Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

Chele said:
You clearly didn’t read the two other reasons of my post; your general play and your reads. AtE was just upon one of them.

And @Vanessa I’m not sure if Rune would be one to coast purposely in Mafia games though?

Heyden said:
I don’t see how that’s relevant to you asking people to read your 6 posts less than 24 hours into the game, which a) sussed antonio bc you obviously have a personal vendetta against him and b) townlocked mog for something
To me it kinda felt like you were asking for reassurance on your play, it’s just such a weird thing to ask, especially when there was 0 pressure on you at the time.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I’ve seen rune lurking a bit but her posts for the most part seem fine. I did find their kingmaker mechanic misunderstanding pretty genuine, but I’m not sure that’s alignment indicative. She is coasting, but nothing sticks out to me rn thats lynchworthy.

Idk, the fact that she's coasting concerns me. She definitely normally puts more effort as town because she feels she's better at it. As town she's usually a top contributor (look at Woodpines - all though she was N1'd she posted lots of quality stuff - and CTSTP) and analyzes/explains all her reasoning. Throwing out two names as town and scumlean with no reasoning is pretty surprising to me coming from her. Either she's busy/demotivated or she's hesitant to post because she's scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll look into the punchy accusations when I'm on the train

- - - Post Merge - - -

I guess to credit her, she defended Punchy and Trundle (with no reasoning, mind you) which would be easy wagons to latch onto as scum. Although, her scumlean Jacob is getting a fair amount of sus now too (which I can't say I understand, while his content has been meh nothing really sticks out to me about it)

Heyden · Jan 8, 2019

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
@Heyden

His posts tone looked bad on first glance but no I?m pretty sure his town

Ok but I just don?t get WHY you want reads on you. I?m not asking why you asked for reads, I?m asking what is so important about other people?s opnions on you with only a few posts?

Chele · Jan 8, 2019

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
Caxnival is her most recent scumgame where she has lived for a while iirc, invalidate that. CTSTP is mog’s most recent game, so unless they learned any new tricks, that is accurate meta

Well obviously Mog and Bianca has learnt something new in the past 10 months.
And why did you go and townlock Mog then? Not even a townlean. It was based JUST off 10 month CTSTP meta.
Also still, it isn’t accurate meta for Bianca. You legit went from scumlean to “I wanna lynch her” in three minutes. Just Caxnival meta alone shouldn’t get you THAT far, to want to lynch Bianca.

@ Vanessa
I’m not too worried about Rune right now. The thing is, if she isn’t online until last minute EoD or for the rest of day, then it’ll be a prime time to think about lynching her.
Also just a question, but are you gonna wait until EoD to choose a person to execute or are you gonna cut it short?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Mog and Bianca have* ughghg okay imma go to sleep. I think my brain is turning upside-down

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

@Chele
I have school until 8pm EST today so I definitely won't be ending it before then, and I'll probably need at least an hour to catch up on stuff I missed while at school, so yeah I won't be ending the day much before the deadline.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I want the full time to decide anyways

unravel · Jan 8, 2019

If you were a scum you wouldn't ask anyone to read you cuz its a stupid move.

illunie · Jan 8, 2019

its d1 idk what u want me to say, its not like ive seen anyone else putting major evidence into their posts

i guess if u want me to say smth then theres no way scum trundle wouldnt have stepped back and taken a deep breathe if he was maf. i mean ness literally scumread him for being too concerned about how he appeared and that that was characteristic of him, do u think that that outburst looked like it was coming from a person who was worried about how they would be percieved lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

and its prob not me lurking btw its prob just me having the tab open somewhere, ik that ppl wont believe me if they dont want to but hey at least im online and not in invisible mode unlike 90 percent of the ppl playing :lemon:

toadsworthy · Jan 8, 2019

I’m alive, pounding headache.... I have appointments at 9am and 11:30, so I’ll be active from that point on until EoD

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

Runeraider said:
its d1 idk what u want me to say, its not like ive seen anyone else putting major evidence into their posts

i guess if u want me to say smth then theres no way scum trundle wouldnt have stepped back and taken a deep breathe if he was maf. i mean ness literally scumread him for being too concerned about how he appeared and that that was characteristic of him, do u think that that outburst looked like it was coming from a person who was worried about how they would be percieved lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

and its prob not me lurking btw its prob just me having the tab open somewhere, ik that ppl wont believe me if they dont want to but hey at least im online and not in invisible mode unlike 90 percent of the ppl playing

