Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[cornimer]

Mhm... This game is making me too paranoid. I don't know what to do... :X

To recap, Punchy claimed that his win condition is to "eliminate all hostile parties", when multiple town members have said that their role PMs don't actually state win condition. Therefore it is clear that Punchy doesn't actually have a town role PM. Do you see the logic here?

- - - Post Merge - - -

P.S. please don't copy and paste your own role PM again to prove anything

 

[Ryumia]

To recap, Punchy claimed that his win condition is to "eliminate all hostile parties", when multiple town members have said that their role PMs don't actually state win condition. Therefore it is clear that Punchy doesn't actually have a town role PM. Do you see the logic here?

- - - Post Merge - - -

P.S. please don't copy and paste your own role PM again to prove anything

Mhm... I see. Thanks, Vanessa.

 

[iLoveYou]

To recap, Punchy claimed that his win condition is to "eliminate all hostile parties", when multiple town members have said that their role PMs don't actually state win condition. Therefore it is clear that Punchy doesn't actually have a town role PM. Do you see the logic here?

- - - Post Merge - - -

P.S. please don't copy and paste your own role PM again to prove anything

So then our plan stands. We keep him at a majority of 3 votes to risk the fewest loses possible. It has to be 3 votes because Heyden is a double voter.

 

[cornimer]

So then our plan stands. We keep him at a majority of 3 votes to risk the fewest loses possible. It has to be 3 votes because Heyden is a double voter.

Yup, and he has 3 votes now, so I think we're good so long as everyone co-operates and votes for themselves

 

[amanda1983]

Oh thank goodness neither do I but I was afraid to say anything bc that sounds sus af

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like I thought Tina just messed up when sending me Locket's role PM

Still speed-skimming to catch up asap but oh my ****ing goodness, same here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Though, now I realise I could've just pm'd Tina instead of stressing about it. Huh. My bad.

 

[Ryumia]

Still speed-skimming to catch up asap but oh my ****ing goodness, same here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Though, now I realise I could've just pm'd Tina instead of stressing about it. Huh. My bad.

Glad that you came here, Amanda.

 

[Antonio]

Idk if I can do this but

Since we all got our votes on punchy and there really shouldn't be much discussions till 8PM, would you guys tell me your opinions on the CSS for my discord bot page (Basically the style of the site)? I don't know if this is allowed or not (going off topic, asking for opinions) but just me know if it is.

Link

Again, sorry.

 

[amanda1983]

Glad to see the plan hasn't changed since I left, but colour me *thoroughly* unsurprised that the WIFOM over Punchy seems to still be a thing.

IDK what some people are looking for in the way of a scum-slip, maybe Punchy literally announcing they are Mafia?? But that would of course just get written off as too obvious / a joke / more WIFOM in any case...

As long as Punchy is alive, there is *some* degree of doubt as to his alignment. This is true for any non-confirmed player. But in this particular case the chance of a Town!Punchy is just vanishingly small at this stage (arguably this became true couple scum-slips ago but I try an err on the side of caution wherever possible).

And, to be brutally frank, even if he is somehow Town (which he's not), his lynch is still our best move rn, for a couple reasons :
- the never-ending what-does-his-role-do-and-how-many-players-might-be-killed-by-the-bomb discussion needs to end. It's too distracting, and became circular awhile ago from my PoV. We need to focus on playing the game, not imagining weird game-breaking doomsday scenarios.
- the information we gain from his lynch. There is so much content to analyse as soon as we see the flip, it kind of doesn't matter what the flip even is.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Glad that you came here, Amanda.

I'm sorry I was gone so long, date night with my partner and then some other IRL stuff.. I still haven't slept yet fml

 

[Ryumia]

Glad to see the plan hasn't changed since I left, but colour me *thoroughly* unsurprised that the WIFOM over Punchy seems to still be a thing.

IDK what some people are looking for in the way of a scum-slip, maybe Punchy literally announcing they are Mafia?? But that would of course just get written off as too obvious / a joke / more WIFOM in any case...

As long as Punchy is alive, there is *some* degree of doubt as to his alignment. This is true for any non-confirmed player. But in this particular case the chance of a Town!Punchy is just vanishingly small at this stage (arguably this became true couple scum-slips ago but I try an err on the side of caution wherever possible).

