Mafia Xenoblade Chronicles Mafia-Endgame

[Heyden]

Dolby, what are your opinions on everyone else??

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Dolby, what are your opinions on everyone else??

What about your reads pal :^)

 

[Jacob]

Cadbberry and Jacob sheeping as usual, if anything I am almost sure that one of them is scum. Jacob is perfectly matching his scum meta and does not do anything to contribute except pushing for the easy lynch. Cadbberry is even worse because she is so indecisive about EVERYTHING and follows and sheeps everyone so make her look like she is town.\

so far i've pushed and voted people who didn't get lynched both days (with the exception of Dolby today), so unless you don't know what "sheeping" really means then this read is pathetic

 

[Cory]

I think Jacob is town.

He's trying to townsolve and I expected someone to have his role name.

 

[Dolby]

I was first to vote on inkling because he was acting like scum and I have been trying to get people to see you were scum for days.

I was using that as an example as to why mob mentality is not always correct

 

[Cadbberry]

I was using that as an example as to why mob mentality is not always correct

But you wrote it off as saying

Literally sheeping right here

So I dont think you were exampling mob mentality to well if that is what you were attempting to do

 

[Kirbystarship]

I still think Dolby is more of a threat than Ashtot. I think Dolby is blue snipeing so I'll keep my vote on him.

 

[Dolby]

I still think Dolby is more of a threat than Ashtot. I think Dolby is blue snipeing so I'll keep my vote on him.

All four night kills so far were blue, I'll grant you that, but

1. Entropy was the driving force behind lynching Crys, which made her an obvious kill for the mafia
2. Taesaek was an outted cop
3. Alexi returned as town to taesaek

These three people were all fairly trusted by the town, the only kill that doesn't make sense immediately is Trundle, which is why I think that Ashtot killed him

 

[Trent the Paladin]

All four night kills so far were blue, I'll grant you that, but

1. Entropy was the driving force behind lynching Crys, which made her an obvious kill for the mafia
2. Taesaek was an outted cop
3. Alexi returned as town to taesaek

These three people were all fairly trusted by the town, the only kill that doesn't make sense immediately is Trundle, which is why I think that Ashtot killed him

All these reasons make sense, not to mention Alexi had been on/off softing since D2 start.

Any more reads Dolbs?

 

[Dolby]

All these reasons make sense, not to mention Alexi had been on/off softing since D2 start.

Any more reads Dolbs?

These aren't even my reads, lol. I'm thinking of making two more cases on people who I feel are scummy. Not making them until after I eat lunch

- - - Post Merge - - -

I misread "reasons" as "reads".

 

[Dolby]

Cadbberry​

Well we don't want you targeted but with the PR soft claim I think there is already a target on you. So if you want to claim, maybe it ok, if it helps we need it but if we have a doctor, bodyguard, someone, be on Panda so we don't loose her.

Bringing this back up: Lowkey attempt to get the doc off of Taesaek, a hardclaimed cop

I fear for lynching a PR but I need to vote so I will go back with Ares, my apologies

In regards to lynching Ares, who had just softed

In regards to the Inkling wagon yesterday, and her suspicion of me today, I find her scummy in that she pretty much disregarded her previous suspicions on Ashtot when a town target came into play. I think that she's mafia trying to preserve the teams KP

Day Two

I can see why people want to lynch Ashtot now, oh I am so close to jumping on that vote but I am going to think about it before I switch votes. I can see why they are so scum read though

Night Two and Day Three

I would love to hear some opinions from Ares and Ash, they haven't posted on here since 5/10, I would like some reads or an explanations on D3 or some of your opinions on the events going on at the moment.

I agree with the idea, lets lynch the scummiest and leave it to the vig to shoot our the non contributers. I am thinking our vig should look at Dolby, Nightmares, and Mother. As for scum Ashtot does seem to be very sus, if vig did shoot and he didn't die does that mean GF? Does it work that way, GF is immune at night?