But normally you do say stuff on D1. In woodpines you had a whole reads list on D1 and didn't you make a giant Evan ISO in CTSTP on D1? You've basically only commented on 2 people and not even really analyzed them. Can you explain your Jacob read? What you said about Trundle makes sense so thanks for that

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not expecting you or anyone to make a whole reads list or ISO for the record (because I certainly am not), I'm just trying to prove that you've been uncharacteristically quiet

mogyay · Jan 8, 2019

i still don't like the whole trundle situation but i'll elaborate later, i'm busy this afternoon but i'll be back early evening to provide some actual reads (they won't be that elaborate tho bc lbr it's me lol)

also heads up but day ends 3am for me and i have work at 6am so absolutely no way do i plan on being around for it

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

Also just a reminder that EVERYONE should vote in the voting thread before EoD, if not you'll be scumread thx

Heyden · Jan 8, 2019

Punchy
I'm sure Punchy won't mind me using a few months old meta considering his top scumread is solely based on one year old meta. I'm not gonna explain everything in paragraphs bc I'm sure you guys get the idea I'm trying to illustrate when I compare his behaviour.

PunchyDaHufflepuff from RESISTANCE MAFIA (SCUM) said:
Toads what are your thoughts on me?

Just an interesting parallel I noticed which stuck out to me initially, compared to this game;

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
people please read me ty <3

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
Jacob read me please

So for unravel to say it's a stupid thing for mafia to do, well, maybe that stupidity is showing.

I also noticed as town he overuses 'I think' or 'could' or 'possibly', or contradicts himself bc he's uncertain as a townie should be, but as mafia it's quite the polar opposite if you delve into most of his posts.

PunchyDaHufflepuff from RESISTANCE MAFIA (SCUM) said:
No way, you are blatantly obvious scum imo.

PunchyDaHufflepuff from RESISTANCE MAFIA (SCUM) said:
oh. oh oh oh. Your teammate is Ryumia.

PunchyDaHufflepuff from LOVERS MAFIA (TOWN) said:
Dad seems to be fishing out my reaction. I was waiting for more evidence to vote Antonio, but Dad seems trigger happy, which I think is a red flag, bigger than bringing up the topic of no lynch. Bianca's second post seems towny, but her first post is scummy when you take into consideration that this is Bianca, and that post doesn't seem town Bianca.

PunchyDaHufflepuff from NOMINANTION MAFIA (TOWN) said:
antonio's post sounds forced
I want to look back into cala, with Antonio's post, I could see a cala/Antonio team.
I want to rule out toads because I don't think he'd let either of them make those posts.

Compared to this game;

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
Bianca is still wishywashy, fluffy, and defo not town bianca

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
This is 100% town mog, scum mog would be uncomfortable and seem out of it. Check CTSTP

And with that point, if you go through his post filter on this game, you won't find the word 'could' or 'think' (discounting him attacking Chele's knowledge) or 'possibly', it's all 'would' and 'is' as if he's certain, which is showing his obvious directional accusations imo.

There doesn't seem to be a main FOS rn so I wouldn't be surprised if the Punchy bw catches on after Chele's and my post
I have a ton of chem hw to do and I sleep in tomorrow so I can't promise I'll be here EoD :') goodnight

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

Heyden thats some interesting stuff you found hmm

illunie · Jan 8, 2019

Vampnessa said:
But normally you do say stuff on D1. In woodpines you had a whole reads list on D1 and didn't you make a giant Evan ISO in CTSTP on D1? You've basically only commented on 2 people and not even really analyzed them. Can you explain your Jacob read? What you said about Trundle makes sense so thanks for that