And, to be brutally frank, even if he is somehow Town (which he's not), his lynch is still our best move rn, for a couple reasons :
- the never-ending what-does-his-role-do-and-how-many-players-might-be-killed-by-the-bomb discussion needs to end. It's too distracting, and became circular awhile ago from my PoV. We need to focus on playing the game, not imagining weird game-breaking doomsday scenarios.
- the information we gain from his lynch. There is so much content to analyse as soon as we see the flip, it kind of doesn't matter what the flip even is.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I'm sorry I was gone so long, date night with my partner and then some other IRL stuff.. I still haven't slept yet fml

Mhm... I see. Thanks for the input, Amanda.

 

[cornimer]

##VOTE: Any and all iterations of Punchy

Theory: there are actually 5 different iterations of Punchy and they each make up part of his kracko role
(Ex: Pinchy is a veteran, Ponchy is a time bomb, Penchy is a lover, etc.)

 

[amanda1983]

Idk if I can do this but

Since we all got our votes on punchy and there really shouldn't be much discussions till 8PM, would you guys tell me your opinions on the CSS for my discord bot page (Basically the style of the site)? I don't know if this is allowed or not (going off topic, asking for opinions) but just me know if it is.

Link

Again, sorry.

I think generally this is frowned upon during a game, regardless of how active or whatever things may be. Maybe asking on the discord channel would be better in the future? Just to avoid unnecessary confusion (you've seen how much chaos can erupt seemingly randomly in these games, it's probably best to steer clear introducing something that might lead to issues later on.. like someone trying to build a case against you and citing this as an example of scummy behaviour, for example).

 

[amazonevan19]

Theory: there are actually 5 different iterations of Punchy and they each make up part of his kracko role
(Ex: Pinchy is a veteran, Ponchy is a time bomb, Penchy is a lover, etc.)

But that's just a theory...a GAME theory

 

[iLoveYou]

Theory: there are actually 5 different iterations of Punchy and they each make up part of his kracko role
(Ex: Pinchy is a veteran, Ponchy is a time bomb, Penchy is a lover, etc.)

LOL you made this even better

 

[amanda1983]

Theory: there are actually 5 different iterations of Punchy and they each make up part of his kracko role
(Ex: Pinchy is a veteran, Ponchy is a time bomb, Penchy is a lover, etc.)

Oh my ****ing goodness Vanessa I just started giggling uncontrollably and had to run to the bathroom til I stopped.. it's 5:20am and my partner is a very understanding man who loves me very much but... Ya, he needs the sleep.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyway. I need to vote before I crash. So I'm voting myself, even though it feels so wrong to be doing so. I mean, I understand the strategy, and I'm all for minimising risk whenever reasonable. But to be very clear, I *want* my vote to go on Punchy. Idec anymore what the consequences are from whatever role he does have, should it involve a bomb. I'm sure I'll care as soon as I see the results, of course, but rn I am completely done with this lynch.

 

[Chris]

Do not hijack the thread for your own means.

 

[Ryumia]

I'm sorry I was gone so long, date night with my partner and then some other IRL stuff.. I still haven't slept yet fml

Gasp... :0 I miss this part. I feel bad. :X

Aww... You didn't sleep yet. Hope you get some good rest when you get some sleep. ^ . ^

- - - Post Merge - - -

Mhm... The bottom thing looked weird. :/
It was suppose to be this: ^ . ^

 

[PandaDarling]

WAIT !!!!

why is everyone going crazy.... i don't wanna rush and have all of us die ! lets just collect ourselves for a moment... we still have over 24 hours left of D3 and i still think we should place our votes on Punchy very carefully, seeing as he may be able to impose a lot of damage to us.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

SMH I DIDN'T EITHER. I SAID THAT BC I THOUGHT THAT YOU WOULD THINK THAT IT WAS SUS

- - - Post Merge - - -

ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh

 

[Heyden]

my cursed double vote will get me killed

 

[amazonevan19]

WAIT !!!!

why is everyone going crazy.... i don't wanna rush and have all of us die ! lets just collect ourselves for a moment... we still have over 24 hours left of D3 and i still think we should place our votes on Punchy very carefully, seeing as he may be able to impose a lot of damage to us.

uh wut

we're going through with a plan that could kill, at most, three people. Everyone else is voting themselves

- - - Post Merge - - -

SMH I DIDN'T EITHER. I SAID THAT BC I THOUGHT THAT YOU WOULD THINK THAT IT WAS SUS

- - - Post Merge - - -

ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh ugh

wtf are you talking about