Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[voltairenism]

Oh, but speaking of, something else to talk about.

What are your feelings on voting non elim day 1?
Are you pro voting off inactives if we don't have any good maf leads?

Post automatically merged: May 10, 2024

This one

Post automatically merged: May 10, 2024

We had 10/17 at this point and 4 mafia so this is some strange logic.

cranky bc zinnia didnt give you cyan right /j
guess we can assume zinnia townread everyone online. do you think they would be covering up for a teammate?
and yeah im always for policy chops. dont rly enjoy no elim though. no intel

 

[Jacob4]

Oh, but speaking of, something else to talk about.

What are your feelings on voting non elim day 1?
Are you pro voting off inactives if we don't have any good maf leads?

no elimination is just numerically not a good option in 13v4

only time no elim should be considered is in a situation where there's 2 more town alive than mafia, where town nokilling and then mafia killing would be optimal for town as it gives them better odds of killing mafia the next day, but in this setup mafia have the option to nokill which offsets that lol

 

[TN4U]

i agree with whoever said volt is slightly townish

Same here. Nothing has stood out to me from them so far.

 

[voltairenism]

we do no elim and mafia do no kill. we try to make this the longest mafia game in a prisoners dilemma kinda vibe

 

[TN4U]

only time no elim should be considered is in a situation where there's 2 more town alive than mafia, where town nokilling and then mafia killing would be optimal for town as it gives them better odds of killing mafia the next day, but in this setup mafia have the option to nokill which offsets that lol

Exactly. It's a little too early to not vote for anyone. Justice needs to be served as soon as possible for Damniel's sudden death.

 

[EpicGamer12]

chances are the mafia haven't come online yet

I will say, policy vote AFKs last game would've worked pretty well

 

[annika]

I will say, policy vote AFKs last game would've worked pretty well

yeah im an advocate for doing this if need be

i still encourage people to try and find who could be a woof among the active posters tho

 

[EpicGamer12]

So now that mog is asleep we can all agree she is giving mafia vibes right?

 

[Jacob4]

no elimination is just numerically not a good option in 13v4

only time no elim should be considered is in a situation where there's 2 more town alive than mafia, where town nokilling and then mafia killing would be optimal for town as it gives them better odds of killing mafia the next day, but in this setup mafia have the option to nokill which offsets that lol

so basically another way of explaining this:

town nokilling day 1 heightens the likelihood that town will get less kills than they would have otherwise, subsequently handing more of the kill control to mafia, which obv isn't really a good thing

 

[TN4U]

So now that mog is asleep we can all agree she is giving mafia vibes right?

I have the feeling she might be. Something's off about her replies.

 

[annika]

So now that mog is asleep we can all agree she is giving mafia vibes right?

hmm, i’m not sure—i didn’t find her vibes suspicious, but i could just be biased bc she types cutely

could be a woof with specifically dolby ig

 

[FrostyAlmonds]

- I’m not really suspicious of anyone yet, so I might go with it

Hiya Yoshi. Welcome to your first maf game, hope you'll have a good time playing.

Did you already read through the thread already to have this opinion?

cranky bc zinnia didnt give you cyan right /j
guess we can assume zinnia townread everyone online. do you think they would be covering up for a teammate?
and yeah im always for policy chops. dont rly enjoy no elim though. no intel

You got me.
I mean that's fair, but also IDK I don't buy having solid townreads on everyone less than 2 hours into the game?? I mean, it's possible that no one from maf has come in yet, but I don't think it's townaligning to assume that when over half the players have said something in game?? Comes off as a little too lax for a town perspective, and sounds more like a tmi statement. I wouldn't say it's to cover a teammate, more like trying to relax us and not overthink too hard which again, not very town aligned. IDK, it's just a weird assumption to come from town.

 

[Yoshi155]

Hiya Yoshi. Welcome to your first maf game, hope you'll have a good time playing.

Did you already read through the thread already to have this opinion?

Yeah, I hope it’s fun too.

For the second one, I have read through the thread and I’ve seen that there are a few consistent people that we think it is, but I don’t think there’s enough evidence for a hard vote yet. So I’ll just probably vote for no elim this time.

 

[TN4U]

hmm, i’m not sure—i didn’t find her vibes suspicious, but i could just be biased bc she types cutely

could be a woof with specifically dolby ig

In my opinion, Mog seems more of a woof than Dolby. Both could be mafia, but Mog's replies to others makes me personally think that she's hiding something. I'd rather vote for her first over Dolby to be honest.

 

[annika]

Yeah, I hope it’s fun too.

For the second one, I have read through the thread and I’ve seen that there are a few consistent people that we think it is, but I don’t think there’s enough evidence for a hard vote yet. So I’ll just probably vote for no elim this time.

you don’t have to decide what you’ll vote this early, we have like 46 hours

 

[voltairenism]

I have the feeling she might be. Something's off about her replies.

wdym

hmm, i’m not sure—i didn’t find her vibes suspicious, but i could just be biased bc she types cutely

could be a woof with specifically dolby ig

lmao
why a dolby/mog team?

Hiya Yoshi. Welcome to your first maf game, hope you'll have a good time playing.

Did you already read through the thread already to have this opinion?




You got me.
I mean that's fair, but also IDK I don't buy having solid townreads on everyone less than 2 hours into the game?? I mean, it's possible that no one from maf has come in yet, but I don't think it's townaligning to assume that when over half the players have said something in game?? Comes off as a little too lax for a town perspective, and sounds more like a tmi statement. I wouldn't say it's to cover a teammate, more like trying to relax us and not overthink too hard which again, not very town aligned. IDK, it's just a weird assumption to come from town.

yeah i just think mafia has motivations in their actions. so im not sure what could be the motivation to try to cover for a teammate or change the topic. i wont discard them being awkward bc of tmi though
if zianni flips red we should remember this moment ig

 

[FrostyAlmonds]

Yeah, I hope it’s fun too.

For the second one, I have read through the thread and I’ve seen that there are a few consistent people that we think it is, but I don’t think there’s enough evidence for a hard vote yet. So I’ll just probably vote for no elim this time.

What consistancy? None of us have anything to go off of it's only been two hours, right now is mostly fluff and picking at dumb statements to generate conversation. I don't want to influence you, esp since it's your first game, but generally saying you want to vote no elim pretty much on your first post when the game has barely started is not a solid strat. We still have 46 hours to make a decision. I asked that about people's feelings not if we want to vote No elim right here and now.

Post automatically merged: May 10, 2024

**When I say dumb statements, I don't mean the statements themselves or who said them are dumb hjvhjsvsjd everyone is valid for what they post, I just mean like finding anything to question.

 

[TN4U]

wdym

Well, looking at #88, it sort of tells me that Mog would want to eliminate Jacob very quickly. It's not incredibly obvious, but it sort of raises a red flag.

 

[Yoshi155]

What consistancy? None of us have anything to go off of it's only been two hours, right now is mostly fluff and picking at dumb statements to generate conversation. I don't want to influence you, esp since it's your first game, but generally saying you want to vote no elim pretty much on your first post when the game has barely started is not a solid strat. We still have 46 hours to make a decision. I asked that about people's feelings not if we want to vote No elim right here and now.

Post automatically merged: May 10, 2024

**When I say dumb statements, I don't mean the statements themselves or who said them are dumb hjvhjsvsjd everyone is valid for what they post, I just mean like finding anything to question.

I thought that we thought Zinnia was one of the mafia members? That might just be me not paying close attention.

 

[Jacob4]

1:20am here so gonna go now lol, will be back tomorrow :3