Cory was opportunistic regarding Crys


Moreover, Inkling is far more willing to post, like I said earlier, than last game when he was town-aligned and had night immunity. I think that he is trying to derail the thread so that suspicions work with the scum agenda. Let's see some of his posts from last game



Oh the irony


This is a large behavior change from his behaviour as town, another reason why I suspect him.

There are about 15 quotes in there. Each of these conclusions are logical and reasonably drawn, although Inkling was town that game, his argument was still valid.

And here is Scum Dolby.

Entropy or Ashtot

Entropy stole M3ow's skin. But in all seriousness her behavior is not normal for her. I don't like the continuous excuses that she's made in avoiding putting effort in

Because you hadn't done anything


People have posted their suspicions and your using the ****posting that was at the start of the day as an excuse for half of our dozen or so posts which are ****posts and noncontributivness. Moreover, I don't like the implied OMGUS with this. The only useful thing that you've done is point out ashtot's pocket on Trundle. Speaking of Ashtot...

I don't like Ashtot's instant townread on Trundle. Moreover, this comment right here rubs me the wrong way

{insert Ashtot?s pocket of Trundle here}

I don't like how Nightmares disappeared after a few minutes wondering if day had started yet.

Anyone else consider this ironic given his revenge vote? Just checked the post links and this is his only post in the game

Entropy never excused herself for not putting in effort. Entropy defended herself for not posting the most seriously because everyone was acting the same way. Including yourself, Dolby. So you had NO room to talk about ?not doing anything?. Especially because you still have done nothing at this point in the game.

In the next paragraph Dolby incorrectly tries to draw the conclusion that OMGUS is inherently scummy: I have seen scum use this tactic FAR too many times to try to call someone that is town scummy. OMGUS is only suspicious when there are not substantial reasons why. Entropy had more reasoning to suspect Tom than vice versa, because Tom's reasoning for suspecting Entropy contradicted himself.

Does that make sense? You all know why, right? Because anyone pushing on someone for illogical reasons IS scummy.

Further, Dolby acknowledged the fact that Entropy HAS contributed and continued to contradicted himself there. Ashtot's pocket of Trundle was strange and you continued to add that into your following paragraph as if you had some sort of revelation.

The only part where you are not an easy read is your interactions with Ashtot. Both of you have been pushing each other since Day 1. So do tell me Dolby, what is your opinion of Ashtot now?

Panda-Null, I have no opinion towards them
Llamas-Null
Alexi-Town lean. I like their participation
AshTot- I can never tell, but I'm leaning scum
Taesaek-Null
Inkling-The post advocating for a lynch on Tom, then immediately backing off, is the scumiest thing that I've ever seen
Jacob-Fitting their town meta well
Tom-Not fitting town or scum metas, so I'm inclined to believe him
Nightmares-Scum lean.
Ares- I very much doubt that a new mafia player would vote for another mafia member day one
Hayden-Can't place them
Tina-Idk
Cory-Townlean
Xine-Town Lean
Tardis-Fitting town meta
Xerolin-Null
Caddberry-I don't like the way that she's piggybacking onto everyone's opinion

Sorry about how messy this is. I pretty much gave up trying to format things with colors because autocorrect wouldn't let me leave it alone

These were the reads we were all waiting for, aren?t they super gr8 and super in depth? I took the liberty of color-coordinating this. Notice how they almost are all town or null, as like every other lazy scum ever that wants to fence sit without taking a clear stance.

I asked Dolby to expand on this, and it took over a day for Dolby to finally come up with semi-detailed reads. It is painfully obvious that he had to force himself to write them, while being prodded multiple times, when he should be highly motivated on his own to post reads. He posted several times in-between these reads and the following ones, so it is not like he was too busy to do so earlier.

I definetely support an Ash shot if there is a vig. If he's scum, he'll die, if he's town, he's honestly no value to us anyway besides keeping our numbers up. Moreover, I do not like that his last post was early yesterday after being so explosive on Day One. I think that he is trying to avoid bringing more attention to himself.