PandaDarling- Helping town a lot, pushing and trying to get information, just seems very good hearted
Xine- Also helping town a lot, good reads, scum hunting
Tardis2016- Said that this matches past town metas, will trust for now
Ares- Still said they were important, though they are loosing my trust slowly, but town lean
Tom- Claimed as neutral
Hayden- Just popping in and out, nothing to much for me to follow, pushing a bit here and there but not really the activity they usually have
Jacob- Unusually silent considering the guy it is, I am not trusting of all of his scummy behaviors and phrases
Cory- I really have mixed feelings, seems to be trying to push a town lean but just seems scatter brained in the end, a few weird not game based posts, but really aren't reading them as more scum in end
Tina- I can't decide about her, being inactive and not helping town to much, just popping in to give a few answers and leaving again, don't trust them
Mother of all Llamas- Can't even play the game, band wagoning and pointless behavior, I hope they get mod killed for their inactivity, it is ridiculous, if you wont contribute please don't sign up again
Nightmares- Fake looking town slips, I don't trust them at all
Dolby- A band wagoner and not helping, posted reads but that isn't enough to prove town, just seems to be coasting and just saying simple replies to not give away to much information
Ashtot- De-railer and just seems to be trying to throw town off, now not posting once we asked for more information.

This is where I begin to have an issue with Cadbberry in regard to their avoidence of Ashtot

So should we lynch dolby and let Ashtot get shot by our vig, if we have one, or let ashtot get lynched and dolby take the vig bullet, or if not, which one is a bigger threat to town. Tardis makes the case that dolby is a PR hunter so maybe it would be good for the more pointless poster to stay longer and have the larger threat lynched

No, not just because of that, because you act like a scummy band wagoner, you also have been avoiding answering questions until today, now you are suddenly active because we want to lynch you today

And then, like Panda, you begin to completely disregard other suspicions that you had before. I wouldn't be surprised if you were setting up to bus Ashtot and then decided to be suspicious of me to keep KP elevated

I am not bussing anyone, I can't even buss in the first place considering I am not mafia. Dolby is scummy as it is and he has helped him self get lynched with all the things he has said. I am also not the only person to say it, if I am bussing dolby then why are there a multitude of cases against him and many many votes against him, because a lot of people say he is mafia.

How am I sheeping? I have been for Dolby all of N2 and D3. If you want to talk about sheeping I would look at your self, you have given terrible descriptions and answers as to why you want to lynch anyone and just pop in to band wagon vote.

Spoiler: Cadbberry's sheeping

I am painting with my mom but I will try to stay on the conversion the best I can. Also I will unvote Ares for now as we were told to do

well that is some incriminating evidence, now I see why everyone is going to Ares, but I always worry that we may have jester at the same time, I don't know if that role is commonly played on TBT, but I have to say that either those were some fake plays or they are a bad mafia member

It wasn't your fault that you couldn't be on panda, with so many people not posting much of use it is hard to decide who to lynch. That is why with the evidence against Ares I voted for them, because there isn't much to work with

I am voting Inkling for being a question dogger and for making no sense in their posts.

I can see why people want to lynch Ashtot now, oh I am so close to jumping on that vote but I am going to think about it before I switch votes. I can see why they are so scum read though

If that is his town meta then I accept it, I have only played one game with him and he was a lot more active and spammy so that is just my limited knowlege. I trust your vouching of a town meta like this

Those are some great points, I appriciate you bringing those up, it helps me re read him a bit.

As mentioned by another player, Vig, if there is one, shoot Ash.

I started the vote on inkling, I don't think I was on any wagon to lynch him, just using my opinions of his activity to lynch him. My guess is Mother and Dolby, Dolby being incredibly silent and lurking only and Mother never being active but when posting just jumping on the band wagon vote with the most people. I also have a high sus of Nightmares, there have been just a sequence of town slips that looks so cheesy I can taste it, even if they weren't as active in other games this is still game three for them and the amount of basic questions coming in high sequence looks very false to me.

I didn't even think about them just being called out as GF, that is a great point Cory

So should we lynch dolby and let Ashtot get shot by our vig, if we have one, or let ashtot get lynched and dolby take the vig bullet, or if not, which one is a bigger threat to town. Tardis makes the case that dolby is a PR hunter so maybe it would be good for the more pointless poster to stay longer and have the larger threat lynched

Hypocritical much?

I am not bussing anyone, I can't even buss in the first place considering I am not mafia. Dolby is scummy as it is and he has helped him self get lynched with all the things he has said. I am also not the only person to say it, if I am bussing dolby then why are there a multitude of cases against him and many many votes against him, because a lot of people say he is mafia.

A suggestion that we follow mob mentality, especially since the Inkling lynch worked so well last time

I can honestly see Dolby being mafia, he is contributing the least, giving reads that are basic, and for just bandwagoning on the inkling lynch

You yourself are guilty of all of these.

Spoiler: Cadbberry's reads

I am voting Inkling for being a question dogger and for making no sense in their posts.

