Quinn > Reneigh = Faith
I have an inherent bias towards bird villagers for some reason, probably because I have many memorable favourites from my early years playing ACGC. I'm also big on the uchi aesthetic, of their designs being a little off-kilter and alternative, and something about Quinn just 100% did it for me the second I saw her card in the direct. Besides losing my mind over Rio's return, I was able to stop and go:
heeey, who's that new uchi eagle?!
Still haven't seen her in-game but I know it will be a very exciting moment whenever that happens!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/577d8/577d8b434b12fab8f692979f05050bde88e29f58" alt="Smiling face with hearts :smiling_face_with_3_hearts: 🥰"
(been too busy IRL lately to play much of ACNH 2.0, boo-hoo.)
Reneigh and Faith are sort of tied because I don't have any experience with either of them.
Reneigh strikes me as a fancier-designed cousin of Annalise, who I have really liked and enjoyed in ACNH.
And while Faith does sort of look like this:
I'm still interested in meeting her in-game!
(disclaimer: I've, uh, never watched any iteration of The Office. I was shown that particular scene once and it's stuck in my head ever since. Glad I was able to reference it!)