WHY ARE YOU ACTING LIKE WE WEREN?T APPROACHING MYLO WITH TWO MODKILLS IMPENDING

Just noticed that this opened.

PandaDarling-Seems like town Panda to me
MOAL- Moal seems to be hopping on the wagon that has the most strength and supporters. Sadly I've seen this behavior by them done quite a few times in recent games. The few posts that they have are explaining their bandwagon votes. I feel like their just going to continue this
Alexi-I had them down as a town lean earlier and the fact that Taesaek says that they returned town reinforces it. They are being helpful and contribuative. The only reason that I'm leaving them as a townlean is because her scum and town metas are similar and there is still the possibility of her being godfather.
Ashtot- The topic of Ashtot has been covered so many times that it is no use for me to say anything more about it.
Taesaek-No explanation needed here. Their claim makes no sense from a scum perspective as well at this point in the game
Jacob ScumJacob prefers to sit back and do only the minimum required for him. Jacob is being more confrontative than he would be as scum, so I'm town leaning him.
Tom- I am confident that Tom is, for once, telling (at least part of) the truth, because his claim makes no sense from a scum perspective, but also because his play this game doesn't match his town or scum meta. Yellow is for third party
Nightmares- Honestly, I just don't have any thoughts on their involvement in the game
Ares- I don't think that noob scum would vote for a teammate on Day One, or that Crys would act towards a new scum teammate. I think that they are noob town.
Hayden-They aren't contributing to thread discussion in any useful way
Cory-Just don't know what to think about him
Xine- I think that they are town, but I've never seen them as scum.
Tardis2016-Acting similar to Trump mafia, rather than their silence in Tarot
Caddberry- Simply put, I don't like how they piggyback off of every opinion expressed in the thread

Not doing reads on those seeking replacements, and I'm going to grab a quick siesta.

These reads are not entirely bad, but extremely weak compared to your opinions in Tarot mafia. You were quite confident in your reads in that game, and aggressive with your suspicions, and in this game you are just drifting without actually pressing on anyone that you think is scum. Your tone is drastically different.

The reads that I do have a problem with are these:

MOAL- So you have seen Mother of all Llamas do this as scum and town or only scum?? I do not understand this. They are highly notorious for coasting, and coasted the exact same way in Trump mafia. I do not understand why you are being so vague about it when you were the one that hosted the game.
Jacob - Has HARDLY been contributing substantially, so your townread on him makes no sense. He was only confrontational to one person- and the second that Taesaek told him to stop tunneling then he backed off. Since then we have heard basically nothing, although he is posting elsewhere.

And especially this: Why did you leave out Tina?

What is a strongman?

Hello everyone, welcome to Xine's scumtell class. This here is called a dumbtell. It is called playing dumb about an aspect of the game that you should know if you are an experienced player. Dolby, how have you played nearly 45 games without ever seeing a strong-arm before??? They are very common on MU, so I would be surprised if there was never one in this forum before. And even if you genuinely did not know what it was, there was no reason to ask in the thread. Google is your friend.

TL;DR #2: I am extremely confident that Dolby is mafia. His indifference and avoidance of the thread, his weak or nonexistent logic, along with the fact that not once in this game has he town told even just a little bit. Not to mention his pardon on being modkilled.

- - - Post Merge - - -

You know what?
Everyone state their role name.

This is an entirely horrible idea, you realize that right? We are not even at MYLO yet. If my Dolby case does not convince you, then I will claim.

Otherwise I would STRONGLY prefer everyone just shuts up and we wait for MYLO to claim.

 

[Dolby]

My role name is Scarlen, and yes before people start screaming at me, I am going to address Xine's case

 

[xine]

Here comes the mother of all coasters.

I like you.

 

[Cory]

Sorry for being quiet all day, haven't had enough free time to read the thread until now



I'm Vangarre

i knew there would be a vangarre

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok, the safe claims that I think daniel made are rock solid. Good work.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'd be willing to vote dolby. His flip would help me determine who is scum most likely/

- - - Post Merge - - -

If dolby flips scum. I'm pretty confident that the last 2 scum are Mother of all Llamas and cadberry