1.PandaDarling
8.Taesaek
18.Cory
19.Xine
14.Ares
2.Dolby
4.Mother of all Llamas
10.Jacob
20.Tardis2016
11.Tom
17.Tina
5.Alexi
13.Nightmares
15.Hayden
21.Xerolin
6.Ashtot
9.Inkling
16.Aronthaer-Waiting on Replacement

Here are my color coded reads, wanted to get these out before I jet to school, I will be home in 7-8 hours so I apologize for not responding for a while if you have questions about anything.

I can elaborate, so my town reads rely on being helpful and scum hunting, Panda and Xine are scum hunting a lot making me feel like I can put them in town though last game Panda was scum and was very helpful so there is always a possibility that they could be scum but am not getting that read currently. Ares soft claimed, I did make a vote before and I do regret that decision since it made no sense to do such, and I am going to trust that soft claim for now. Cory has also claimed as a townie and I am inclined to believe him though he has been a bit of a lacking town, acting like Ashtot early in game, being very troll like, but after his claim I am going to believe him. Tae, it is more of a gut feeling, he is being much more inquisitive this game and has been trying to get some good reads over people.
As for my null, Jacob, I just can't tell, I have known him for a while and I cant tell if he plays like this or it is just his personality shining through. Dolby hasn't really contributed enough for me to decide if I am totally suspicious yet compared to other reads of him. Also he claimed he was busy with AP exams so I can understand how he has not posted much of anything. Mother doesn't post anything at all, I really don't like playing with them for that reason. But looking at their play style, they are just coasting and bandwagoning on anything that is happening, I probably move them to scum for this behavior, much like the last game where they were scum and didn't say anything when it came to busing their team mates or when they were just coasting along. Tardis has been unusually silent and I would have to say I would also move them in sus for this, they are a very mouthy person, posting a lot of opinions, even de-railing things but this game they are being very pop in and go, usually from the play style of last game.
Tom has claimed as a third party, I am going to trust his claim and thus put him as a yellow third party.
Tina had almost everyone read as sus and has been awkward in her posting, I want to go back and find quote but her front page link isn't there and I am about to bike to school. It just a tiny sus though, nothing too big and they could easily be town and it could just be me over thinking things. Alexi has just been everywhere, though they are very questioning and pushing this just reminds me of last game where they were mafia, so it may just be their meta and I don't know it as well as others but I can say that I just don't have a deep trusting with her play style this game. Nightmares is just coasting by and is being useless, they are posting everywhere on tbt but only getting single sentences sent out to explain, maybe they can't handle their role or maybe they just aren't helpful, its hard to say but I have to don't trust that. Also they are 'town slipping', as this is their third game I would expect them to know some of the terms, I had some issues with words in my first game but I just don't believe these ones, they just look so fake to me. Hayden has been unusually quiet, they are usually like Tardis and have been just absent, it looks awkward and I don't know if I trust a quiet Hayden like this, I honestly can't tell how much they posted since his link is broken on the OP but I know it isn't like the other game I played with them, it just has me on edge. My read on Xero really doesn't matter since they are banned, but I didn't like their wording and everything came off as a joke when I read it.
Inkling and Ashtot both have been de-railing, saying contradictory things, though Ashtot has gotten a bit better and is trying to help a little. I would say though that Inkling is the prime target we have right now, it just hasn't been making so much sense and with inkling not even trying to defend them self, claim, anything, it just looks like they cant decide what to say now that everyone turned and called them mafia, like they didn't have a back up something to say.

I gotta jet to school but I can use the computer a bit so I will try and pop in.

PandaDarling- Helping town a lot, pushing and trying to get information, just seems very good hearted
Xine- Also helping town a lot, good reads, scum hunting
Tardis2016- Said that this matches past town metas, will trust for now
Ares- Still said they were important, though they are loosing my trust slowly, but town lean
Tom- Claimed as neutral
Hayden- Just popping in and out, nothing to much for me to follow, pushing a bit here and there but not really the activity they usually have
Jacob- Unusually silent considering the guy it is, I am not trusting of all of his scummy behaviors and phrases
Cory- I really have mixed feelings, seems to be trying to push a town lean but just seems scatter brained in the end, a few weird not game based posts, but really aren't reading them as more scum in end
Tina- I can't decide about her, being inactive and not helping town to much, just popping in to give a few answers and leaving again, don't trust them
Mother of all Llamas- Can't even play the game, band wagoning and pointless behavior, I hope they get mod killed for their inactivity, it is ridiculous, if you wont contribute please don't sign up again
Nightmares- Fake looking town slips, I don't trust them at all
Dolby- A band wagoner and not helping, posted reads but that isn't enough to prove town, just seems to be coasting and just saying simple replies to not give away to much information
Ashtot- De-railer and just seems to be trying to throw town off, now not posting once we asked for more information.