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm not expecting you or anyone to make a whole reads list or ISO for the record (because I certainly am not), I'm just trying to prove that you've been uncharacteristically quiet

id make a reads list if i could but most of today has just been a mess of ate back and forth, woodpines had a lot more actual content from what i remember. my read on jacob is v subject to change like im p sure i said before so its not rly worth me making a full iso or smth but i guess if u rly want smth he feels like hes said basically no new reads and is just jumping on ppl that everyone else is jumping on, and the one time where he listed 3 ppl and said he thought there was maybe one mafia between all three of them was super fishy and just looked like he was hedging his bets and not committing to a read (trundle said this stuff before i think which is y i didnt think it was super important to explain myself). ofc u could prob say some of that stuff about me as well which is y its a weak read but there u go i guess, this game has just kinda sucked so far lol

mogyay · Jan 8, 2019

i've been kinda putting punchy townlocking me to the back of my mind but the more i think about it the more i feel uneasy, i'm aware that my meta is completely obvious but like chelle said it's been a year and everyone is capable of changing. my mafia meta is just so obvious that it would obviously be in my best interest to change my playstyle and i also don't believe me and punchy have that much of a history together that he's capable of town locking me, which leads me to believe that maybe he knows something that i don't, i always believe someone who's capable of town locking this early in the game must surely have information that we don't, coupled with the emotion it is kinda suspicious

on the flip side, punchy is probably a good mafia target, and i didn't even suspect him that much honestly but i felt like he was using his emotions against us, i do agree punchy is treated unfairly but that outburst seemed almost random and out of place??? i even said at the time like 'where's this coming from' bc he absolutely must have looked at the thread and saw what antonio said AND THEN decided to comment on it after (at least i think that's how it went down), it'd look better if u had the outburst as soon a u saw it???? does that make sense lol

all in all i would be ok with a punchy lynch but i'm also ok waiting

illunie · Jan 8, 2019

Heyden said:
Punchy
I'm sure Punchy won't mind me using a few months old meta considering his top scumread is solely based on one year old meta. I'm not gonna explain everything in paragraphs bc I'm sure you guys get the idea I'm trying to illustrate when I compare his behaviour.

Just an interesting parallel I noticed which stuck out to me initially, compared to this game;

So for unravel to say it's a stupid thing for mafia to do, well, maybe that stupidity is showing.

I also noticed as town he overuses 'I think' or 'could' or 'possibly', or contradicts himself bc he's uncertain as a townie should be, but as mafia it's quite the polar opposite if you delve into most of his posts.

Compared to this game;

And with that point, if you go through his post filter on this game, you won't find the word 'could' or 'think' (discounting him attacking Chele's knowledge) or 'possibly', it's all 'would' and 'is' as if he's certain, which is showing his obvious directional accusations imo.

There doesn't seem to be a main FOS rn so I wouldn't be surprised if the Punchy bw catches on after Chele's and my post
I have a ton of chem hw to do and I sleep in tomorrow so I can't promise I'll be here EoD :') goodnight

i agree that the change in how certain he is in himself is concerning but i think he had a good explanation for y he was asking for ppl to reading (not good as in sensical but good as in i can def see y town punchy would do it), def changes my stance on him a bit tho, wouldnt say its a solid sr for me but well see i guess

- - - Post Merge - - -

Vampnessa said:
Also just a reminder that EVERYONE should vote in the voting thread before EoD, if not you'll be scumread thx

wait is this legit or a meme i cant tell, ur gonna sr ppl for not voting

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

No it's not a meme, I want everyone to vote as if it's a regular lynch because I said I'm doing majority
If people don't vote they need a good reason why or else it will seem to me like they're just trying to stay off the radar by not giving us any information

illunie · Jan 8, 2019

Vampnessa said:
No it's not a meme, I want everyone to vote as if it's a regular lynch because I said I'm doing majority
If people don't vote they need a good reason why or else it will seem to me like they're just trying to stay off the radar by not giving us any information

would u sr a person for not voting in a normal game?

mogyay · Jan 8, 2019

ye i agree with vanessa. why would u think she wouldn't rune? not voting is very useless, there's enough stuff going on that we can make informed decisions

cornimer · Jan 8, 2019

Runeraider said:
would u sr a person for not voting in a normal game?

Yes unless they were hospitalized at EoD or something

illunie · Jan 8, 2019

im just trying to remember if we always sr ppl for not voting, from my memory it was just sort of a we thing, not great but not rly ai either

Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

Senior Member

You’ll find me upstairs.

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

Professional klutz

girl now uwu

Tangsworthy

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

✨night night✨

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

Senior Member

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

girl now uwu

✨night night✨

girl now uwu

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

girl now uwu

✨night night✨

grab acorns 'til you're delirious

girl now uwu

Similar threads