Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[iLoveYou]

im sry im oblivious
i really think that we should nl until we get to a mylo or lylo situation, we really cant afford to miss a lynch so its probabky better for us to get into a situation where we need to lynch than to take a guess

& you're 100% sure that a "no lynch" won't count as a mislynch ?

 

[cornimer]

im sry im oblivious
i really think that we should nl until we get to a mylo or lylo situation, we really cant afford to miss a lynch so its probabky better for us to get into a situation where we need to lynch than to take a guess

If we NL until MYLO then we basically only have one shot though. We have two mislynches allowed currently so waiting untl MYLO/LYLO just makes the situation even worse

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does No Lynch count as a mislynch

 

[EpicGamer12]

The role explained exactly what happened and they were so vague about it. I'm done with mafia

 

[amazonevan19]

im sry im oblivious
i really think that we should nl until we get to a mylo or lylo situation, we really cant afford to miss a lynch so its probabky better for us to get into a situation where we need to lynch than to take a guess

well scum can pick off some peeps and we can PoE it down

but what if scum starts sitting on their kills lmao

I think we should really hunt hard and lynch tomorrow, if it's wrong we start NLing and hunting, if it's right we'll go on from there. We can't afford to not lynch tomorrow imo

 

[N e s s]

im sry im oblivious
i really think that we should nl until we get to a mylo or lylo situation, we really cant afford to miss a lynch so its probabky better for us to get into a situation where we need to lynch than to take a guess

no we're not doing this. I think I might be able to figure the game out with whats been provided so far, so I'll work my ass off tonight to pump out reads. I have at least 4-5 people off the top of my head I'm fairly certain aren't mafia anyway.

 

[Chris]

If we NL until MYLO then we basically only have one shot though. We have two mislynches allowed currently so waiting untl MYLO/LYLO just makes the situation even worse

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does No Lynch count as a mislynch

No. A mislynch would be if a town player died.

 

[illunie]

If we NL until MYLO then we basically only have one shot though. We have two mislynches allowed currently so waiting untl MYLO/LYLO just makes the situation even worse

- - - Post Merge - - -

Does No Lynch count as a mislynch

sry i dont mean straight up mylo, i think the right time should be when we have like 12 players or smth like that, definitely not tommorw tho

 

[amazonevan19]

No. A mislynch would be if a town player died.

thank you. I was gonna say, if town can't no lynch then I may pull a punchy and "MK myself"

 

[cornimer]

well scum can pick off some peeps and we can PoE it down

but what if scum starts sitting on their kills lmao

I think we should really hunt hard and lynch tomorrow, if it's wrong we start NLing and hunting, if it's right we'll go on from there. We can't afford to not lynch tomorrow imo

Yeah even if we use our first mislynch tomorrow, we have more information to base the next one off

 

[illunie]

no we're not doing this. I think I might be able to figure the game out with whats been provided so far, so I'll work my ass off tonight to pump out reads. I have at least 4-5 people off the top of my head I'm fairly certain aren't mafia anyway.

what do we really lose for waiting tho? town players? thats just ppl we could mislynch

 

[cornimer]

sry i dont mean straight up mylo, i think the right time should be when we have like 12 players or smth like that, definitely not tommorw tho

Ah ok I see what you mean

 

[illunie]

well scum can pick off some peeps and we can PoE it down

but what if scum starts sitting on their kills lmao

I think we should really hunt hard and lynch tomorrow, if it's wrong we start NLing and hunting, if it's right we'll go on from there. We can't afford to not lynch tomorrow imo

hey i mean if maf doesnt kill we can bring it to a tie lol

 

[glow]

lmao told u he was telling the truth

he gamethrew by lying about a wincondition he did not have

 

[N e s s]

what do we really lose for waiting tho? town players? thats just ppl we could mislynch

by doing No Lynch every single game until MyLo then we're only going to make things worse. Would you rather have 2 mislynches or only 1 mislynch each day?

 

[amazonevan19]

lmao told u he was telling the truth

he gamethrew by lying about a wincondition he did not have

I think this game is more than sufficient grounds to WOTC Punchy every game from now on

 

[illunie]

by doing No Lynch every single game until MyLo then we're only going to make things worse. Would you rather have 2 mislynches or only 1 mislynch each day?

ppl are gonna die regardless right, whats the point in bringing ourselves closer to losing by killing them ourselves

- - - Post Merge - - -

I think this game is more than sufficient grounds to WOTC Punchy every game from now on

ok thats a little mean, maybe give him a coach or smth tho

 

[Ghostkid]

So im guessing we are gonna no lynch for a couple of days?

 

[N e s s]

ppl are gonna die regardless right, whats the point in bringing ourselves closer to losing by killing them ourselves

you're literally using the argument noobs use of "oh idk if i wanna lynch someone Day 1 bc no info and i don't want any1 2 die!!"

please thats a dumb plan and we're only going to be delaying the game if we do that. We have 2 mislynches, therefore, we have 1 extra chance before it is MyLo every single day. If you wait it out to mylo then we're only wasting that extra chance.

 

[amazonevan19]

maybe we should just scumhunt first then decide whether or not to nl, not argue over whether or not to nl NOW. Cuz obviously if we can't come up with a candidate then we should nl.

 

[amanda1983]

I'm not blaming Tina for this but can we all agree for any hosts in the future to NEVER use that role ever again for a set-up, I mean seriously this is complete bogus. We're being punished for lynching someone who was very clearly incapable of doing anything to help town here other than just spout nonsense every 2 seconds, it made sense to lynch him and now town has been severely damaged for it in a stupidly unfair way.

Agreed.

how horrendously unlucky

...for punchy, cuz he just so happened to guess two of Tom's roles and scumslip in every possible fashion
...for town, cuz Punchy was probably the single worst person to have been given this unbalanced af role

Agreed times infinity.

This game is an experimental set-up from the mind that brought you the Mute City Egg[SUP]TM[/SUP] (2015). It may not be fully balanced and it is requested that you don?t destroy the host in the event things go horribly horribly wrong. That?s her biochemistry professor?s job.

Please note:

• Observers will not go out until Day Three.
  [*]Roles are completely randomised with no human balancing.
• Safe claims have been provided for non-town players.
• Observers will not go out until Day Three.
• Only active notifications will be received, e.g. a roleblock notification will only be received if an action was actively blocked.
• If you ask a question about roles besides your own, and/or anything that could incriminate a player (whether falsely or legitimately), you will always receive the answer ,?I cannot answer that?.
• Observers will not go out until Day Three.

Additional information will be added to this post as necessary.

I think it would be an understatement at this point to say that things have gone "horribly horribly wrong". I don't blame you, and I know I'm not alone there. I do suggest that future games would benefit from some "human balancing", in my personal opinion. In hindsight, the combination of potentially not fully balanced setup + completely randomised roles has led to a completely unbalanced game. But hindsight is good for making things like this clear lol.

: )

- - - Post Merge - - -

i guess the ghosts were the time bomb? even tho it isnt really based on time

I think the so, the ghosts trigger a limit on "time" remaining in the game - we either win quickly (somehow) or else die to MLs or Mafia NKs or some combination thereof.