These reads are three sentences per person at most

Finally, there are her numerous filler posts

Spoiler: Cadbberry's filler

Please don't do that

Awww, sorry heyden There are still some more restocks I bet, I feel it in my bones. I wish you luck on them

Glad to have you back online!

I didn't even know there was a discord! Oh thats rad! Unless its the one I am in and then I am just stupid af

Well I am really dumb huh, give me the dunce cap..... sorry tae
Now I feel really rude

I am painting with my mom but I will try to stay on the conversion the best I can. Also I will unvote Ares for now as we were told to do

Very cool your phone is getting replaced, I hope it works better. Who do you think is most sus right now?

Can't wait to see your reads

I am an indecisive person, it is who I am, if you vote you may be my nail in the coffin, I well claim if I need but I am nothing important so it doesn't matter

I have been giving my opinion but because I came late to the party I am now a sheep? Or because my opinion in the same as another?

Also just saying I was painting, well finished :3

Spoiler: my painting, this is why my responses were slow

Sorry you are so behind in work, I do hope Daniel can find another replacement soon. I hope you catch up Aron

I asked that question too and I cant say I remember it getting answered, but that may just be my awful memory

Well, there goes two of our PR roles! Ugh, this bites

How do they look petty?

What about Tae's post was petty?

Would you two stop taking the thread off track and actually play the game

Thank you Daniel <3

That is noted for my future games, I was not aware this was a bad thing to point out. Both the Trump game and this one have had it and I assumed it was an ok point out.

Why aren't you sus of Mother as the godfather?

I didn't even think about them just being called out as GF, that is a great point Cory

TL;DR: Cadbberry has been taking every oppurtunity to avoid an Ashtot lynch. Many of her posts are filler posts. Her behavior is hypocritical, and she has an alarming amount of filler posts

 

[PandaDarling]

Anyways... When is this day ending ? On time on late again. ?

 

[Dolby]

Anyways... When is this day ending ? On time on late again. ?

7 pm PST

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Anyways... When is this day ending ? On time on late again. ?

That's really all you have to say? Even after Dolby threw suspicion on you?

 

[PandaDarling]

That's really all you have to say? Even after Dolby threw suspicion on you?

Where did he throw suspicion on me ? And ya I don't really car e what he has to say, I know what's I am I can confirm what I am and I'm pretty sure he is going to flip red, what's what's your deal? You want to side with him now? Sometimes you say things like this and reminds me that your not town sided.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Where did he throw suspicion on me ? And ya I don't really car e what he has to say, I know what's I am I can confirm what I am and I'm pretty sure he is going to flip red, what's what's your deal? You want to side with him now? Sometimes you say things like this and reminds me that your not town sided.

Towards the bottom of his Ashtot post.

And you know what, you're right I'm not. Don't care, just gonna skirt the rest this game because unless Vig or Maf shoots me for the hell of it, I'm going to win.

 

[Kirbystarship]

Towards the bottom of his Ashtot post.

And you know what, you're right I'm not. Don't care, just gonna skirt the rest this game because unless Vig or Maf shoots me for the hell of it, I'm going to win.

How are you going to win if Vig or mafia shoots you?

 

[PandaDarling]

Towards the bottom of his Ashtot post.

And you know what, you're right I'm not. Don't care, just gonna skirt the rest this game because unless Vig or Maf shoots me for the hell of it, I'm going to win.

No seriously ? Why would you care what Dolby is saying about me ? Do you doubt he is scum and that I am town ? Why would it matter. It's his last attempt to save himself.

 

[Dolby]

Where did he throw suspicion on me ? And ya I don't really car e what he has to say, I know what's I am I can confirm what I am and I'm pretty sure he is going to flip red, what's what's your deal? You want to side with him now? Sometimes you say things like this and reminds me that your not town sided.

...This is just a sign of bad play. What a mafia-aligned player says shows a lot about the alignments of other players. More over, before Xine's case, you were using the fact that all four players that died were blue and that I was pardoned for not voting two days in a row (the exemption was pre-announced by Daniel at Day Two) as justification for why you think that I'm scum. Are you dismissing my cases as worthless without reading them? And why did you say that you think that I am a godfather specifically?

 

[mother of all llamas]

Why are we still lynching Dolby instead of Ashtot?